• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Summer 2012 Anime |OT| Goddesses, canines, and killer MMOs!

Status
Not open for further replies.
They are not even the same genre. Structurally they could not be more different. Yuru Yuri is a sketch show that you are comparing to a typical narrative flow in K-on that even shows progression across the series. And wow if you really think K-on! made shows about girls in middle school a thing.
Going off the first episode, calling it a sketch show is a stretch. The flow is different, but K-On! was part comedy. Keep in mind I am only talking about the first season.

I'm not saying K-On! was super original or even started a trend.
 

Uchip

Banned
Oh, haha, I know, I saw your posts on it.
I'm working on Wakfu, I swear!

well
if you don't want to watch it all, you can skip the middle ground for both seasons because its mostly filler (albeit above average filler)

iHkK0FvHgdnAD.jpg

im glad you got the joke
was a bit worried that I sounded insane
 

dimb

Bjergsen is the greatest midlane in the world
Femmeworth you are probably one of the many people who didn't get that the first episode/intro of Yuru Yuri is a parody. That is the only explanation here.
 
Femmeworth you are probably one of the many people who didn't get that the first episode/intro of Yuru Yuri is a parody. That is the only explanation here.
Maybe you should have started off with that. I think you all need to be reminded of the wording in my post.
but my initial impression is that it's an inferior version of K-On!.

I may have been jumping the gun, but you guys doing the same damn thing isn't going to help anything.
 

dimb

Bjergsen is the greatest midlane in the world
Maybe you should have started off with that. I think you all need to be reminded of the wording in my post.


I may have been jumping the gun, but you guys doing the same damn thing isn't going to help anything.
I looked up old impressions of the first episode. It's not a great episode, or one that tells you what Yuru Yuri is because it is a parody that most people just take at face value as the opening. Also I must look pretty foolish because even though you think it's K-on Lite I thought it was a rip on K-on.

Your assessment that it wasn't a parody is pretty par from other impressions that found it to be a "generic moe show".
 
I looked up old impressions of the first episode. It's not a great episode, or one that tells you what Yuru Yuri is because it is a parody that most people just take at face value as the opening. Also I must look pretty foolish because even though you think it's K-on Lite I thought it was a rip on K-on.

Your assessment that it wasn't a parody is pretty par from other impressions that found it to be a "generic moe show".
It's all right. I should have watched a few more episodes before even comparing it to K-On!. I didn't mean to start up anything.
 

dimb

Bjergsen is the greatest midlane in the world
It's all right. I should have watched a few more episodes before even comparing it to K-On!. I didn't mean to start up anything.
It was the right comparison to make though from the first episode, and that's what you posted impressions of. I would be more interested in understanding why a large number of people take the opening at face value instead of viewing the events of the opening episode to mock tropes.
 

trejo

Member
Natsuyuki Rendezvous 1-3

Why hadn't I watched this sooner?! Oh my god, this shit is glorious. It's kicking me right in the feels and I am lovin' it!

Best show of the season right here. Don't even feel the need to check out any of the other crap anymore.

Also, Rokka is hella cute.
 
It was the right comparison to make though from the first episode, and that's what you posted impressions of. I would be more interested in understanding why a large number of people take the opening at face value instead of viewing the events of the opening episode to mock tropes.
It was definitely self-aware, I forgot to mention that in my post. I just wasn't sure how far it was going to take that.
 

firehawk12

Subete no aware
But black people would just reject his shots all day. Remember they can't even get through Japanese doors.

Heh, I totally forgot about "Daddy" from one of their earlier games.

Why bother importing players when you basically have the best players in the world living in Tokyo? lol
 
Phi Brain s2 16


We're approaching the tone of the last 1/3 of season 1, which is definitely a good thing. I imagine all the Phi Brain children will get their own episode where they manipulate someone. Then they'll all take matters into their own hands for the final arc.
 

Narag

Member
Metal Skin Panic MADOX-01

This is a 40 minute OVA from 1987 that's about a powered battlesuit being tested by the military that just so happens to fall off the back of a truck and end up in some loser's hands. He tries it on, finds himself stuck in it, and has to fight back against a military that isn't taking prisoners in their pursuit to retrieve the battlesuit. It has some of the ugliest characters I've seen. Story is pretty bad too as the guy just wants to meet up with his girlfriend during all of this.

mt3cil.png

At least the MC has good taste.

Now one might think this is something to be avoided with the above description but, Jebus H Christ, the OVA is a showcase of mechanical & effects animation if I've ever seen one. This is straight up porn for anyone that appreciates such. It's like everything non-character related that could be spruced up with extra animation was done so. Military vehicles like helicopters and tanks are beautiful in this, there's all sorts of hot gadgetry & weaponry in the MADOX-01 suit that's great in motion, and hell, I think there was even an amazing doorknob that was just there and a joy to watch turn.

ZzrnYl.png
ZgzbYl.png

5mkifl.png
airTil.png

4AQzRl.png

I could gif stuff but you know what? There's too much to gif. What a visual treat even if the story was lacking.
 

Branduil

Member
Metal Skin Panic MADOX-01

This is a 40 minute OVA from 1987 that's about a powered battlesuit being tested by the military that just so happens to fall off the back of a truck and end up in some loser's hands. He tries it on, finds himself stuck in it, and has to fight back against a military that isn't taking prisoners in their pursuit to retrieve the battlesuit. It has some of the ugliest characters I've seen. Story is pretty bad too as the guy just wants to meet up with his girlfriend during all of this.




Now one might think this is something to be avoided with the above description but, Jebus H Christ, the OVA is a showcase of mechanical & effects animation if I've ever seen one. This is straight up porn for anyone that appreciates such. It's like everything non-character related that could be spruced up with extra animation was done so. Military vehicles like helicopters and tanks are beautiful in this, there's all sorts of hot gadgetry & weaponry in the MADOX-01 suit that's great in motion, and hell, I think there was even an amazing doorknob that was just there and a joy to watch turn.

And just think, today all of that would be CGI.
 
Phi Brain s2 16



We're approaching the tone of the last 1/3 of season 1, which is definitely a good thing. I imagine all the Phi Brain children will get their own episode where they manipulate someone. Then they'll all take matters into their own hands for the final arc.

i haven't seen this ep , yet but this screen is intresting ..
 

cajunator

Banned
I've seen worse. Like this guy, who has watched the first three seasons of Zero no Tsukaima in their entirety while rating all of them a 3. It's a wonder he never picked up the fourth, really.

He was in it for the Cute. Or maybe the Kugiloli.

Very High
80.7%

High
75.8%

Medium-High
64.3%

Extremely High
87.8%

Very High
84.1%

Medium
51.4%

Extremely High
85.3%

Unknown :(

Somewhat Low
45.0%

Somewhat High
69.4%

Somewhat High
73.8%


Interesting results!

For reference: http://myanimelist.net/profile/moonspeak

65% for yours.

http://myanimelist.net/profile/Cajunator
 

trejo

Member
You guys are just reminding me why I've never bothered setting up a MAL account before.

So many wasted hours I don't want to be reminded of. :(
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom