The Kindle app has had a white text on black background mode (called Black) and Sepia since launch (or at least since I got it for my iPhone). The iBooks app just got night mode in the iOS5 update.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
The new iPad |OT|
- Thread starter 3N16MA
- Start date
The Kindle app has had a white text on black background mode (called Black) and Sepia since launch (or at least since I got it for my iPhone). The iBooks app just got night mode in the iOS5 update.
Searched for 'e-ink', 'e-reader', 'strain'; no dice.
So I decided to do my own (secondary) research:
In 2000, a study in Industrial Ergonomics showed that light reflection and polarization played a large role in eye fatigue. Their results show that glossy screens are more likely to cause fatigue than matte screens.
In 2004, a study published at International Display Workshops found no difference in eye fatigue between e-ink and printed paper.
In 2006, a study from Duke University published in Radiation Imaging Physics argued that one cause of eye strain is from a process called luminance adaptation (this may not be the primary source for this theory). In a nutshell, it suggests that using an LCD in a dimly lit room causes eye strain by this mechanism. LCD's in brightly lit rooms (or ambiently lit screens like e-ink) would not cause strain by this mechanism.
A 2009 study published in Displays showed no statistically significant difference in subjective reports of eye fatigue among 48 participants when comparing two different e-ink displays to paper; this study also compared resolutions of 800x600 and 640x480 and showed that although visual performance increased (finding a specific symbol in a string of letters), there was no effect on eye fatigue. This suggest that "Retina" displays probably won't make much difference in terms of fatigue.
I did not find any studies that compared e-ink to LCD for eye fatigue.
Based on what I did find, I would tend to believe that e-ink devices would cause less eye fatigue than the iPad for the following reasons:
1. e-ink devices always use ambient lighting, so there is no luminous adaptation required.
2. e-ink devices use matte screens, whereas the iPad uses a glossy screen.
It does seem that you can accommodate your iPad use to mitigate these effects if you only read in brightly lit rooms and position yourself to minimize screen reflections.
Still, I would be interested to see an actual study comparing the two technologies head-to-lead using identical lighting conditions and tests that were more akin to the practical application (i.e. reading a chapter of a novel).
Felix Lighter
Member
I honestly can't think of a feature iBooks could offer that is more important than having the ability to read your books on almost any platform.
Baconsammy
Banned
iBooks sucks for mainstream books. It lacks the selection of Amazon/BN and limits you to only reading them on Apple devices. Sepia started with the Kindle app, not iBooks. Avoid buying books from Apple unless you absolutely have to.
I can only recommend the one I'm currently using: This one
I got it because it's:
1- light
2- protects the entire device without sacrificing access to any of the inputs/buttons/cameras
3 - is cheap but very well made
4 - retains the magnet-based functionality of the official Apple covers (turns on/sleeps the iPad when opening and closing
I think the reason for that was because of the tsunami in Japan, which caused shortages in chips used by the iPad 2. That's why there was no preorder back then.
Nah, wasn't iPad 2 a 7x increase in gpu? So iPad 3 is 14x iPad 1. That should be plenty for general use.
Infinity blade 3 might need to compromise but I think iPad 1 res upscaled would be fine for the kind of game that would benefit from more polys and more shaders rather than resolution
I wish they'd deliver Thursday. As it is you'll get it sometime during Friday, which is later than many buying at retail.
The iPad Is Unbeatable (Slate article): http://www.slate.com/articles/techn...y_parallels_its_unbeatable_ipod_success_.html
I thought this was an interesting look at things, sorry if posted already.
I thought this was an interesting look at things, sorry if posted already.
Baconsammy
Banned
I'm buying books, not an app though. The ability to read my books on any device/computer that I want trumps any advantages the iBooks app has.
Great, thanks for responses guys. I can't wait to check this out on Friday.
shrimpjive
Banned
Unless Apple was able to predict tsunamis a year ago, there is no way that is true. The tsunami hit Japan on March 11th--the same day the iPad 2 released.
Aruarian Reflection
Chauffeur de la gdlk
What's a good place to look for iPad case reviews? Macrumors has an entire forum dedicated to accessories but the users seem so neurotic I feel like I'm visiting AVS for TV advice
Baconsammy
Banned
Clearly iPad causes tsunamis.
CharminUltra
Member
Not if you couldn't care less about other devices or reading books on your desktop, laptop, toaster, fridge etc.
The one big flaw of iBooks is book selection, which sucks at the moment. If Apple fixes this someday, I will gladly jump into the e-book reading bandwagon.
Until this happens, I'll be sticking to real books. I don't plan to waste money supporting crappy tech like e-ink.
Baconsammy
Banned
Dont look now, but I think there's some kids playing on your lawn.
CharminUltra
Member
Says the fan attached to devices that suck hairy monkey balls when it comes to reading comics, magazines and reading without a light
The_Inquisitor
Member
Huh? Just use the kindle app on the iPad if selection is your concern.
My grandfather has stacks and stacks of books overflowing in his house. When he picked up the iPad on my recommendation he was incredibly relieved to no longer have to carry around so many books in his travels.
dskillzhtown
keep your strippers out of my American football
My Fedex tracking numbers for my 2 orders (one for me+gf) are still not showing any results despite me getting the shipment email on Saturday.
I'm scared
It is going to sit at Fedex for a few days until the 16th anyway. I am in the same boat as you with the tracker. But then again the Fedex tracker has something that I got delivered to me on Friday still on the truck.
The_Inquisitor
Member
Which is true for now. Most of the books I want to read I already have in .txt format. Plan is to just upload the files into iTunes and make some directories.
CharminUltra
Member
Bingo.
Dreams-Visions
Member
pretty good read.
IMO, the more powerful certain applications get, the scarier tablets will become. Limitations on productivity/output are a function of the limited features of the core productivity applications that I've seen on the platform (like iWork).
If MS ever releases Office for tablets...with near-full or full features of their desktop counterparts...the laptop market will become very interesting indeed. Looking at all the apps I have installed, and outside of Adobe, Visual Studio and Office stuff, I do nothing productive on my computers. Pro-grade software Adobe stuff will probably never be doable with resistive touchscreens...but fully-appointed Office and Visual Studio on tablets would be huge.
unless Amazon is interested in losing sales, that app is being given all manner of attention right now.
PrimaNocta
Member
Question, Do Apple Smart covers fold all the way behind the iPad so I can still lay it flat on a table? Interested in getting Incipios hard cover case but i'm not sure if the smart covers will fold over the back with a hard case attached to it.
As for the book selection issue, while Amazon has more of a selection iBooks is constantly improving. When I have a book I want to read thats on Amazon but not iBooks (far more rare now then last year) I just buy it on my Macbook and format it into a epub and send it to iBooks.
Yes I have to go through the process of changing the kindle book to epub but it is worth it for the far superior reading experience and options that iBooks provides.
Yes I have to go through the process of changing the kindle book to epub but it is worth it for the far superior reading experience and options that iBooks provides.
This is a joke right?
See, now you make me undecided again about what to do lol. I'm about to buy The Way of Kings this week and I want to take advantage of that retina display!
Can you use Calibre to do this for books purchased from Amazon or only unprotected files?
I don't get why Kindle doesn't have the option for changing font. It seems like such a small thing but it makes a huge difference. Being able to pick out your own font for your books is a great little tool.
You have to download software that can remove DRM (plenty of free software out there) first but it's pretty simple.
Speaking of which, it's odd that you can just pick any font you want. It's good to give the user control, but it seems like authors would want to set a typeface appropriate to whatever they're presenting.
Baconsammy
Banned
Says the fan attached to devices that suck hairy monkey balls when it comes to reading comics, magazines and reading without a light
Because actual comics, magazines and books are great without light? I personally dont read comic books, so that's not an issue, but my daughter reads a lot of books that have pictures and those are much better on the iPad than on the Kindle. The Kindle, however, is far superior for my "mainstream" books.
Kindle is not device specific either. The iPad gets heavy when you want to read for an extended amount of time. With the Kindle reader that never happens. And you can read your books on both devices! Plus your phone or through the web app at your machine. At some point soon the Kindle App will be updated too, so the Retna thing will be a moot point.
Of course, this decision is all up to you
I just know I love my reading situation. Kindle on the beach/bed/night/day (With a slip light). iPad if I am on the couch and just feel like browsing a book for a bit, or read a magazine.Jill Sandwich
the turds of Optimus Prime
Oh 'eck, just called the Apple Store I'm going to be queuing like an idiot at. They say 8am launch.
I'm going to need a flask.
I'm going to need a flask.
D
Deleted member 22576
Unconfirmed Member
8am?
I guess that works out well for me.
I guess that works out well for me.
Ken Masters
Banned
can't wait for this thread on friday, but will be torture until the 23rd when I get mine
Mine is still processing. I ordered Friday night. I wonder how accurate this is. Granted I have an iPad 2, so it's not supper pressing. Although my wife may say otherwise. Haha.
Personalized iPad with Wi-Fi 64GB - Black (3rd generation)
Ships: by March 19
Delivers Mar 19 via Standard Shipping
Personalized iPad with Wi-Fi 64GB - Black (3rd generation)
Ships: by March 19
Delivers Mar 19 via Standard Shipping
Baconsammy
Banned
Smart covers can fold behind the iPad, or fold up into two different positions to allow for typing or video viewing.
Always go with the solution that provides you the most reading options. And right now that's Amazon. iBooks may be a better app in some regards, but it doesn't have enough plusses to counter Amazon's huge advantage of a much larger library and a much larger array of options on which to read your purchases. I also doubt that Apple has a means by which you can let people borrow your books, but if they do I'll gladly stand corrected.
jts
...hate me...
23rd for me too, but I'm taking a break from GAF and all the tech news until I get mine. I want a fresh experience dammit!
