Edmond Dantès;171964630 said:There is a rather interesting essay posted on TORn; the Silmarillion as a film trilogy.
http://www.theonering.net/torwp/2015/07/11/98552-an-essay-the-silmarillion-as-a-trilogy/
Some interesting points, but without a primary protagonist from the outset, not really viable. And again, people will ask, but where are the Hobbits? Why should I care about mystical elves and unapproachable humans?
IMO his only decent suggestion comes at the very end where he suggests looking to the MCU for inspiration. The outline he provides is not really a movie trilogy, and the idea for the third film in particular is absurd. But one could envision a Silmarillion meta-series sorta like the MCU where you have a series of films tracing the Princes of the Noldor through the Great Battles of Beleriand, a series (or multiple series) of films tracing the great heroes of the Edain, and potentially stand-alone films for other characters/groups, all of which interconnect and appear in each other. I honestly thing this would be a better approach than the HBO series option that gets floated a lot these days (thanks to GOT), since modern premium cable drama series often look for a core, driving plot, which The Silmarillion doesn't really have.
I mean, in my ideal world The Silmarillion wouldn't be adapted for the screen at all, but I see this as the least bad option were an adaptation inevitable (which thankfully does not seem to be the case).