How dare you move SAO up!
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Toonami |OT8| Our Summer War Game
- Thread starter Seda
- Start date
- Status
How dare you move SAO up!
BassForever
Member
More like
Top tier:
Fma brotherhood
Flcl
Soup eater
High tier:
One piece
Gits
Inuyasha
Mid tier:
Naruto
Clone wars
Low tier:
Bleach
Igpx
Garbage tier:
Sao
Based upon general group reactions to each show, one piece should move up and soul eater should move down in a few months though
Not sure if lazybones18 likes SAO enough to move it up, or just really hates Bleach to isolate it.
BassForever
Member
If you want a tier list based upon overall quality of the show it'd be different
lazybones18
Banned
Subjective, but I wouldn't mind to see your thoughts..
BassForever
Member
It'd be hard for me to make such a list as one piece, igpx, and sao are the only shows I've seen to completion. To post my personal rankings on the quality of all the shows I'd need to watch every episode of each show. Posting ratings on what I've seen so far doesn't really work as a show could get better or worse, and some shows I've marathoned to catch up (naruto and inuyasha) and others I haven't (bleach and brotherhood). Based only upon what I've seen on toonami one piece would be low tier cause only the past few weeks weren't painful foxy arc or filler and op would/should be top tier on any overall quality list.
Gucci Messiah
Banned
FOOLS! This is the true tier list:
MCXC God Tier
Bleach
Lamborghini Mercy Tier
Big O
Ghost in the Shell
Soul Eater
One Piece
SBT
FMA Brotherhood
Not bad if you're shitfaced Tier
Naruto
Deadman Wonderland
Inuyasha
FLCL
IGPX
Bebop
Only fox could enjoy this trash Tier
Casshern Sins
Samurai 7
So bad Shard won't even bitch about it Tier
Thundercats
Clone Wars
GXP
Kick-Heart
Sword Art Online Tier
SAO
MCXC God Tier
Bleach
Lamborghini Mercy Tier
Big O
Ghost in the Shell
Soul Eater
One Piece
SBT
FMA Brotherhood
Not bad if you're shitfaced Tier
Naruto
Deadman Wonderland
Inuyasha
FLCL
IGPX
Bebop
Only fox could enjoy this trash Tier
Casshern Sins
Samurai 7
So bad Shard won't even bitch about it Tier
Thundercats
Clone Wars
GXP
Kick-Heart
Sword Art Online Tier
SAO
lazybones18
Banned
Casshern Sins and trash do not go together!
Gucci Messiah
Banned
BassForever
Member
Samurai 7, Casshern Sins, SBT, GXP, Eureka 7, and Deadman Wonderland. I will eventually watch all these shows to rank them in my new toonami show rankings. Blundercats I'll just put in don't care tier
Doctor Decimate
Member
so how long will it take Clone Wars for people to admit it's not as bad as a handful of episodes are? it took IGPX about a season.
BassForever
Member
Gucci Messiah
Banned
Clone Wars is terrible, that opinion isn't changing
I've never seen SAO, what is it that makes it so bad?
How MikeMyers Tiers Toonami Shows
Top Tier
InuYasha
Low Tier
Everything Else
How MikeMyers Tiers Toonami Shows
Top Tier
InuYasha
Low Tier
Everything Else
Schadenfreude
Member
What he said. I'll always find it boring.
foxuzamaki
Doesn't read OPs, especially not his own
Alright alright
thetechkid
Member
You guys are tearing this family apart with your ratings!
We love our family no matter what. We don't abandon them, that's Gokus job.
foxuzamaki
Doesn't read OPs, especially not his own
Gucci Messiah
Banned
If a show fails to capture my attention after being given numerous chances then yes, it is terrible
foxuzamaki
Doesn't read OPs, especially not his own
I;m still new to the clone wars show with the exception of seeing a random episode or 2 (that happen to be a really well loved episode btw) and some stuff on youtube(like the fight thats in that gif) I think you wouldnt be saying this in the later seasons. The only thing im not sure of is when everyone started universally loving clone wars. But it just gets better as it goes on.
Doctor Decimate
Member
if you didn't like the episode with the clones trapped in the base i don't even know what to say.
Gucci Messiah
Banned
If you're still new to the show, how would you know I'd like later seasons?
Bad writing, weird pacing, GOD AWFUL ART, and a lack of believably all make me hate Clone Wars. I mean yeah, it's a show that has aliens wielding swords of light in space but there's just so much BS that sucks me out of the experience and reminds me I'm watching a show. For example, why does everyone have terrible aim? Seriously, that pisses me off to no end.
Doctor Decimate
Member
.....because it's Star Wars?
BassForever
Member
I take it you've never seen the star wars movies before, or you're not a fan of them.
grandjedi6
Master of the Google Search
Clone Wars, like most shows, gets better as the seasons go on.
That's because Bones can't write interesting original content, even if it's life depended upon it.
Soul Eater is already feeling flatter than it used to. Such a shame. Performances are still great but the writing is beginning to fade
That's because Bones can't write interesting original content, even if it's life depended upon it.
I can't wait to get to Hinata 2.0.
Probably one of the very few side characters who gets significant development in the second half.
Wake me up when we get to the sith and the bounty hunters season. I mostly remember season 1 being boring.
Is JB and all other characters introduced from here on out officially in the manga or new storyline?
Gucci Messiah
Banned
I've seen them all multiple times but "because it's Star Wars" isn't an excuse I can accept.
Doctor Decimate
Member
So in other words it's fine in the movies but not in the show...because
Gucci Messiah
Banned
Doctor Decimate
Member
then what? all you keep doing is giving vague answers to this topic.
BassForever
Member
Your problem with the art being crap I'll give, the style does suck and I hate it. Complaints about the writing or action don't work cause its the exact same or better then the 6 films. If you want to say the art style is so awful it ruins the show then fine, but not the action or story.
Doctor Decimate
Member
i think the pacing is a legitimate complaint as well, but beyond that i agree. and i would say the pacing really isn't too huge of a deal in the grand scheme of things since it's basically a choice between what they're doing now or having the characters talk to each other about exactly the same thing at the beginning of the episode.
Seda said:
....which is honestly pretty sad now that i think about it.
Those will continue to be the best episodes as will the ones that are predominately about Obi-Wan.
I feel like this is going to be the case, yes.
Gucci Messiah
Banned
I don't hate Clone Wars like GXP or anything but I don't think it's a good show. Just my opinion.
Lol no you can't just dismiss my complaints about the writing by claiming it's on the same level as the films, that's completely subjective. I didn't say the action was bad, just that there are things that pull me out of being immersed.
Lol no you can't just dismiss my complaints about the writing by claiming it's on the same level as the films, that's completely subjective. I didn't say the action was bad, just that there are things that pull me out of being immersed.
Doctor Decimate
Member
X-Bone takeover
Gucci Messiah said:
Star Wars is hardly renowned for its compelling dialogue. it's really not at all a stretch to say they're on the same level, better at times and worse in others. hell, i'd ask the people who disagree with this to remove their nostalgia goggles. if you wanna say the events of the films manage to overshadow the mediocre writing, fine. but that's different.
Gucci Messiah
Banned
- Status