So I just finished the game... yeah. I think this is the best game I've played in the last couple of years.
From the masterfully told story, to the bar raising set pieces, I greatly enjoyed my time from start to finish. I won't lie, after reading some of the impressions on gaf my hype-o-meter was taken down a notch. But after playing what I just played, I'm convinced gaf doesn't know shit.
One of my few criticisms of the game is that the para 9 is utter shit and shouldn't have been included in the SP. It's probably the reason why people are complaining about the aiming. The gun has like zero hit detection and the feeling is off. It also doesn't help that it's like the default gun. Actually, hit detection seemed to be a little wonky from many of the guns. But the para especially. And the default sensitivity for aiming is too low IMO. You gotta crank that shit up, son. And patch that shit up, naughty dogs.
I was also disappointed that fire doesn't chip away at one's health. It ruined the chateau ending's suspense.
The biggest surprise was that the puzzles were awesome, all of them. They were all legitimately good. No, not uncharted puzzles good. legitimately interesting, challenging, top tier level good.