Just got done with this today. I was a first time player of the game period, and I was left with a fairly positive feeling about it. I'm not over the moon about it like some, but it's a good change of pace for Naughty Dog, and odd rendering glitches aside, it's certainly a very good remaster in terms of performance and IQ.
Story-related stuff:
Story-related stuff:
I felt like that Winter and Spring felt rushed, at least in terms of trying to move stuff along. I don't think it helps that they felt a bit samey in terms of gameplay design (quiet intro, followed by an infected bit, then a short "playable" section that felt more like a glorified cutscene, and finally, fun with hunters), so it sticks out. I wish there was a bit more time spent in those, perhaps cutting down on the stuff in Summer, since that overstayed its welcome after you got done with Nolan North's Tricky Trap Town. Fall felt like the strongest part of the game to me, even though I think it's time for Naughty Dog to stop using the "slow walk through a peaceful area that you will soon go back through in reverse while in combat" trope, although to their credit, it's really, really short compared to other games.