platypotamus
Member
traveler said:Looking at picking up something more thematic. How is Dungeon Lords? I love the concept and the presentation looks slick; it just seems like one of those games that could have a definite best strategy that, once you have figured out, you could always stick to.
I loveeeeeeeeee Dungeon Lords. Haven't really found an optimal strategy, because the monsters, rooms, and adventurers are randomized each game, you've really got to adapt to what's facing you. Sure, some monsters are more powerful than others, but you just might not be able to get the one you want because an opponent gets there first, or it might be weak against the adventurers coming your way (Vampires are great unless you've got a couple priests coming at you). A pretty heavy worker placement kind of thing, great theme, and pretty, can't recommend it enough.
(One negative: Playing with less than 4 players involves a kinda of kludgey "fake player" mechanic, but it still works and is pretty fun)
I'm also considering Dixit and Arabian Nights, but they seem like pure theme and very little game. Could still be fun.
Haven't played Arabian Nights, though I think Astrolad loves it. I love Dixit. It's perfect for playing a more social gaming night rather than strategic, and it's great for more casual players. My wife, who hates being creative or pretending still really loves it, and I've played with both super serious hardcore gamers and very casual, English-second-language people, even at the same time, and we all had a blast. We want expansions/sequel even.
Lastly, Descent and RuneWars look pretty amazing, but they're fairly expensive, look pretty daunting to newcomers, and seem like they'd require lots of setup.
I played the hell out of Descent and some of its expansions. It is about as fiddly of a game as you can possibly imagine, and setup will literally take an hour. The Overlord (DM) we played with had a sewing kit or fishing tackle box that he used to keep all the bits in, which helped, but it was still a lot of set up, and a lot of rules look ups as we played. Still, pretty fun for people that want a dungeon crawl experience without the extra pain of the pen and paper RPG.