The Order 1886 Review Thread

Status
Not open for further replies.
Freedom = $1.05 said:
you know, if you guys are really upset about that spoiler then maybe common sense would dictate that you shouldn't quote the spoiler since that's going to spoil it for more people. you know, you're making it worse or something.

It's also not really a spoiler but i guess i don't know where that line is drawn anymore.
Click to expand...

Yeah it's not really a spoiler in anyway, it's not like he stated what was being reused and everything.

I wanna do a different predicition, screw predicting review scores, I wanna guess how big this thread is gonna end up lol. I say 70 pages at 100ppp, shit we already at Page 7 in like an hour with 1 review!
 
Supermanisdead said:
11 minutes of QTEs is pretty long, imo. QTEs usually go like 10 seconds or something. Having 11 minutes of them, plus 2 odd hours of cutscenes in a 7~ish hour game is bad.
Click to expand...

I don't mind some QTEs, and cutscenes, but I hope it is more than just 7 hours long.
That sounds just as short as SSO campaign, and this is a linear game, so there won't be much to do after you complete it.
 
The suggestion that a boss encounter features animations of any quality isn't a spoiler unless you subsequently turn it into one.
 
Snoogans2you said:
Pics or GTFO
Click to expand...
j8lQ2ZHl.jpg
 
Elandyll said:
Wonder what will happen to the Tomb Raider thread though, and the (imo legitimate) bad feelings about its exclusivity.
That one will probably need some "extra tight" modding I'm guessing :)
Click to expand...

If any reviewer gives Tomb Raider a higher score than Uncharted 4 there will be Twilight Princess level riots.
 
Percy said:
You find it more understandable for people to be emotionally invested in seeing a game do badly than for them to be invested in seeing it do well?

That's kind of messed up tbh.
Click to expand...

What I mean is that being a cinematic game (and an exclusive) I understand why people will be jerks and want it to fail.

But being a new IP, nobody has any prior history with it and thus shouldn't be that invested in it being good.
 
7 hours from first review makes me somewhat relieved. I'm getting it no-matter what but hopefully the 5 hour trolls will back off a tad
 
I'm burning through the posts yeah!
Two hundred pages comin
That's why they call me Galahad the Knight!
This review threads traveling at the speed of light!
Bish gonna make a supersonic ban out of you
 
People seem to think that low scores would cause the most meltdowns. But I think there's more people expecting/wanting failure than those expecting/wanting success.

Feels like this thread's fate is already written.
 
Incase you can't tell from my post history, I think this game is going to be gud.

Has a review thread ever made it to a second thread?
 
sinnergy said:
Metroid Zero mission could be finished in about 3 hours, was srtill a great game, it's the feeling that you have left when you are finished that matters...
Click to expand...
Most of the cases people are willing to forgive, fairly or not, tend to be very dense, highly fun games, even at $60 (see: Metal Gear Rising or Bayonetta.) Doubly reinforced with the angle of replaying to master, but man I think MGR was enough of a thrill at $60.

This one sounds like it's OK shooting with a good story, and I prefer to get those for cheaper. It's also why I
 
Elandyll said:
I expect Bloodborne's review thread to be pretty epic, but nothing like UC4 will probably be (along Halo 5 that is).

Wonder what will happen to the Tomb Raider thread though, and the (imo legitimate) bad feelings about its exclusivity.
That one will probably need some "extra tight" modding I'm guessing :)
Click to expand...

Oh yeah. Uncharted 4 vs. Tomb Raider vs. Halo 5 is going to be interesting™
 
Elandyll said:
I expect Bloodborne's review thread to be pretty epic, but nothing like UC4 will probably be (along Halo 5 that is).

Wonder what will happen to the Tomb Raider thread though, and the (imo legitimate) bad feelings about its exclusivity.
That one will probably need some "extra tight" modding I'm guessing :)
Click to expand...

THOSE XBONERS WILL PAY IN FORUM BLOOD FOR WHAT THEY TOOK FROM ME!

Not really lol. I mean ya, it is legitimate to be mad about the exclusivity, but at Squeenix not at Microsoft. They just took the smart deal and now have a game to go up against Uncharted. A better game maybe, as I thought Tomb Raider did Uncharted better than Uncharted.
 
Always-honest said:
I don't know ofcourse. But i also see no reason to post it in this thread.
Click to expand...

It's a thread that's supposed to be about the quality of the game. People have said they were disappointed by that, so it's completely relevant in this thread. I'm going to take an early guess and say that lots of reviews are going to have complaints about it being anti climactic.
 
Elandyll said:
I expect Bloodborne's review thread to be pretty epic, but nothing like UC4 will probably be (along Halo 5 that is).

Wonder what will happen to the Tomb Raider thread though, and the (imo legitimate) bad feelings about its exclusivity.
That one will probably need some "extra tight" modding I'm guessing :)
Click to expand...

Bloodborne's review thread will be epic from all the circle jerking (probably well deserved lmao)

U4 and Halo 5 I agree but the "sense" of anticipation in a weird way won't match The Order I think. More positivity for those games.

TR will be interesting like you say, the salt from exclusivity will maybe mean some want it to fail I guess :/
 
Seventy70 said:
It's a thread that's supposed to be about the quality of the game. People have said they were disappointed by that, so it's completely relevant in this thread. I'm going to take an early guess and say that lots of reviews are going to have complaints about it being anti climactic.
Click to expand...
I haven't played the game yet. Now i don't want to anymore.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads

The Knightling | Review Thread
1
168
Gamer_By_Proxy replied
Hades 2 | Review Thread
Review  2 3 4
178
675
HYDE replied
Dying Light: The Beast | Review Thread
Analysis Review  2 3 4
164
1K
Alpha Male replied
Cronos: The New Dawn | Review Thread
Analysis Review  2 3 4
158
2K
Minari replied
Trails in the Sky 1st Chapter | Review Thread
Analysis Review 
14
348
Thief1987 replied
Top Bottom