• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

The XXII Sochi Winter Olympic Games / Ski And Skate Against Hate

Status
Not open for further replies.

Parch

Member
Swiss and Japan flying. I though Hiraoka had the best run.

Silly judged sport so subjective. Never did care for it.
 

fuenf

Member
He is the best. And the snow is crap. But the others managed just fine and deservedly won the medals.

yep. Vancouver was far more exciting then this event, IPOD almost single handily saved the competition but imo these whole Olympics have an rather amateurish feel about them.
 
"Extreme" sports are entertaining to watch but it is a bit lame that the very best in the world still fail to land clean runs a lot of the time (at least in these Olympics, land a clean run and you are top 5 guaranteed almost)
 

Blader

Member
"Extreme" sports are entertaining to watch but it is a bit lame that the very best in the world still fail to land clean runs a lot of the time (at least in these Olympics, land a clean run and you are top 5 guaranteed almost)

The halfpipe is apparently very sloppy.
 

GSG Flash

Nobody ruins my family vacation but me...and maybe the boy!
iPod had a really clean run, unlike Shaun. If Shaun White didn't clip the deck, he might have medal'd.
 

zroid

Banned
"Extreme" sports are entertaining to watch but it is a bit lame that the very best in the world still fail to land clean runs a lot of the time (at least in these Olympics, land a clean run and you are top 5 guaranteed almost)

I believe the thing is they all know if they don't push their skill to the limit, they aren't going to get on the podium. So people will wipe out since they're not playing it safe, it's just the nature of the competition.
 

Parch

Member
"Extreme" sports are entertaining to watch but it is a bit lame that the very best in the world still fail to land clean runs a lot of the time (at least in these Olympics, land a clean run and you are top 5 guaranteed almost)
Yeah. At least slopestyle has specific elements plus speed and danger. More technically judgeable.
Halfpipe sucks. It's way too sloppy and subjective.

If they wanna add X Games stuff, add races, not judged events.
 

lamaroo

Unconfirmed Member
Potentially stupid question, but why does ski jumping even have judges?

Couldn't they just judge based on the distance they travel? Why does everything need style points?
 

Ulumsk

Member
Yeah. At least slopestyle has specific elements plus speed and danger. More technically judgeable.
Halfpipe sucks. It's way too sloppy and subjective.

If they wanna add X Games stuff, add races, not judged events.

There's also boardercross later. I agree with your sentiments on judges though. The scoring in the men's slopestyle was sloppy and soured the event debut imo.
 

Irminsul

Member
Couldn't they just judge based on the distance they travel? Why does everything need style points?
Otherwise, everyone probably would just try to near-crash as far as possible. By having to land correctly, this behaviour is mitigated.

Also: tradition.

I guess.

Seems like the only one being able to judge landings is the guy from the country the landing's name comes from. Figures.
 

GSG Flash

Nobody ruins my family vacation but me...and maybe the boy!
Potentially stupid question, but why does ski jumping even have judges?

Couldn't they just judge based on the distance they travel? Why does everything need style points?

I agree, style points in ski jumping sounds really stupid.
 

lamaroo

Unconfirmed Member
Otherwise, everyone probably would just try to near-crash as far as possible. By having to land correctly, this behaviour is mitigated.

Also: tradition.

I guess.

Seems like the only one being able to judge landings is the guy from the country the landing's name comes from. Figures.

Well you'd obviously have to land on your skis, add a line somewhere down the hill you need to cleanly pass.

It's like adding style points to long jump in the summer olympics.
 

Irminsul

Member
Well you'd obviously have to land on your skis, add a line somewhere down the hill you need to cleanly pass.
Well, yes, but you can get much closer to a crash by just having to land on your skis than by having to correctly "stand" your landing.

Okay, COME ON NOW CARINA! FLIIIIIIIEEEEEG (as they say in Germany)!
 

GSG Flash

Nobody ruins my family vacation but me...and maybe the boy!
Well, yes, but you can get much closer to a crash by just having to land on your skis than by having to correctly "stand" your landing.

Okay, COME ON NOW CARINA! FLIIIIIIIEEEEEG (as they say in Germany)!

I would think losing your life would be a good deterrent to not do crazy shit...
 

Parch

Member
The scoring in the men's slopestyle was sloppy and soured the event debut imo.
Yeah, men's board slopestyle judging seemed weird. The women's event judging seemed more logical.

The ski slopestyle seems OK, but when they lose speed somewhere it almost guarantees that they're not going get enough distance to land the last jump and just crash. That's a pretty dumb and unsafe part of it. Interesting event to watch, but not a really great olympic event.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom