• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

True Detective - Season 2 - We get the Season we deserve - Sundays on HBO

Velcoro himself says that if Antigone hasn't heard the stories about him by now that she would soon. Made it seem like pretty common knowledge.
 
Can any one explain the porn scene that Mcadams watch?
HBO Asia remove that part and I can only hear the sound of the moan.

Just her surfing some hardcore (and maybe BDSM?) porn sites.

All I got from that scene is that she is a normal human being and she is into porn.

Yeah, I didn't care for that scene. I suppose it's supposed to be her "damage", with her swinging back whiskey and surfing hardcore porn.

Would most of you be upset/annoyed if the Colin scene was a fake out? As I said yesterday, much of the talk is around how ballsy the decision was. How shocking it was to kill off a lead that early etc.

My speculation (I haven't seen the next ep promo, btw): it's someone related to the investigation that wants to "keep it unsolved" or whatever. That's why I think it's just rock salt--it's supposed to be a warning.
 

Bloodrage

Banned
SPOILER:

If you were in the other thread and saw the set pictures it's obvious he isn't dead unless they cut out a lot of scenes that showed him in totally different settings that haven't been shown yet in the first two episodes.

/SPOILER
I pointed this out earlier and my posts were deleted. Also watch the trailers in the OP. Everyone already forgot what was in them. He's alive.
 

aravuus

Member
Feel like it's a parody of True Detective at this point. Writing and delivery has been so off for me.

Yeah, it's really not doing anything to me right now. If Ray really is dead, I'll stop watching for now and (try to) binge watch season 2 at a later date when I'm hungover or bored or just have a lot of time to kill.

If Ray is alive, which I'm hoping for, I suppose I'll keep watching weekly. Not like there's anything else going on right now.
 

KingKong

Member
It's pretty clear from the way it's filmed that he's not dead. If they were to kill off a major character like that they'd show it, he just looked knocked out. Did we even see any blood?
 

mre

Golden Domers are chickenshit!!
Hell, even he isn't ignoring it when asked point blank lol
I mean, Semyon (Vaughn) and the Vinci city folks (Mayor, police chief, etc.) don't ignore it, they all revel in the fact that he's corrupt, and use him to intimidate a reporter. The state police wants Kitsch and Rachel McAdams' character to get close to him and see just how bent he is as part of their investigation.
 

Mononoke

Banned
I would be annoyed that they went for a 'shock' cliffhanger like this in the first place. That's usually a hallmark scene the writer is on fumes.

Yeah. At least for me, a fake out cliff hanger is usually, kind of a cheap way to shock your audience IMO (although that hinges on the execution of it). It also makes the cliff hanger and scene feel lesser in hindsight. So I've never been a big fan of writers leaning on these kind of narrative decisions.

On my Twitter feed, I saw people losing their minds after the episode aired. I can't help but think that most of these people will be mad if it ends up being a fake out. I was just asking since I've seen a lot of posts in this thread saying they believe the character is really dead. And lot of it is about how gutsy the decision was.

I also think people have a lot of expectations for this show and are always assuming extreme things. Like Piz is subverting everyone's expectation and all of this was a distraction from what the real season is about etc.

My speculation (I haven't seen the next ep promo, btw): it's someone related to the investigation that wants to "keep it unsolved" or whatever. That's why I think it's just rock salt--it's supposed to be a warning.

I've also stayed away from any spoilers including promos. Great point/speculation. That makes a lot of sense! Wouldn't be surprised if that is what it ends up being.
 

Mononoke

Banned
Seems like universally, people don't like Vince Vaughns character. I wonder what the show could do at this point to save that character. I was really hoping that Vaughn would have nailed this role (or that the character would be more interesting). I guess we have plenty of room left for them to do something. But it seems like most just don't like that character.

I have to say, I am glad they went with Rachel McAdams and Colin Farrell. For all the issues I have with the season so far, I am starting to dig these characters.
 

Catdaddy

Member
That opening VV was painfully long. I guess my main problem with VV is I don’t think I’ve seen him in a dramatic role, if I did was forgettable. So seeing remembering him as a wise-cracking clown and then moving into this isn’t very convincing to me, also he doesn’t have the best writing.
 

Theorry

Member
I think we see a more intresting character when he goes abit crazy. And it looks its going that way more.


Btw really a shame HBO doesnt do a "Inside the episode" for this serie.
 

labx

Banned
Wow... Still waiting for ep. 4 to pick it up, but man, so mixed reviews of the show. TD, is becoming the show that everybody loves to hate.

I wonder IF the fate of Matthew McConaughey would have been different -Not getting the Oscar or Golden Globe-, Sesason 1 would have so much praise.
 

Bloodrage

Banned
Wow... Still waiting for ep. 4 to pick it up, but man, so mixed reviews of the show. TD, is becoming the show that everybody loves to hate.

I wonder IF the fate of Matthew McConaughey would have been different -Not getting the Oscar or Golden Globe-, Sesason 1 would have so much praise.
I wonder if people would have liked the show at all if it weren't for Matthew McConaughey's character.
 
The scene with Kitsch breaking up with his gf was just god awful. Both the acting and the dialogue, my god it sounded like a soap opera that kept going with zero emotion at all.

That said, loved the episode overall and it really started to pick up from a pretty weak intro. I like how Farrell got it out in the open that he's dirty and they don't want the case solved. Could be an awesome dynamic if he is going to start trying to be a decent person again and uses his shadyness for the good of the case.
 

see5harp

Member
Man Colin slipped with the accent like 3 times just in that one scene with his ex-wife. Wasn't super distracting since every other part of the performance was solid. Like what I'm seeing thus far. I think the VV monologue went on for way too long. Despite enjoying the series thus far, I sorta feel like Justin Lin was wasted on these setup episodes.
 

coleco

Member
I wonder if people would have liked the show at all if it weren't for Matthew McConaughey's character.

Very good point. He kinda tied up the show and somehow was in tune with many parts of the series: the narration, the story, the mood, even the scenery.

The case investigated in season 1 was ok but nothing special.
 
Two people talk, one drinks, the other stares at the wall. At the end of the discussion one of them gets up and exits the room, the other person asks a question or says something about the one going out who says a smart one-line and finally goes out leaving the reamining person driking or staring at the wall.

True Detective 2.
 

Con_Smith

Banned
I think people are selling VV short. His character seems like a underworld guy who got screwed over by the corporate folks. He isn't some untouchable gangster but he doesn't seem like a complete push over either. Going back to episode one after watching two makes him a lot more fleshed out than I previously thought.

That "We're not gangsters" line felt like a slap on VV face, letting him know Corporate world plays by a whole nother set of rules and you just got your cash ganked to me. Can't wait to see Vince break start digging into people to get his money and information. I won't be one of the ones hot in the ass to dismiss this season, as even season one took a good three episodes to wheel me in and I'm enjoying the ride so far.
 

kingocfs

Member
Two people talk, one drinks, the other stares at the wall. At the end of the discussion one of them gets up and exits the room, the other person asks a question or says something about the one going out who says a smart one-line and finally goes out leaving the reamining person driking or staring at the wall.

True Detective 2.

Cut to overhead shot of LA highways
 

AlphaSnake

...and that, kids, was the first time I sucked a dick for crack
Woodrugh was at a hotel across from a gas station after getting into an argument with his GF.

You see a couple people walking drunkenly through the station, one couple wearing rainbow fur boots, and another getting out a car(presumably is a male prostitute)

It's definitely a prostitute. He was counting money as soon as he stepped out of the car.
 
[KoRp]Jazzman;170294807 said:
The scene with Kitsch breaking up with his gf was just god awful. Both the acting and the dialogue, my god it sounded like a soap opera that kept going with zero emotion at all.

On the plus side, that scene just confirmed to me that Adria Arjona is, in fact, the most beautiful woman in the world.

Two people talk, one drinks, the other stares at the wall. At the end of the discussion one of them gets up and exits the room, the other person asks a question or says something about the one going out who says a smart one-line and finally goes out leaving the reamining person driking or staring at the wall.

True Detective 2.

Cut to overhead shot of LA highways

Yup. The pieces are "there" but they're not working.

I've also stayed away from any spoilers including promos. Great point/speculation. That makes a lot of sense! Wouldn't be surprised if that is what it ends up being.

There's also the thing where, really, if he wanted to kill him, he's lying on the ground, immobile. Why shoot him in the gut? Shoot him in the head.
 

Dan

No longer boycotting the Wolfenstein franchise
I think some of the comments about the dialogue is hyperbolic. I'm not sure season one was always so brilliant, we were just generally more into what those characters were saying.

I think the show is struggling to manage to four POVs, especially with a plot that involves relatively complicated machinations of finance, land deals, local governments, multitudes of agendas, etc. It's hard to pull all that off on anything more than a surface level.

Can any one explain the porn scene that Mcadams watch?
HBO Asia remove that part and I can only hear the sound of the moan.
As that scene initially unfolded, I was wondering if she was searching for her sister.
 

Dan

No longer boycotting the Wolfenstein franchise
My speculation (I haven't seen the next ep promo, btw): it's someone related to the investigation that wants to "keep it unsolved" or whatever. That's why I think it's just rock salt--it's supposed to be a warning.
I was kinda thinking it might be the opposite, someone who DOES want this investigation to get closer to something. Velcoro is checking this place out quietly on the down low. This stranger causes a big fuss so that the house doesn't go unnoticed by official law enforcement channels, and injuring Velcoro may also serve to sideline him for a bit so the investigation can get moving without his interference. The latter would make sense for why this person doesn't just phone in a tip or something to bring police to the scene. Two birds, one stone.
 
I was kinda thinking it might be the opposite, someone who DOES want this investigation to get closer to something. Velcoro is checking this place out quietly on the down low. This stranger causes a big fuss so that the house doesn't go unnoticed by official law enforcement channels, and injuring Velcoro may also serve to sideline him for a bit so the investigation can get moving without his interference. The latter would make sense for why this person doesn't just phone in a tip or something to bring police to the scene. Two birds, one stone.

It would also explain the costume. Because if you're out to kill someone then there's no reason to dress up.

So get dressed up, put a hurting on Velcoro, maybe even tell him a thing or two while you have his attention, and then get out of there ASAP without anyone knowing who you are.
 

giga

Member
I think we see a more intresting character when he goes abit crazy. And it looks its going that way more.


Btw really a shame HBO doesnt do a "Inside the episode" for this serie.
His "shake up" scene was anything but menacing. I wasn't sure if I was supposed to take it seriously.
 
Kitsch is best when he doesn't have to brood 100% of the time. He has a specific type of charisma. Tim Riggins worked because he wasn't a tortured soul ALL of the time.

Hoping he gets to do some more with his character soon, because it's not really working for me right now.

agreed. Kitsch can be fantastic, but thus far the writing hasn't done him any favors.
 
I was kinda thinking it might be the opposite, someone who DOES want this investigation to get closer to something. Velcoro is checking this place out quietly on the down low. This stranger causes a big fuss so that the house doesn't go unnoticed by official law enforcement channels, and injuring Velcoro may also serve to sideline him for a bit so the investigation can get moving without his interference. The latter would make sense for why this person doesn't just phone in a tip or something to bring police to the scene. Two birds, one stone.

You have a theory here, but why show us, the viewer, a shot of Velcoro receiving a shell at point blank?

People are going to be confused and upset that the man "came back from the dead".
 

joeposh

Member
My baseless theory:

Casper's therapist gives the impression that his sexual proclivities cast him as a submissive. Vince Vaughn's character goes to do recon at the "club", he gets a little more details on that -- that he likes to watch.

It's possible that he was into some sort of elaborate home invasion cuckold setup. Where Casper would normally be somehow forcefully incapacitated while his lady was taken by the invader. Perhaps Casper just put in an order that he never got a chance to cancel. That would help explain why Ray wasn't killed and why the person in the mask was comfortable blasting him right in front of a camera that could be networked out to a server.

Again, it's probably a reach but given some of they hints they dropped it seems somewhat possible.
 
Dead or not, I think its pretty obvious
VV set up Ray
.

Nah, if anything VV was being setup as he got the address from the girl at the club. It's in VV's interest to get to the bottom of things as he's out 5M otherwise.
 
Two people talk, one drinks, the other stares at the wall. At the end of the discussion one of them gets up and exits the room, the other person asks a question or says something about the one going out who says a smart one-line and finally goes out leaving the reamining person driking or staring at the wall.

True Detective 2.

A question gets asked. Answer leads to revelations of...damage. A lingering look in response. Silence. The tone is dark, verging on depressing. Cut to overhead shot of intricate Los Angeles traffic.

True Detective 2
 

mre

Golden Domers are chickenshit!!
I was kinda thinking it might be the opposite, someone who DOES want this investigation to get closer to something. Velcoro is checking this place out quietly on the down low. This stranger causes a big fuss so that the house doesn't go unnoticed by official law enforcement channels, and injuring Velcoro may also serve to sideline him for a bit so the investigation can get moving without his interference. The latter would make sense for why this person doesn't just phone in a tip or something to bring police to the scene. Two birds, one stone.
But did they make a big fuss? That room was very obviously sound proofed, and I'm thinking it might be the location of where Caspere's genitals were blown off (hence the pool of blood). If it is where that occurred, then that shotgun blast didn't garner any notice.
 
You have a theory here, but why show us, the viewer, a shot of Velcoro receiving a shell at point blank?

People are going to be confused and upset that the man "came back from the dead".

Well, the lack of blood in that scene should be a sign. This isn't a show or a network that has any qualms with spraying blood every which way but we didn't see a single ounce of the red stuff come out of ray.

I mean, we saw a guy with his nuts shot off yet there was no spray in any of the 2 shots ray took. And whomever was after Ray, if they really wanted to kill him then they wouldve gone with a shot to the head when he was down no?

So yeah, if he's not dead it wouldn't surprise me but i do think we're owed some sort of explanation, like salt or some shit. It didn't seem like he was wearing a vest so i think that's out of the question.

i don't think so if anything it might of been the fat gangster with the Gold Teeth. VV has no reason to set up Ray

Ray being his only link inside the investigation to the guy who had his $10 million means he really doesn't have a motive to kill him. He has 10 million reasons to keep him around and sound.
 

Lashley

Why does he wear the mask!?
My baseless theory:

Casper's therapist gives the impression that his sexual proclivities cast him as a submissive. Vince Vaughn's character goes to do recon at the "club", he gets a little more details on that -- that he likes to watch.

It's possible that he was into some sort of elaborate home invasion cuckold setup. Where Casper would normally be somehow forcefully incapacitated while his lady was taken by the invader. Perhaps Casper just put in an order that he never got a chance to cancel. That would help explain why Ray wasn't killed and why the person in the mask was comfortable blasting him right in front of a camera that could be networked out to a server.

Again, it's probably a reach but given some of they hints they dropped it seems somewhat possible.
Actually a decent theory
 
I know we've discussed rock salt in the shotgun, but have we also discussed the possibility of simply rubber bullets? Would serve the same purpose as the rock salt (serious injury, but Ray survives), but would be a little more probable that the point-blank shot doesn't practically kill him.
 

BTM

Member
Am I the only one who thinks Kitsch has a tiny resemblance to Harrison Ford? During the breakup scene especially.

Maybe I'm just crazy.
 

mre

Golden Domers are chickenshit!!
My baseless theory:

Casper's therapist gives the impression that his sexual proclivities cast him as a submissive. Vince Vaughn's character goes to do recon at the "club", he gets a little more details on that -- that he likes to watch.

It's possible that he was into some sort of elaborate home invasion cuckold setup. Where Casper would normally be somehow forcefully incapacitated while his lady was taken by the invader. Perhaps Casper just put in an order that he never got a chance to cancel. That would help explain why Ray wasn't killed and why the person in the mask was comfortable blasting him right in front of a camera that could be networked out to a server.

Again, it's probably a reach but given some of they hints they dropped it seems somewhat possible.
The bird mask obliterates this theory. This is the same guy that killed Caspere drove around Caspere's dead body. He had the mask in his car when he was driving Caspere's dead body around.
 
Am I the only one who thinks Kitsch has a tiny resemblance to Harrison Ford? During the breakup scene especially.

Maybe I'm just crazy.

they're both really good at making is absolutely clear they don't give a shit

in a good way, not in a kevin costner way
 
Top Bottom