The Order 1886 Review Thread

Status
Not open for further replies.
I really don't understand people who feel the need to take offense to numbers they don't agree with. I almost hope this game doesn't perform well critically just so we get more Uncharted 3 levels of meltdowns. I had no idea up until a week ago that The Order had any sort of following at all.
 
1237811334_crying-in-the-audience.gif
 
can we add robert florence's joke review please. i think it'll lighten things up a bit, and it make a good point about some of the more silly people out there.

here you go
 
fantomena said:
Reviews for this game will be so insanely polarizing. It will get 4/10s, 9/10s etc.
Click to expand...

This really wouldn't surprise me.

I expect around a 75 on Metacritic.

Day one regardless of reviews. Read some impressions in that other thread, seemed decent enough to me.
 
IKizzLE said:
Reviewers have been taking AAA games this generation to task.

Infamous Second Son: 80
Watch Dogs: 80
Wolfenstein: 79
Evolve: 79
Destiny: 76
Dying Light: 73
DriveClub: 71

I mean 80 on metacritic is like the sound barrier no one can break.
I will be pleasantly surprised if The Order breaks 80.
Click to expand...

That Driveclub score is absolutely crazy bad for how top tier the game is. Agreed on Second Son tho. It felt the weakest out of all the Infamous games, despite more powers. SP best villain is still Kessler.
 
I'm far more hyped for this thread once the reviews hit than I am for the game itself. Thursday can't come soon enough!
 
High 70s or Low 80s. I'm calling it now.

I'm also calling more than 1 reviewer shitting because of what it's not, rather that what it is. Sadly, that seems to be the crux of all video game reviews nowadays.
 
This game will probably end up at around 65 on metacritic. Initial sales will be decent because of all the promotion, but legs will be extremely weak because the game has practically no replay value and is really short in the first place. I will be surprised if Sony will actually fund a sequel. There is a good chance that this will be Ready at Dawn's last console game.
 
Dawg said:
How is jeuxvideo able to break so many embargoes? Not the first time this has happened.
Click to expand...

Nirolak said:
It's a magazine so they have to print and ship it.
Click to expand...

Yes, people shouldn't be confused between "jeux video magazine" and "jeuxvideo.com" (which is solely a website), they're 2 different entities (not that either is particularly worthy of interest tbh).

Also, JeuxVideoMagazine is hosting a "master class" (public conference of some sorts) with the studio's co-founder on thursday evening in Paris, so I guess they're really confident that it's ok to post the review, they wouldn't want to piss him off so close to the event :P
 
Scrulox said:
This game will probably end up at around 65 on metacritic. Initial sales will be decent because of all the promotion, but legs will be extremely weak because the game has practically no replay value and is really short in the first place. I will be surprised if Sony will actually fund a sequel. There is a good chance that this will be Ready at Dawn's last console game.
Click to expand...

I personally think it's the beginning of the end for the PS4. Hell, consoles everywhere.
 
Scrulox said:
This game will probably end up at around 65 on metacritic. Initial sales will be decent because of all the promotion, but legs will be extremely weak because the game has practically no replay value and is really short in the first place. I will be surprised if Sony will actually fund a sequel. There is a good chance that this will be Ready at Dawn's last console game.
Click to expand...
...there's something to be said here.
 
I-hate-u said:
That Driveclub score is absolutely crazy bad. Agreed on Second Son tho. It felt the weakest out of all the Infamous games, despite more powers. SP best villain is still Kessler.
Click to expand...
That DC score is crazy weird for a lot of reasons. When the reviewers played it, it probably deserved higher. But if they had actually waited like they should have, it would have gotten even lower because of server things. And if they were to update their score (which, if we're keeping scores around, I wish more reviewers would do), it would probably be higher because of the many patches and improvements.
 
bananafactory said:
Damn. Oh well, look forward to hearing your thoughts on Thursday =)
Click to expand...


It's like can we take anyone's opinion seriously about this game now. We are claiming reviewers will be swayed by the craziness on gaff. Could other people be swayed to say they like it because they think it's getting a bad rap? It's all crazy over here
 
bananafactory said:
Isn't this a good review?
Click to expand...

we should wait for a consensus, unless this one review is really good. Since i can't read french, and since no one here can really either since this is a north america forum, we should at least wait till another review pops up before passing judgment because no one can confirm if it's really good or not.
 
IKizzLE said:
Reviewers have been taking AAA games this generation to task.

Infamous Second Son: 80
Watch Dogs: 80
Wolfenstein: 79
Evolve: 79
Destiny: 76
Dying Light: 73
DriveClub: 71

I mean 80 on metacritic is like the sound barrier no one can break.
I will be pleasantly surprised if The Order breaks 80.
Click to expand...

Far Cry 4 is 85 on PS4 and 82 on Xbone, but you're right it's more an exception.
 
haven't been keeping up with this game... but why is this such a hot game on gaf?

Just seems like your typical 'launch era game', pretty with standard safe gameplay. Is it just because it's ps4 exclusive?

Was Ryse a hot topic back then?
 
goldsoundz said:
I really don't understand people who feel the need to take offense to numbers they don't agree with. I almost hope this game doesn't perform well critically just so we get more Uncharted 3 levels of meltdowns. I had no idea up until a week ago that The Order had any sort of following at all.
Click to expand...

I wouldn't hope a game critically fails just to witness some silly reactions. That seems kind of selfish.
 
Mifec said:
No I asked him if he considered the game AAA, if so it's an AAA game that got more than 80 :D
Click to expand...
I just used the those examples to make a point that reviews are harsher thus gen than last. Of course there are games that broke 80 thus gen, it's just fewer than the same time last gen. No game on ps4 or One that isn't a rerelease has broken 90.
 
This is going to be one entertaining thread. It'll be interesting comparing reviews/thoughts to my own after I play the damn thing.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads

The Knightling | Review Thread
1
168
Gamer_By_Proxy replied
Hades 2 | Review Thread
Review  2 3 4
178
697
HYDE replied
Dying Light: The Beast | Review Thread
Analysis Review  2 3 4
164
1K
Alpha Male replied
Cronos: The New Dawn | Review Thread
Analysis Review  2 3 4
158
2K
Minari replied
Trails in the Sky 1st Chapter | Review Thread
Analysis Review 
14
350
Thief1987 replied
Top Bottom