-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Summer 2014 Anime |OT2| Or, where Jexhius finally watches more Doremi for Hito.
- Thread starter Narag
- Start date
- Status
You forgot Death Scythe...
My main problem with Wing after rewatching it last winter was the politics, they really fall short.
welp...
I didn't even realize there was an apostrophe on the one at #5.
Admiral Woofington
Member
lol wut
like Firehawk said Gintama is like 200+ episodes, FMA is only 60+ if you only watch Brotherhood. Having said that I love them both a lot and will always insist that Gintama is worth the investment. One of the better anime comedies and actually has some really sweet action arcs.
Yeah, but even with the terrible effects, you can still see the extra effort KyoAni puts into their animation. It's like the inverse of polishing a turd.
Antiwhippy
the holder of the trombone
Pretty different series anyway.
Gintama is a gag show except for the occasional serious bits and FMA is a conitnuous storyline with not much deviating it from the original plot.
Gintama is a gag show except for the occasional serious bits and FMA is a conitnuous storyline with not much deviating it from the original plot.
firehawk12
Subete no aware
That's not legal!
My sportsball knowledge is a decade old, but if I had to use basketball gifs to describe Hanamonogatari's climax:
+
Theonik
Member
I might try these out if I run out of anime again. Also the Omake I guess.
'Father has eaten god, we can't do nothing to stop him, we must therefore try to tire him'
Luls, dat poster in the end is sick tho.
The problem with the politics in Wing is that they're UC Politics instead of trying to be their own real thing.
FIVE STAR STORIES
I could never forget that night Narag got me to watch the most BL mecha anime I have ever seen.
foxuzamaki
Doesn't read OPs, especially not his own
huh, interesting
Admiral Woofington
Member
Nozaki-kun 10
After a lackluster episode 9, the series gets back in form in episode 10 and delivers what is easily one of the most consistently hilarious episodes in the series. The movie, Waka's misunderstandings, the singing (and reaction), The Prince being more honest about her feelings, Nozaki's acting, Sakura's reaction to his costume, and finally Mikorin in everything he did (especially the last bit when he was like a scared animal). All brilliant. I straight up laughed. What a great episode. I stopped reading the manga since the anime was starting, but will continue once the anime ends.
Also the sword fighting was surprisingly well done, there goes the budget.
After a lackluster episode 9, the series gets back in form in episode 10 and delivers what is easily one of the most consistently hilarious episodes in the series. The movie, Waka's misunderstandings, the singing (and reaction), The Prince being more honest about her feelings, Nozaki's acting, Sakura's reaction to his costume, and finally Mikorin in everything he did (especially the last bit when he was like a scared animal). All brilliant. I straight up laughed. What a great episode. I stopped reading the manga since the anime was starting, but will continue once the anime ends.
Also the sword fighting was surprisingly well done, there goes the budget.
Five Star Stories
So here's what I really think of it: This was a really good pilot episode to a series that never happened. A lot of what went down in the ending should've at least had a second hour to give it more time to really breath. There were a lot of characters who appeared important but did not pan out, presumably because they were meant to be important much further down the road. The ending to the movie even sets up a series, with its talk of an oncoming war. There's also a distinct lack of the fifth star.
In any case, there wasn't a whole lot of giant robots going on in this OVA, but what there was sure was gorgeous to behold! The animation was all pretty darn good, even if I wasn't at all fond of the character proportions. I was going to say designs there, but honestly the majority of the designs were stupid fun late 80s scifi anime designs and I'll eat that for breakfast.
There was a LOT of androgyny going on, and some of it was built around a clever feint in the plot that, again, would've been better if it had had more time to really come into play. There's an entire subplot about the Emperor and his lover that could be a lot better if only it had sufficient time. There was also a rather notable romantic chemistry between the protagonist, Sopp, and his buddy, Viewlard. I was pleased to find that the show was willing to tease itself for that, and for Sopp's feminine appearance, because it cut that tension to its knees in an enjoyable way. The need to sort of jeer at the thing for the above mentioned is removed when the OVA itself is cracking the jokes. It's a kind of self-deprecating move I wish more anime was self-assured enough to do, honestly.
Would I recommend Five Star Stories? I'm not sure. Not as a mecha anime. It is one, yes, and true to the genre the giant robot does play a sort of key role in being the vehicle through which the protagonist's character and story are told to the audience, yes. It's just that there is only one fight, right at the end. Otherwise mecha are only a driving plot point, rather than an actual function of the show. But if you have an hour to kill, and you like late 80s scifi anime, then I think it'd be worth checking out. It wasn't amazing, but I consider it a fun ride, given the cost of time.
So here's what I really think of it: This was a really good pilot episode to a series that never happened. A lot of what went down in the ending should've at least had a second hour to give it more time to really breath. There were a lot of characters who appeared important but did not pan out, presumably because they were meant to be important much further down the road. The ending to the movie even sets up a series, with its talk of an oncoming war. There's also a distinct lack of the fifth star.
In any case, there wasn't a whole lot of giant robots going on in this OVA, but what there was sure was gorgeous to behold! The animation was all pretty darn good, even if I wasn't at all fond of the character proportions. I was going to say designs there, but honestly the majority of the designs were stupid fun late 80s scifi anime designs and I'll eat that for breakfast.
There was a LOT of androgyny going on, and some of it was built around a clever feint in the plot that, again, would've been better if it had had more time to really come into play. There's an entire subplot about the Emperor and his lover that could be a lot better if only it had sufficient time. There was also a rather notable romantic chemistry between the protagonist, Sopp, and his buddy, Viewlard. I was pleased to find that the show was willing to tease itself for that, and for Sopp's feminine appearance, because it cut that tension to its knees in an enjoyable way. The need to sort of jeer at the thing for the above mentioned is removed when the OVA itself is cracking the jokes. It's a kind of self-deprecating move I wish more anime was self-assured enough to do, honestly.
Would I recommend Five Star Stories? I'm not sure. Not as a mecha anime. It is one, yes, and true to the genre the giant robot does play a sort of key role in being the vehicle through which the protagonist's character and story are told to the audience, yes. It's just that there is only one fight, right at the end. Otherwise mecha are only a driving plot point, rather than an actual function of the show. But if you have an hour to kill, and you like late 80s scifi anime, then I think it'd be worth checking out. It wasn't amazing, but I consider it a fun ride, given the cost of time.
Well that's probably because it's based on a 12(26 for the English versions) volume manga with ludicrous amounts of appendix material.
I agree that Yozora is a jerk for no good reason to everybody.
Watch Haganai. Even with Yozora its still a really good series about friendship.
That definitely explains a significant amount to me.
Sailor Moon Mondays: Sailor Moon Episode 35
Okay, was it just me or were the subtitles hideously desynced? like it took a couple of seconds for some of them to appear on screen and shit like that. Anyway, this is the thrilling conclusion to what amounts to a three part mini-arc that heralds the end of the Zoicite arc, and damnation if these arc shift are not the best of Sailor Moon. I know the first series reveled its zany absurdity but this is one of those shows that could bring the proper amount of dramatic gravitas when the tonality called for it. At any rate, the curtain of exposition is finally delivered and the truth behind everything is revealed, at least what needs to be revealed for this season. Oh special mention need to be placed on Rei for basically redeeming her character after being such a mega bitch for most of the season. Another tip top episode in a series of them, this arc comes with the highest of recommendations. I do wish it was going to last but we have to go back to formula for a measure of time.
Okay, was it just me or were the subtitles hideously desynced? like it took a couple of seconds for some of them to appear on screen and shit like that. Anyway, this is the thrilling conclusion to what amounts to a three part mini-arc that heralds the end of the Zoicite arc, and damnation if these arc shift are not the best of Sailor Moon. I know the first series reveled its zany absurdity but this is one of those shows that could bring the proper amount of dramatic gravitas when the tonality called for it. At any rate, the curtain of exposition is finally delivered and the truth behind everything is revealed, at least what needs to be revealed for this season. Oh special mention need to be placed on Rei for basically redeeming her character after being such a mega bitch for most of the season. Another tip top episode in a series of them, this arc comes with the highest of recommendations. I do wish it was going to last but we have to go back to formula for a measure of time.
Have you watched R?
At this point you're only watching secret anime to drive Survivor nuts.
Sailor Moon Mondays: Sailor Moon Episode 36
Yes indeed we are back to the Monster of The Week business and we begin the Kunzite arc and this time the rationale is while the Dark Kingdom has gained a solider in Endiymion it has lost the Silver Crystal to Sailor Moon and needs to find her.....by launching random ass schemes worthy of Jadite. I bet Quen Beryl regrets not listening to him now. Anyway, while it is good that Usagi is been affected by these recent events, mopey Usagi is not particularly compelling to watch. Anyway, this episode was all about setting up the new arc dynamics, it is worth a watch.
Yes indeed we are back to the Monster of The Week business and we begin the Kunzite arc and this time the rationale is while the Dark Kingdom has gained a solider in Endiymion it has lost the Silver Crystal to Sailor Moon and needs to find her.....by launching random ass schemes worthy of Jadite. I bet Quen Beryl regrets not listening to him now. Anyway, while it is good that Usagi is been affected by these recent events, mopey Usagi is not particularly compelling to watch. Anyway, this episode was all about setting up the new arc dynamics, it is worth a watch.
Psycho_Mantis
Banned
Nah. I could understand if you said FMA was though. Remarkable series.
SliceSabre
Banned
There is another person in the world who loved Heavy Arms Gundam like me.
I feel like my entire existence has been justified.
Theonik
Member
And to drive us to.spam him with Lynne art. Keikaku douri.
You can give it a shot. Might enjoy it.
I told him what it was but he refuses to believe me.
Theonik
Member
This was all part of the plan wasn't it?
Femmeworth
Banned
I have plenty of nostalgia for Wing's designs but I can't agree with this. Maybe if you limit it to AC. Edit: And mix in the Endless Waltz designs.
Personally I'm under the belief no one cares what it is unless it's what they want it to be.
Dedication Through Light
Member
ORECA BATTLE Episode 23 The Evil Vice-Admiral Fisca
First time hearing a name like Johngary in anime. Great episode due to Fisca's strength
First time hearing a name like Johngary in anime. Great episode due to Fisca's strength
and Tide Warrior Flow
Akame ga Kill 9-10
Yes let's try to convince a genocidal general to desert her side and fight for the good guys on your first day together. I picked this up again to see if it got better but the show is even dumber than in the first two episodes. They're even ruining my medieval fantasy with flamethrowers and mecha'esque suits. Not my cup off tea at all.
Sabagebu 10
Another dull episode, I would drop the show but at this point I'll bear with it till the end.
Gekkan Shoujo Nozaki-Kun 10
I wanted the cast getting together and I got it. Good episode even if Seo wasn't at the top of her game.
School Days 01
Time to finally get on this. I think I more or less know what I'm in for but we shall see.
That foreshadowing at the beginning.
Episode was rather dull and the main guy was insufferable but he still got done more in one episode than Raku in twenty. I foresee a great future for him !
Yes let's try to convince a genocidal general to desert her side and fight for the good guys on your first day together. I picked this up again to see if it got better but the show is even dumber than in the first two episodes. They're even ruining my medieval fantasy with flamethrowers and mecha'esque suits. Not my cup off tea at all.
Sabagebu 10
Another dull episode, I would drop the show but at this point I'll bear with it till the end.
Gekkan Shoujo Nozaki-Kun 10
I wanted the cast getting together and I got it. Good episode even if Seo wasn't at the top of her game.
School Days 01
Time to finally get on this. I think I more or less know what I'm in for but we shall see.
That foreshadowing at the beginning.
MikeHattsu
Member
Theonik
Member
Jex
Member
How I see this matter is that if you're watching a Gundam show for pleasure you just kind of have to expect that the writing will be bad, especially if Tomino was involved. The most you can hope for is that the mehca will look cool, that the animation is decent and that there are a few genuinely likeable charatcers. You can't really ask for more then that from even some of the 'best' shows in the franchise.
School Days 01
Time to finally get on this. I think I more or less know what I'm in for but we shall see.
That foreshadowing at the beginning.Episode was rather dull and the main guy was insufferable but he still got done more in one episode than Raku in twenty. I foresee a great future for him !
Like sand through the hourglass so these are the School Days of our lives.
Happy birthday DD!
amishpriest99
Member
Dedication Through Light
Member
DraColle Episode 23
Im enjoying these shows too much hilarious episode because of all the returning characters. Green Pepper Gang folks and then Meatmania's changing of eating choices, lol.
Im enjoying these shows too much hilarious episode because of all the returning characters. Green Pepper Gang folks and then Meatmania's changing of eating choices, lol.
the answer to the quiz, lol, poor Rei!
amishpriest99
Member
It was such a disappointment to me that AGE couldn't even hit that minimum baseline :/.
BassForever
Member
Akame Ga Kill 10
Surprised how quick Tatsumi was able to get back to night raid, though of course the series can't end right away otherwise the scientist dude would just report the base to the other Jeagers instead of doing a solo attack like the next episode teases. Guess Wave is gonna be mind wrecked between now and the next we see him :\
Surprised how quick Tatsumi was able to get back to night raid, though of course the series can't end right away otherwise the scientist dude would just report the base to the other Jeagers instead of doing a solo attack like the next episode teases. Guess Wave is gonna be mind wrecked between now and the next we see him :\
BassForever
Member
Aldnoa NOPE OUT
Fuck this show, it takes a lot for me to want to stop watching a show and they've finally hit that point. This is just the stupid kind of stupid that feels like it's completely wasting my time. Captain Erf was bad because it was mostly boring, Aldnoah Zero is bad because it's just bad. This is a direct to dvd/dumpster movie in the form of an anime with some kind of credentials behind it.
Fuck this show, it takes a lot for me to want to stop watching a show and they've finally hit that point. This is just the stupid kind of stupid that feels like it's completely wasting my time. Captain Erf was bad because it was mostly boring, Aldnoah Zero is bad because it's just bad. This is a direct to dvd/dumpster movie in the form of an anime with some kind of credentials behind it.
Happy Birthday Deputy Dangle!
Gonna be catching up on the anime I missed yesterday (Nozaki-kun and Sabagebu) and keep watching some Lucky Star today. Love these little reference littered throughout the anime haha. Hell I can't believe they even had a Code Geass reference in episode 13. Did not expect that one at all
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lbrZQB4RxOE Sounds like he does some "SCHAAAWING" sound effect XD
Gonna be catching up on the anime I missed yesterday (Nozaki-kun and Sabagebu) and keep watching some Lucky Star today. Love these little reference littered throughout the anime haha. Hell I can't believe they even had a Code Geass reference in episode 13. Did not expect that one at all
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lbrZQB4RxOE Sounds like he does some "SCHAAAWING" sound effect XDamishpriest99
Member
Guess that saves me from needing to watch past the first episode then. Wasn't really enamored with it but thought I might give it a further chance.
I'll never understand why Macross Plus at the very opposite spectrum compared to Stardust Memory about the perception of the story and writing quality.
Stardust Memory deemed as really bad, had offensive character, etc and Macross Plus are hailed as masterpiece and had "Mature" story, both about as offensive to me from what I saw.
Stardust Memory had Infuriating character? Macross Plus had Isamu Dyson and Guld Goa Bowman that despite supposedly filled the adult character role both had mentality of 8 year old, seriously what so mature about this show story when both character act like Tom and Jerry for majority of show? come to think about it they made peace like Tom and Jerry too.
And the show also have one of the most offensive plot point that I seen in fiction, I'm not femmeworth but I can't believe Keiko Nobumoto writing this
here's the plot point:
Even not talking about how classless it is, its so frigging absurd to pass as coherent plot device.
Character Development is non-existent too, at least Stardust Memory not trying to portray their unlikeable character as hero.
Stardust Memory deemed as really bad, had offensive character, etc and Macross Plus are hailed as masterpiece and had "Mature" story, both about as offensive to me from what I saw.
Stardust Memory had Infuriating character? Macross Plus had Isamu Dyson and Guld Goa Bowman that despite supposedly filled the adult character role both had mentality of 8 year old, seriously what so mature about this show story when both character act like Tom and Jerry for majority of show? come to think about it they made peace like Tom and Jerry too.
And the show also have one of the most offensive plot point that I seen in fiction, I'm not femmeworth but I can't believe Keiko Nobumoto writing this
here's the plot point:
Later its revealed Guld's tantrum for the whole show just selective amnesia after tore an young girl cloth, I repeat. SELECTIVE AMNESIA after tore an young girl cloth
Character Development is non-existent too, at least Stardust Memory not trying to portray their unlikeable character as hero.
BassForever
Member
Irregular At Magic High 23
"you can surpass Shiba"
"you can surpass Shiba"
- Status