Chihayafuru 25 - S1 END
My overall feelings about the show are mostly the same as when I first watched it. It starts off very strong, continues pretty well through episode 15, loses a good deal of steam after the recap episode, but manages to recover a little before the end. As a radiant drama that takes advantage of its sparkling aesthetics and superb soundtrack to create a rich mood, it excels. When it goes full tilt into sports anime mode and gets into the nitty-gritty of karuta strategy, it does not. Karuta has more depth than it appears on the surface, but not that much more depth. There's only so many ways to make a karuta match exciting. Plus the overall plotting can be clumsy, particularly in how it handles Chihaya and Tachi's development as players. The way it holds them back from progressing feels artificial, and it's difficult to figure out the course of their development. Compare this to Haikyuu, which does an excellent setting out clear goals for the characters and have them steadily work towards them and in the process steadily improve as individuals and as a team. I suppose the Chihayafuru manga author felt she could mess around since all the main characters are first-years and she still has two more years of high school to move them towards anything. (Theoretically more, since karuta isn't an age-restricted sport, but I doubt the manga will go beyond high school graduation.) That's not a particularly satisfying mode of writing, however. It would be more palatable for the series to flail about on the large scale if the balance of individual events was more tilted in favor of character moments instead of karuta analysis. Even a moment as simple as Kana coming alongside Chihaya reading in the hallway in the final episode can be touching. By contrast, hearing them list off one and two syllable cards for the umpteenth time makes my eyes glaze over.
But despite its obvious weaknesses, Chihayafuru is still a good show overall. I'm not sure how much I'll enjoy the second season, which I haven't seen, but I'll wager there's enough in there to make it worth getting to.