Support NeoGAF

HokieJoe · Apr 28, 2008

Emiru said:
Review sites wouldnt do that.

Yeah I know. What was I thinking? ;-)

Dot50Cal · Apr 28, 2008

Dark FaZe said:
So to sum up thread

360: Horrible fucking dog shit with horrible pop in

Ps3: The fucking godly version without flaw

Just wondering. In all honesty what seems to be the verdict at this point? And I hope it comes from someone without bias.

Popup probably affecting both versions, seems to be more prevalent on the 360 version.

tinfoilhatman · Apr 28, 2008

Any word on Dts and 1080i support for the PS3?

MorisUkunRasik · Apr 28, 2008

Slight issues with both versions with the PS3 having a slight advantage, not game crippling

King_Slender · Apr 28, 2008

Nitsuj23 said:
I just have a hard time believing there's pop ins that bad, and they weren't mention in any of the reviews. They said some pop ins, nothing that severe.

We will all have to wait until Monday/Tuesday. Reviewers cannot possibly explore every aspect of the city.

GSG Flash · Apr 28, 2008

I watched the PS3 videos on IGN, and I couldn't tell any difference from the 360 version. If you tried to pass off the PS3 version as the 360 one and vice versa, you would probably get away with it.

Dot50Cal said:
Final one for the night, sign messed me up I was going for the high score dudes!

I think that's the worst one of all of the ones you posted, the sign popped up a long time after you hit it :/

MobiusPigeon · Apr 28, 2008

we need a gametrailers comparison STAT. i may end up with both versions eventually if rockstar doesnt patch it up. This thread IS full of shit tho. Out of all the streams i've watched I havent seen much pop up as bad as these gifs.

Deus Ex Machina · Apr 28, 2008

Emiru said:
I think its dot50cal spreading fud.

I'm with you.. or perhaps his Dev kit is dusty and old lol

Jtrizzy · Apr 28, 2008

Dot50Cal said:
Final one for the night, sign messed me up I was going for the high score dudes.

Damn it was just getting fun.

neptunes · Apr 28, 2008

Remember when this game was slated to launch last october? :lol

yeah....RIGHT!!

the game probably looked like a children's pop-up book.

diffusionx · Apr 28, 2008

If the PS3 version has fake achievements a la Burnout Paradise I'll probably pick that one up.

If it doesn't... I'll probably get the 360 version to be honest.

Yes I am that lame. Truth be told I am also waiting for Eurogamer's comparison.

BenjaminBirdie · Apr 28, 2008

diffusionx said:
If the PS3 version has fake achievements a la Burnout Paradise I'll probably pick that one up.

If it doesn't... I'll probably get the 360 version to be honest.

Yes I am that lame.

We only have one source on that. And they're...a bit....cylon...y.

Death Dealer · Apr 28, 2008

mintylurb said:

The path of the righteous man...

65536 · Apr 28, 2008

Dot50Cal said:
Popup probably affecting both versions, seems to be more prevalent on the 360 version.

Well to be fair, you are making the assumption that it isn't going to be that bad on PS3 as well, for all we know it could be identical.

No matter which version turns out to be the best, in the end, we all lose. If the game was PS3 exclusive it would have been better than what we've got now.

Swifty · Apr 28, 2008

If the pop-ins are as bad as 50Cal is showing us, then there shouldn't be so many 'tards on the live streams asking if the player is playing the 360 or the PS3 version since it should be easy to tell.

Flunkie · Apr 28, 2008

neptunes said:
Remember when this game was slated to launch last october? :lol

yeah....RIGHT!!

the game probably looked like a children's pop-up book.

I can has pop-up book plzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz?

Karma · Apr 28, 2008

diffusionx said:
If the PS3 version has fake achievements a la Burnout Paradise I'll probably pick that one up.

If it doesn't... I'll probably get the 360 version to be honest.

Yes I am that lame. Truth be told I am also waiting for Eurogamer's comparison.

Gamesradar says no achievements for the PS3 version.

MorisUkunRasik · Apr 28, 2008

andrewfee said:
Well to be fair, you are making the assumption that it isn't going to be that bad on PS3 as well, for all we know it could be identical.

No matter which version turns out to be the best, in the end, we all lose. If the game was PS3 exclusive it would have been better than what we've got now.

All reviews so far have said this, he is not assuming anything.

Dot50Cal · Apr 28, 2008

Deus Ex Machina said:
I'm with you.. or perhaps his Dev kit is dusty and old lol

Its a falcon. Just got it replaced earlier in the month due to the old workhorse finally giving in:

Yoboman · Apr 28, 2008

Emiru said:
I think its dot50cal spreading fud.

You would think that

2real4tv · Apr 28, 2008

neptunes said:
Remember when this game was slated to launch last october? :lol

yeah....RIGHT!!

the game probably looked like a children's pop-up book.

:lol

h3ro · Apr 28, 2008

Dot50Cal said:
Popup probably affecting both versions, seems to be more prevalent on the 360 version.

Just couldn't keep away could ya...

Odrion · Apr 28, 2008

I want someone to put a blinking "10.0" in this gif.

clav · Apr 28, 2008

Dot50Cal said:
I give up.

Night, Gaf.

Wait... that's a dev kit?

Those are just two power cables unless I'm not seeing the black SATA cable.

Dot50Cal · Apr 28, 2008

h3ro said:
Just couldn't keep away could ya...

I have a terrible stomach ache

I can't sleep.

HaloFans said:
Wait... that's a dev kit?

Those are just two power cables unless I'm not seeing the black SATA cable.

Sidecar isn't on, just the usual hard drive.

segarr · Apr 28, 2008

Dot50Cal said:

IGN:"10" :lol

MercuryLS · Apr 28, 2008

andrewfee said:
Well to be fair, you are making the assumption that it isn't going to be that bad on PS3 as well, for all we know it could be identical.

No matter which version turns out to be the best, in the end, we all lose. If the game was PS3 exclusive it would have been better than what we've got now.

We all win actually cause everyone with a X360/PS3 can play it if they so choose.

Raistlin · Apr 28, 2008

Nitsuj23 said:
Is this a pirated copy?

Review copy.

dfyb · Apr 28, 2008

andrewfee said:
Well to be fair, you are making the assumption that it isn't going to be that bad on PS3 as well, for all we know it could be identical.

.........most comparisons have already said otherwise.

Deus Ex Machina · Apr 28, 2008

Dot50Cal said:
Its a falcon. Just got it replaced earlier in the month due to the old workhorse finally giving in:

Why does it look beat up? and look at the nasty stains..

MercuryLS · Apr 28, 2008

segarr said:
IGN:"10" :lol

Oh for fuck sakes, the pop-in isn't that bad playing off a disc. I don't know how many times I and many others who've played it have to say this.

If it was that bad you'd better believe that it'd be mentioned in every review.

Dot50Cal · Apr 28, 2008

Deus Ex Machina said:
Why does it look beat up? and look at the nasty stains..

The loving embrace of a careless intern does wonders for exterior cases

Loudninja · Apr 28, 2008

Deus Ex Machina said:
Why does it look beat up? and look at the nasty stains..

Why do you keep asking these questions?

Yoboman · Apr 28, 2008

Deus Ex Machina said:
Why does it look beat up? and look at the nasty stains..

That's his old one

BenjaminBirdie · Apr 28, 2008

Deus Ex Machina said:
Why does it look beat up? and look at the nasty stains..

And yet through all those years of wear they couldn't take two seconds to take off the InfraRed plastic.

(It took me a few months too.)

Firewire · Apr 28, 2008

Dot50Cal said:
Final one for the night, sign messed me up I was going for the high score dudes!

what the hell!

Raistlin · Apr 28, 2008

andrewfee said:
Well to be fair, you are making the assumption that it isn't going to be that bad on PS3 as well, for all we know it could be identical.

So the reviewers were simply lying?

Karma said:
Gamesradar says no achievements for the PS3 version.

And again ...

... a company rep stated they are adding in stuff for home.

Dot50Cal · Apr 28, 2008

Loudninja said:
Why do you keep asking these questions?

Because I'm saying things he doesn't like :lol

I'll give the disc a whirl, see if I encounter similar issues.

Deus Ex Machina · Apr 28, 2008

Dot50Cal said:
The loving embrace of a careless intern does wonders for exterior cases

I see some good size nicks on it.. meaning its been drop a few times.

Odrion · Apr 28, 2008

Well thank you Dot50Cal, you have helped me decide which version.

I doubt it's not too terrible, but if I have a PS3 I may as well use it.

Pachael · Apr 28, 2008

Dot50Cal said:
Final one for the night, sign messed me up I was going for the high score dudes!

Car Vault!

Yoboman · Apr 28, 2008

Loudninja said:
Why do you keep asking these questions?

Obviously, dot50cal has PURPOSEFULLY SABOTAGED HIS XBOX 360. If only he had the credibility around these parts of Deus Ex Machina and Emiru - then we might take him seriously

darkressurection · Apr 28, 2008

Deus Ex Machina said:
Why does it look beat up? and look at the nasty stains..

That is the one he replaced, don't any of you people know how to read?

Deus Ex Machina · Apr 28, 2008

Yoboman said:
That's his old one

Which one is he doing these gif. off of?

Beer Monkey · Apr 28, 2008

segarr said:
IGN:"10" :lol

If only games without glitches are eligible for a 10, I doubt we'll ever see a 10 again.

Regardless, isn't a '10' score supposed to reflect the relative quality of the gameplay experience, and not technical perfection?

Evlar · Apr 28, 2008

Deus Ex Machina: Maybe his dev kit is old and dusty lol

<Dot50Cal posts pic of RROD dev kit which is in fact dusty and old>

Deus Ex Machina: WTF why is it old and dusty? lol

clav · Apr 28, 2008

Odrion said:
Well thank you Dot50Cal, you have helped me decide which version.

I doubt it's not too terrible, but if I have a PS3 I may as well use it.

You haven't seen anything from the PS3 pop-ins.

Jtrizzy · Apr 28, 2008

Thanks for the gifs, If you can't sleep, just do more

Deus Ex Machina · Apr 28, 2008

darkressurection said:
That is the one he replaced, don't any of you people know how to read?

Would you shut the hell up! no one lives in this thread except you.

mintylurb · Apr 28, 2008

beermonkey@tehbias said:
The eyes. :lol

Actually, the original picture is still one of my fav from that stomc site. Here it is:

Support NeoGAF

The GTAIV Comparison Head-to-Head Thread Episode V: An Epic Tale of ManBoobs and Woe

Member

Banned

all of my posts are my avatar

Member

Banned

Nobody ruins my family vacation but me...and maybe the boy!

Banned

Member

Member

Member

Gold Member

Banned

Member

Banned

Member

Banned

Banned

Member

Banned

Member

Member

Member

Banned

Member

Banned

Member

Banned

Post Count: 9999

Banned

Member

Banned

Banned

Member

Member

Banned

Banned

Post Count: 9999

Banned

Member

Banned

Member

Member

Banned

Member

Member

Banned

Member

Member

Member

Member

Similar threads