• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Summer 2012 Anime |OT| Goddesses, canines, and killer MMOs!

Status
Not open for further replies.
Sword of the Stranger
ibfOfKE8U4oghc.jpg
Not bad, but not that great either. It was a lot more brutal than I had remembered. The script is sooooo cliched, though I liked the
drug aspect. I wish it had been expanded upon, since it didn't seem to have any negative side effects apart from dependency.
On a visual level it doesn't look much better than a TV production, particularly the foreground art. The CG was integrated very well I thought, one area where it is much better than a TV production. I really did not like the digital effects (motion blur, snow, smoke, etc.) used during the fights, hampered my enjoyment of them very much so. It's a shame, because the actual animation is quite good. Then there is the sound design, which I thought was too exaggerated.
The kid should have died during this scene, going by the sound effect. It sounded like his head exploded.
The musical score really grated on my nerves, way too pronounced and repetitive. The piece played during the final battle was unnecessary.
 

Branduil

Member
Pretty close-minded, but I'd be lying if I said a visual touch didn't prevent me from enjoying a few things.

It's not just what he looks like, but what he represents.

Also, if any of you guys were still wondering why we keep getting bad CGI anime, just read the ME anime thread in gaming-side.
 

Branduil

Member
A fat nerd?

With a harem.

But it's like Commander Shepard says, nothing is ever simple!

I think I figured out why that trailer is so reminiscent of a bad Saturday Morning cartoon. Not only is it the bland character designs and bad digital effects, but the framing and choreography is very inorganic and simple. Like that shot where the marine is shooting while falling feels like something straight out of G.I. Joe. It feels artificial and forced. I guess what I'm saying is, it all just looks so amateur.

Plus that abominable narration.
 

duckroll

Member
I think I figured out why that trailer is so reminiscent of a bad Saturday Morning cartoon. Not only is it the bland character designs and bad digital effects, but the framing and choreography is very inorganic and simple. Like that shot where the marine is shooting while falling feels like something straight out of G.I. Joe. It feels artificial and forced. I guess what I'm saying is, it all just looks so amateur.

Plus that abominable narration.

I think you've spent more time analyzing it now than they spent putting that trailer together. :)
 

Dresden

Member
As wish fulfillment, I can see how Accel World surpasses it's predecessor SAO. In SAO, the protag is a good looking, athletic guy in real life and his character in the game looks exactly like him! In Accel World, well...

I don't know how. Kirito is Nerd, Middle-School Hei. He's perfect in every single way.
 

madp

The Light of El Cantare
I remember it being more really strange and sad than painful.

I find myself kind of enjoying how unusual it is. It's strange, but there's nothing sad about it--it takes itself seriously but it's just grounded enough that it's still possible to become vested in the events and characters. It's certainly something that could never have been made today.
 

Branduil

Member
I find myself kind of enjoying how unusual it is. It's strange, but there's nothing sad about it--it takes itself seriously but it's just grounded enough that it's still possible to become vested in the events and characters. It's certainly something that could never have been made today.

But it was made less than 5 years ago.
 

madp

The Light of El Cantare
But it was made less than 5 years ago.

I stand by my statement. Whatever market that may have once existed for this kind of anime is gone. It doesn't stop equally-bizarre and niche things from being produced today, but super-niche traditional game/sport series like this that appear to have been huffing the last fumes of Hikaru no Go and its ilk just doesn't really exist anymore, with the possible exception of something like Chihayafuru, which isn't exactly comparable.
 

Thoraxes

Member
E7: AO - 13

AHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH YESSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS

AO IS GONNA MEET HIS DADDY SOMETIME. THAT BASTARD IS ALIVE AND HE'S GONNA BE THERE, AND SHIT FUCK YEAH. EUREKA HNNNNNNNNNNNNN[REDACTED] OH MAH GAWD. I hope Ao learns to play the Johnny Be Good by the time the Enchanted Under the Sea dance happens
 

madp

The Light of El Cantare
The market never existed. I'm sure it was just made to promote the manga.

The manga appears to have been fairly short and ended around the time that the anime began. Is it common for anime to be produced to advertise manga that are no longer in production of new volumes?
 

Regulus Tera

Romanes Eunt Domus
Polar Bear Café 10
Penguin-san with the swag, once again.
Oh poor, poor Handa-san. How do you expect to find love when you are far more interested in the smell of feces? You need to get your priorities straight, sir.

Polar Bear Café 11
Furries within furries. Or, alternatively, featheries within scalies? Whatever this is it was not meant to be and needs to be erased from the Earth asap.
Animal netorare. Or, more specifically, interspecies netorare. Not much Penguin-san can do considering the monstrosity that are testudine cocks, at least when compared to regular avian cloacas. (NSFW NSFW NSFW)
Speaking of visuals not apt for all ages, a weird case of anime not being censored by light beams or rubber ducks. Puni Puni Poemi only ever brought despair to the medium.
Thankfully the focus remains on the family nucleus. It does bring a whole new meaning to the genre of bear porn though...

Polar Bear Café 12-13
The jokes are dumb, the formula is too evident, and the puns are simply worthless due to translation. Regardless, Polar Bear Café is a great cartoon. Nothing pompous despite a few visual gags and just some very strong characterisation that manages to get the show entertaining from beginning to end. I'm sad that so many people seemed to not like it when it first started airing --at least this is the least cynical animu I've watched all year. Simply fun and endearing.

Polar Bear Café 14
Speaking of furries within furries: cosplay. Nothing else needs to be said.
The rest of the episode was just the main trio straight up chillin' in the beach. It's indecent fanservice trite the likes of a haremcrap show would come up during the middle of the season in order to give lagging ratings a boost up. And then there are some cartoons that do two beach episodes in one season (K-ON! YOU ARE A SHAMELESS MONEY-GRABBING SCHEME).

Polar Bear Café 15
Sasako is a real cutie (just look at dem thighs). Rest of the skit was okay.
People have already talked about the second part so whatever. It's just great payoff to a long-running joke which a lesser show would have continued on milking for seasons to come. I wouldn't actually be ashamed of sharing this animu with my family, even!

What a neat cartoon.
 

Branduil

Member
The manga appears to have been fairly short and ended around the time that the anime began. Is it common for anime to be produced to advertise manga that are no longer in production of new volumes?

I have no idea. I would guess it would still be on store shelves, though. And given that this is Studio DEEN, I imagine it wasn't a large financial investment.
 
Cartman-kun is refreshingly honest and a breath of fresh moe air. When every single anime protag is a sterilized Kyon/Kyousuke clone, I'm holding you all responsible!
A fat kid represented as a pig? That's creative.
Keep in mind that he chose that avatar, afaik. The fact that he could have made himself look super badass but instead made himself Porky Pig speaks to how ridiculously self-loathing he is.
So should I give Jinrui another go then? I felt my eyes glazing over when I watched the first episode.
The first two minutes or so are some of the most painful anime I've had to endure, but once it reaches the OP it quickly ascends to godhood. Stick with it.
 

Regulus Tera

Romanes Eunt Domus
Lupin III: The Woman Called Fujiko Mine ep 6 (PRISON of LOVE)

I don't really know why I watched this, but I want to blame Lafiel for mentioning it when I asked what I missed from last season. Anyway, mostly all I can really say is that I forgot how many tits there were on this show, that how was I supposed to know it was about some kind of school infiltration plot-slash-excuse for lesbian hijinx (how??), that it was incredibly awkward to watch with my new roommate around, and that all three of the previously mentioned reactions were probably intimately related. Welp.
Why would you come back to watch this?
Eureka Seven AO 13

TIME TRAVEL THEORY IS VALIDATED

FIRST MENTION OF RENTON'S NAME; HE'S THE ONE WHO BUILT AO'S NIRVASH?!

WHY ISN'T IT NEXT WEEK YET AAAAAAAAAAH

I LOVE THIS SHOW
Welp, I'm glad I dropped this show.
Accel World 8


NO NO NO NO NO

time ingame: about ~8 minutes and the giant mech was pretty fucking awesome
ore no imouto ga konna ni kawaii whatever
 

madp

The Light of El Cantare
I have no idea. I would guess it would still be on store shelves, though. And given that this is Studio DEEN, I imagine it wasn't a large financial investment.

It certainly doesn't have high production qualities. The problem with adaptations of finished manga are that, especially in the instance of something like Shion no Ou where the source material isn't very long to begin with and it's easy to adapt fully within 1-2 cours, receiving a complete anime adaptation seems to defeat the purpose of advertising the manga because there's no further story. BUY THE MANGA endings are pretty effective because they generally end on notes that tease new developments or would otherwise be unsatisfying if they were the actual ending, but no such advantage exists for complete adaptations. It really does seem like there was no good reason for the series to exist at all.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom