-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
The GAF POP |OT| of Diversity, Hidden Talent, and Stan Wars
- Thread starter Koodo
- Start date
- Status
Phonomezer
Banned
Good GRIEF.
Christopher
Member
My taste are shitty but I will defend my favs!
get that career boost dick demi
The Good Lord above sure knows her ass needs all the career boost dick she can get (and take... LOL).
Also if you're gonna stan for a British boyband, at least stan for the successful one.
Soulscribe
Member
We could maybe just design it so that each person has 10 points to distribute among their faves however they choose. None of us have only one fave so it works out that way. So someone can do this...
And to make it more interesting we all could have 10 MINUS points to take away up to 10 points across the board. That way the ones we really hate get minus'd and thus ridiculed. Xtina fans would probably hate this though, lol.
So then you apply your minus points...
... And then we move on from there. We can have someone moderate and update rankings as people participate, and if people end up wanting to change their distribution they can just make it known and the moderator can change it. If you guys like this idea then I can do it, coz it sounds hilarious.
And to make it more interesting we all could have 10 MINUS points to take away up to 10 points across the board. That way the ones we really hate get minus'd and thus ridiculed. Xtina fans would probably hate this though, lol.
So then you apply your minus points...
... And then we move on from there. We can have someone moderate and update rankings as people participate, and if people end up wanting to change their distribution they can just make it known and the moderator can change it. If you guys like this idea then I can do it, coz it sounds hilarious.
Botty I dont think you want me to start shading Xtina, do you? Not sure why you Xtina stans are trying it with Demi today
Huh...?
Rocket Punch
Member
Welcom new guys/gays!
:O A++
I agree. The cognitive dissonance of the stans cannot be contained with a single chart. Each stan lives in their own fantasy in which their fave is FLAWLESS.
We all know what a chart based on reality would look like:
Get to it gurls
And where is ADELE?
:O A++
I agree. The cognitive dissonance of the stans cannot be contained with a single chart. Each stan lives in their own fantasy in which their fave is FLAWLESS.
We all know what a chart based on reality would look like:
Get to it gurls
Crumpet Trumpet
Banned
And where is ADELE?
#DEATH
I await the chart battles between Blue Ivy and Adele Jr. in 21 years or so.
Crumpet Trumpet
Banned
Um LTTP much?
Her live performances have been awful since LONG ago.
Perry ain't all that talented though I do like her as a person. She seems pretty nice, humble, grounded, and thankful for her success and fans. The accompanying interview on Kimmel is pretty cool.
Phonomezer
Banned
What a boring performance.
Soulscribe
Member
Following Rocket's lead ^_^
And yeah Katy Perry's performances are consistently terrible. I stan only for her as a kickass person and for Teenage Dream. <3
ok some of yall have to many different names in your lists, lets try to list them all and do this
Adele
Azealia Banks
Beyonce
Bjork
Britney Spears
Christina
Carly Rae Jepson
Demi Lovato
Gwen Stefani
Katy Perry
Ke$ha
Kylie Minogue
Lady Gaga
J.Lo
Jessie J
Madonna
Mariah Carey
Marina and the Diamons
Miley Cyrus
MIA
Nicki Minaj
One Direction
Superior Robyn
TRASH Robyn
Selena Gomez
Shakira
The Wanted
quote and add to this list
Adele
Azealia Banks
Beyonce
Bjork
Britney Spears
Christina
Carly Rae Jepson
Demi Lovato
Gwen Stefani
Katy Perry
Ke$ha
Kylie Minogue
Lady Gaga
J.Lo
Jessie J
Madonna
Mariah Carey
Marina and the Diamons
Miley Cyrus
MIA
Nicki Minaj
One Direction
Superior Robyn
TRASH Robyn
Selena Gomez
Shakira
The Wanted
quote and add to this list
Phonomezer
Banned
Oh is it, I never actually bothered paying attention to the lyrics because Wide Awake is shit.
Explains the look on her face at the beginning, I guess. What a mess.
I wouldn't expect a Madonna stan to have an ear for lyrics, but it was indeed a mess.
Christopher
Member
For all the shit I'm getting for The Wanted at least I'm not a Rihannah stan...
Phonomezer
Banned
Ah, dirrty (dirrty)
Filthy (filthy)
Nasty, you nasty (yeah)
Too dirrty to clean my act up
If you ain't dirrty
You ain't here to party (woo!)
Added quite a few more. If this is going to be the definitive list, it must be very inclusive!
Keep it up, keep it up, don't be a pri, hey
Madonna, uh
You gotta get in line, hop
Tick tock tick tock tick tock
That's right, keep it up, keep it up, don't be a pri, hey
Madonna, uh
You gotta get in line, hop
Tick tock tick tock tick tock
yes, its to rate who you stan for in Pop. Which I forgot to include Bieber and JT
Phonomezer
Banned
Some real shit on that list.
Should JT even COUNT? He doesn't have a music career anymore.... literally
Sit, its not finishedI'm probably going to be blasted but that list lacks my canadian punk princess Avril Lavigne. Though I'm probably the only one who likes her here
ETA: And it is missing Dalai Lana, WTH?!
So are people that Icicle listed but they do get brought up and people stan for them
not sure what the limits should be
Soulscribe
Member
I have literally no opinion of most people on that list so I'm gonna stick to the 10-12 people that I've listened to enough to form an impression.
Is this chart about who you stan for?I only PLEDGE ALLEGIANCE and know the careers from the back of my hand of like 5-7 girls like real stanning(Also including Owning every single album, requested their songs on radio, vote for them on any poll,show they are in. Purchased the magazines they were featured in the cover,going to their concerts, purchased/gifted singles, stuff REAL stans do).
I just wanna know the rules. Cause i may like ALOT of other artists and DEFEND them but i cant call and will never call myself a real stan if i only like their music and dont know much else or care about them tbh
my list would be:
Britney Spears
Brandy
Shania Twain
Mariah Carey
Ciara
Rihanna
Lady Gaga
EDIT: And Recently Lana.
Thats all. The rest im only just any other fan.
Perra
Homewrecker-Icia Keys
Skeri BigBird Hilson
Crispy Chicken Wrap J Blige
Ashanti aka Sideburns aka Sideshow Bob
can all have a seat.
I just wanna know the rules. Cause i may like ALOT of other artists and DEFEND them but i cant call and will never call myself a real stan if i only like their music and dont know much else or care about them tbh
my list would be:
Britney Spears
Brandy
Shania Twain
Mariah Carey
Ciara
Rihanna
Lady Gaga
EDIT: And Recently Lana.
Thats all. The rest im only just any other fan.
Perra
Homewrecker-Icia Keys
Skeri BigBird Hilson
Crispy Chicken Wrap J Blige
Ashanti aka Sideburns aka Sideshow Bob
can all have a seat.
I am only allocating a list right now, the idea is to rate them. Obviously who you stan for will have the most points while the lessers will have negative points and for those who you dont care you can just put 0. But its to see what PopGaf likes
I haven't thought about it that far, just making the list atm
I am only allocating a list right now, the idea is to rate them. Obviously who you stan for will have the most points while the lessers will have negative points and for those who you dont care you can just put 0. But its to see what PopGaf likes
I haven't thought about it that far, just making the list atm
i edited my post lol guess you replied before i hit edit. Anyway alright.
YES Kyon stan Shania. In only 4 albums and a Greatest Hits she's sold way more than like 90% of our faves could ever hope to. '
Ciara tho...
ok, thanks. I had never heard of it until this thread.
... What kind of FLOP ADELE stans do we have on this forum?
How come NO ONE has posted that the queen is PREGNANT. This is NOT a FAT JOKE, she has CONFIRMED that she is PREGNANT.
Ivory Blue or whatever the theif's baby name is, is now on notice. ADELE's baby is coming for the top of the charts
How come NO ONE has posted that the queen is PREGNANT. This is NOT a FAT JOKE, she has CONFIRMED that she is PREGNANT.
Ivory Blue or whatever the theif's baby name is, is now on notice. ADELE's baby is coming for the top of the charts
Marius made a thread about it on OT. It seems Adele has been selected to bring forth the second coming, to fight off Beyonce's anti-christ.
Mariah's blessedt twins will probably play a part in this too.
- Status
Similar threads
- Locked
- Locked