I caught up on Mob Psycho 100. A good decision. Mob was kind of hard to relate to as first but I've turned around on the character. A good rendition of the "I have to hold back so I don't go crazy" archetype. Seeing what he struggles with and what happens to other espers makes his internal struggles believable. Also blah blah animation is amazing blah blah. In terms of pure entertainment, One Punch Man still reigns supreme for me but now I better understand why people like this IP, some more than OPM. I'm also glad the "plot" is finally kicking in and it seems there is a lot of manga material to adapt even if this season ends soon so at least we don't have another situation where season 2 of the anime might be years away ala OPM.
I can understand feeling that way. While you probably already understand this, I'm gonna lay out my preference, because this thread could certainly use more people making the case for
Mob Psycho 100.
There are two basic reasons I think it's a great deal better than One Punch Man.
One is the sense of real emotional stakes. I mean, they're two very different stories, so maybe you could consider this a matter of personal preference. One Punch Man is an escalating series of bigger bad guys showing up to get built up and then shut down by our already-perfectly-unstoppable hero, a comic sendup of all these shows about trying to be the strongest. It's good at what it does, but if it's tearing down the foundation of the genre, Mob Psycho examines how you build up what's left.
Mob is, very intentionally, not a typical protagonist. He doesn't want to be the greatest psychic. He doesn't have big dreams. He just wants to impress his crush by doing something he's completely ill-suited for. Despite his talents, the primary driver of conflict isn't a need to prove himself to others: he has to overcome his own fear and disgust with himself. Those insecurities are very real, very relatable, and touch the whole teenage cast. Everyone's looking for their own identity.
That emotional core provides a really solid foundation for everything that happens. The show may have seemed a little aimless at first, but especially now that it's clear what Mob faces, and how he tries to keep doing the right thing even at the worst times, he's easy to root for.
And it's not just a well-written show, it's also well presented. Pretty much every single segment of this show is lavished with attention. The action draws all the headlines (and deservedly so), but all the "downtime" gets presented with just as much creativity and visual flair. So much gets communicated through what we see, rather than what we hear. Like in recent weeks, the student council president's own
inferiority complex, or Ritsu's
growing guilt and
frustration with
himself. Every element of the adaptation matters, so instead of doing the obvious, Bones has been looking for creative artistic methods that work.
So far for me, this is sitting with stuff like Ping Pong or Flowers of Evil in terms of shows that get pretty much everything right, and as a result stand above their contemporaries.