After many years of soldiering along, my ATH-A700 closed backs finally bid me farewell as the joint holding the left cup in place cracked and crumbled. Budget was pretty tight, but I managed to convince my family to go along with some Fidelio X1s to replace them since Amazon was having a fire sale to clear stock for $188.
Having spent a week with them... I'm really underwhelmed. It's a huge step back in almost every department from my previous pair, from comfort to sound quality. The cups place a ton of pressure on my head, which makes them extremely fatiguing to wear. I wouldn't mind this so much if the sound was up to snuff, but it lacks clarity on instruments with a disappointingly small soundstage. Some of my favorite little details in songs I could hear cleanly with my ATH-A700s are now so buried with the X1s that I have to strain myself to hear them if they can even be heard at all. Once a song becomes even remotely busy, the drivers give up entirely on stereo width and focus themselves into a muddy mess.
I'm not sure where to go from here, since most of the other options that were competitive with these were $100 more than what I can pay for. It just feels weird to finally get these in my hands only to find out they're nothing like what reviews and opinions led me to believe. Nice bass, but far too lacking in clarity for me to be happy with them.