Spoke to State Farm earlier and they informed me that I would have to pay the deductible and if they collect money from the shop I have the possibility of getting the deductible reimbursed. Ugh
Do it. Ask for a check for brand new OEM wheels. They probably cost like $800-1000 EACH from the dealer. Then, take your check, go buy some used wheels for cheap, and pocket the rest.
Laugh at the shop as they get pwned.