Antiwhippy
the holder of the trombone
The direction they're heading with Windows Phone 8 is by no means a bad thing. The inability to have older phones run the new kernel is an unfortunate side effect of a necessary upgrade. It's not like an iOS or Android update where new features are added, it's entirely new architecture.
So while it totally sucks for Lumia owners, if it has to be it has to be. Fortunately it looks like they're ensuring this won't happen again with future phones. Saying "it's all bad" is sweeping all of the major improvements WP8 will bring under the carpet and focusing solely on the single major side effect.
I think the "it's all bad" is will being grumpy as usual. I agree that the change for WinMo8 is needed but taking the position that it really sucks for enthusiast of the Windows phone platform who bought the lumia is not exactly invalid.