chickdigger802
Banned
probably wait for brz/frs 2014 too if you are interested. scoobie + toyota should mean it should last a while atm, but hey, first year kinks.
I don't think someone looking at used celicas and camrys are gonna be happy with bmw maintenance cost
Speaking of elantra, genesis coupe is pretty damn popular these days too.
v6 mustang also gives decent mileage.
Along with what Chick recommended:
I don't know if they're "sexy" in your book, but a GTI sounds like it would fit your bill. An E90 3 Series also has fairly decent MPG and is definitely going to be fun to drive.
If you want to head further into MPG country, a more recent Elantra might do the trick. It certainly has curves, but whether those are ugly curves or not is subjective.
I don't think someone looking at used celicas and camrys are gonna be happy with bmw maintenance cost
Speaking of elantra, genesis coupe is pretty damn popular these days too.
v6 mustang also gives decent mileage.