Shadows of the Damned is so weird for me. I love it, but am surprised it resonated as well as it did with critics and gamers who usually don't like Suda51's stuff. The game had flaws, and I actually feel I'm more critical of it than most. Not flaws like, 'oh, the big boner level was terrible,' but just some gameplay design and mechanics I feel weren't nearly as tight as they could be, a few sections drag a bit, I found some of the bosses to be huge bullet sponges and not very fun to fight.
But I did actually love it. I love the graphical style, the music, the sort of atmosphere it has going on. I liked Garcia and Johnson as characters. I liked the actually somewhat sad and dark backstory and symbolism of what the game is really about that plays symbolically behind everything else. Quite a few gameplay moments I enjoy, had fun kicking demon ass, reading the story books, and have beat it four times at this point. It's what I would of considered a guilty pleasure if others didn't seem to really like it, but they do which leaves me in a position of liking it but feeling I'm more critical of it than most.
A sequel to this game is one of my biggest never going to happen dreams. I've actually thought Shadow of the Damned 2 with RE6 combat mechanics could be amazing, to replace the broken dodge roll in the first game...