About six hours in, here are some quick impressions:
+ Visuals and animations are second to none on consoles, particularly character models (the way the eyes look and move in this game is unreal)
+ Best voice acting ever, in any video game, and honestly some of the most real performances I've seen in any medium (film, TV, cartoons, whatever)
+ Artistic design and detail in the world is astounding
+ Fantastic writing, compelling story, amazing characters
+ So much tension around every corner
+ Soundtrack and music cues are sublime
+ Movement feels responsive and weighty
+ Sound is fucking impressive
+ Combat is great thanks to great stealth and powerful weapons
+ Love the minimal interface, the inventory, and how difficult and unrelenting Hard mode can be
- Controls can be wonky, and I've found myself fumbling with my inventory a number of times leading to my death
- Slight pacing issues in the first couple hours
And that's it.
Game is superb so far. Such a cohesive experience with INCREDIBLE characters. I really do love Joel and Ellie, and even other minor characters because the performances are so real, so believable, and the animations to complement them are just impeccable.
Game is giving me heavy Resident Evil 4 vibes.