omg rite said:
Then I guess Radiohead stopped being a rock band for a little while, eh?
(And no, I'm not comparing Kanye to Radiohead. But enough with the "OMG HE'S IN THIS GENRE. HE MUST ALWAYS STAY IN THIS GENRE" crap mindset.)
Deciding to sing more than rap on a specific album, as an experiment, does not make you any less of a "rapper".
Okay, the album isn't going to be for everyone. Obviously. Be happy he'll have a new album in June and pretend this one doesn't exist. Many others will enjoy it for what it is.
Well, I don't listen to Radiohead so I can't really talk about em, but if Radiohead's new album was all rap, well, I wouldn't necessarily say they were a rock band. Also if Led Zeppelin's first two albums were gangsta rap, I'm pretty sure I'd still consider them a rock band.
I guess my mentality is whatever theyre currently doing defines them. By no way is that a bad thing. If Kanye suddenly wants to start a metal band and scream in it, I don't think I'd still call him a rapper. But I can understand where someone might find flaw in my logic.
However, just cause he's experimenting doesn't mean his songs can't be shit. Robocop is garbage. Heartless is alright. Buuuuuut, Love Lockdown and Coldest winter are fucking great.