Just started Thief Gold this morning. Haven't been this excited about playing a game in ages. Thief 2 is one of my all time favourite games, but I never touched 1 so the environments will be mostly all new to me. As for how it holds up, I actually like the way it looks and plays. It's old and it looks it, but it's not off putting. The controls are missing a decade or so of streamlining, but they're manageable. I can't seem to bind crouch to my right control key though, which is a bit irksome. I can bind other controls to that key, but not crouch... [Ninja edit: I can bind crouch to it, but it doesn't actually work]