-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Uncharted 3 reviews
- Thread starter Robinspain
- Start date
- Status
LightofRohan
Member
I'm still not on there huh...Mama Robotnik said:
But in reality, I think Eurogamer is essentially JEALOUS of NeoGAF - and for that they try and crucify our community by giving UC3 a bad score.
Lord Error
Insane For Sony
Why do you have nofi there? Unless you think he's insane for reviewing the game as high as bunch other places did?Mama Robotnik said:
Mama Robotnik
Member
Empty said:
Exactly right, I'll remove that quote with apologies to nofi.
It looked like someone had seen the score as it was published, immediately linked it with "BUY" without reading the text of the review, and hit post. Now I understand the situation better and know that he was linking to his own review. Again, apologies for that one.
Loudninja said:
If you find a thread with responses to a review that are as interesting as these ones, I invite you to take similar action.
zoukka said:
I feel cool now.
Lord Error
Insane For Sony
That's selling them short, I feel. Try playing UC1 after you've played UC3. I think you'll be surprised at how 'lesser' the gameplay and controls feel. I know I sensed that after playing UC2 already, and I don't see them regressing on it.TTP said:
krameriffic
Member
But the ride loses its punch somewhat after you've ridden two very similar rides before and this one feels like they've just rearranged the hills and turns and put a new coat of paint on it. And it REALLY loses its punch when you know that none of the events of the ride even end up mattering and its just a closed circuit at the end of which all status quo will be restored.xion4360 said:
Some people think the game can be improved by a little bit of innovation and story/character progression. Some people like to keep eating flavorless wallpaper paste that has been dyed a pretty color and served to them in a very nice bowl.
xion4360
Member
plagiarize said:
Its not like I care that it was a complaint in the review. I was directing my comment at the overall discussion here in the thread where people seem so displeased with Uncharted being linear. If you dislike that aspect then uncharted as a series is less appealing to you from the get-go. To now come in and say "boo hoo Uncharted 3 is too linear" is ridiculous. You know what the basic formula of uncharted is, and to expect that to be different this time doesn't make any sense.
The Technomancer
card-carrying scientician
I dunno, I'm a Nintendo fan, I've seen some of the most rabid in people, and even I think some of the quotes in this thread are....ludicrous.Loudninja said:
plagiarize
Banned
he can't accept that someone can have the honest opinion of the game being an 8/10. since his review backs up his opinion quite nicely, he's trying to frame it as making a stupid argument. which is hard, because it really doesn't.zoukka said:
because it's a valid, if rare, opinion.
and even if he scored a bunch of totally linear games higher, it doesn't change anything. that's like telling the cop that the guy infront of you was speeding too and the cop didn't pull him over.
but whatever. i'm looking forwards to the game. the criticisms in that review are ones that i know will not bother me, so i can read it and get excited about it. hell, i read that review before i came into this thread and it basically put the game from a maybe to a definately for me.
i come here, and that same review is apparently an affront to naughty dog because the reviewer dares not like what they were trying to achieve.
TrAcEr_x90
Member
Famassu said:
I actually liked the stealth elements, it was super hard to not alert the shootouts but in some of the sections I was able to beat them using only stealth.
Yoboman
Member
Holding a button to grip is fairly intuitive IMO. The only place it starts getting tricky is when you need to shoot.ProfessorMoran said:
It needs another layer to the platforming and I think most would agree to that. The problem is precision platforming in a realistic game doesn't work well. You get good platforming in games like Mario and inFamous cause the characters can do things like double jump or hover to adjust in mid air, you can't do that in Uncharted
Mama Robotnik
Member
It always does, Chinner.Chinner said:
PairOfFilthySocks
Member
Mama Robotnik said:
Bravo, good sir.
This shit is embarrassing.
plagiarize
Banned
that doesn't invalidate the complaint though does it?xion4360 said:
if someone thought U2 was too linear... if U3 is also too linear to their tastes they aren't allowed to say so? seriously?
That guy is absolutely spot on. This was one of the worst aspects of UC2 and from the videos I've seen, is set to make a return in this game. I think this is a problem with linear game design in general since it's probably the easiest way to keep a game exciting whilst forcing the player down a select route. It's not necessarily a bad thing, it's just that with advances in tech, it's harder to disguise it well to keep the game flowing. The tank chase in particular is an example of this.The_Technomancer said:
The_Technomancer said:
Im sure they had to do it in order to not break the "experience" and from you constantly dying from doing the wrong jumps or jumping a tad too late in a sequence thus making you fail, etc.
I dont get the "the devs basically give you fake freedom but shove you were you need to go" thing because thats what all linear games do and no ones is saying Uncharted is not linear. I guess my beef is they are pointing the obvious and jacking points for it.
Honestly ND have to learn from this experience as they are the only ones doing the type of Hollywood-esq sequences that go far and beyond your typical game. (animations of your character portraying correctly the actions that are supposed to occur)
ProfessorMoran
Member
jett said:
The Giantbomb review said stealth works better.
Lion Heart
Banned
Holy Shit, just got home and read the IGN review. I didn't think they would give it a ten, congrats ND. Fuck the wait is unbearable. And its okay Eurogamer, I still like you.
plagiarize
Banned
it got me 'four fingers' wet.Chinner said:
plagiarize said:
I can't comment on U3, but I can take a guess based on U2. My guess is this was Simon exaggerating the situation. U2 never killed you just for veering off point (unless you attempted to make some weird jump or something), the Uncharted franchise rewards you for exploring, in-fact you have to if you're collecting treasures.
Where you die for veering off point is during critical points, such as during chase scenes, whilst a bridge or building is collapsing and so forth. These are the points when going off tangent can land in an insta kill, but it's very clear and obvious, even from a common sense perspective, you're not supposed to at these points.
So again, it seems like a dud point. Funny though that he was the only one to mention this insta kill problem. Chances are he's trying too hard too push the games explorative boundaries, even when common sense goes against it. But we'll know for sure on release.
Yoboman
Member
Yup, UC3 is significantly tighter and better feeling than UC1 was. ND have made a lot of not so obvious stridesLord Error said:
Just the general animation makes a big difference. Weighty animations for example. I was playing UC1 and I never realised the jump animation was so bad, Drake does this little half hearted hop when jumping over big chasms
Raitosaito said:
Not sure if this was meant to be towards me since Mama felt the need to quote me twice about essentially the same thing, but no where did I ever mention IGN specifically. There's 36 scores on Metacritic, 33 of them which scored higher than Eurogamer. Are you guys really saying Eurogamer is the most credible website out there and that none of those other 33 hold a candle to it? I know you guys aren't that delusional.
Are there any standards for reviewing games? Is being linear part of a genre? Is it right to complain about a genre or design that has been used since the beginning of gaming?
Are developers seeing linearity as an old gaming design that needs to evolve?
Just some questions I have.
Are developers seeing linearity as an old gaming design that needs to evolve?
Just some questions I have.
plagiarize
Banned
Eurogamer does not do this.Famassu said:
Eurogamer assign different reviewers to the review in different countries. Each is free to give their own score.
what other sites may or may not do isn't relevant to what Eurogamer do.
Raitosaito
Member
Famassu said:
So when did you gain the insight to understand their specific editorial process?
VIVIblkmgIc
Banned
That's not really true though. If you look at the train level in Uncharted 2, the whole thing was that you had to fight on that train, and traverse it without getting knocked off. That meant hanging from the side of it, getting on the roof, and getting in the cabins at different points. There are things that happen around the player to some degree, but usually the physics end up affecting the gameplay. I mean, the automic jumping is such a lazy critique. The game isn't a platformer, and the environmental challenges (like the train) don't have to do with precision jumps, so much as strategic positioning, and so forth. Many games use automatic jumping now based on animation---Assassin's Creed and Arkham City are two other examples.Garjon said:
Mama Robotnik
Member
Darknessbear said:
As much as I'd love to add it, I'm pretty sure that you've done that one on purpose. The list is all the more terrifying as it appears most of the fanatic exclamations are genuine.
Lord Error
Insane For Sony
I really wish someone who has played the game could tell me if it's now possible to chose between snapping the bad guys' necks and putting them in a chokehold until they faint.jett said:If it's true that ND has diminished the opportunities for stealthplay instead of expanding on them I'll be honestly disappointed.
Of course knowing how game writers are they probably never even bothered to play stealthy.
The very first gameplay video with the cruise ship suggested this was possible but I've never seen it confirmed or talked about later.
ProfessorMoran
Member
Yoboman said:
It depends, if you're going to integrate combat into platforming, having to hold a button to grip is cumbersome, plus you have to consider whether that feature makes it into MP or not and something like this would absolutely be a no-no for MP.
plagiarize
Banned
i found it interesting because i do that. i try to push the boundaries. i'm never upset if the game just instakills me though... but i am always pleasantly surprised by things like Crysis's shark or Deus Ex Invisible War's smog, or Serious Sam's heat stroke.nib95 said:
i can see how a desert environment might be more difficult to create geographical boundaries in, and i can see potentially them having to resort to something like instakills for going 'off path' but yes, we'll see what he really means when the game comes out.
cause i ALWAYS try to go off path. it's a joy for me to get outside the 'allowed' area. i can't really explain it
There are all different kinds of linearity. I think people are beating up on a strawman. Eurogamer's critique isn't "why isn't this like Infamous or Red Dead". It has to do with how the action plays out within those setpieces.
For instance, Enslaved is linear. Mirror's Edge is linear. PoP 2K8 is a non-linear collection of linear levels. In Enslaved, you pretty much can't jump off a ledge to your death, because the only valid platforming control options are the ones that move you between the ledges and stuff you need to get to. Each button press in Prince of Persia is a shorthand for an elaborate set of motions, turning complex movements through 3D space into something closer to a QTE. Mirror's Edge, on the other hand, leaves an enormous amount of room for player agency in its platforming. There are many ways to succeed or fail any given platforming challenge.
Having not played Uncharted 3, it's hard to tell where on the continuum of controlled gameplay scenarios it falls. What I'm trying to illustrate is that it's possible to like some linear, directed experiences while finding others too limiting, just as some open world games are more "open" than others.
Of course, there's no reason any review should agree with every reader, so I don't get why everyone thinks the Eurogamer review absolutely has to come from the place of someone who is in total agreement with everything the franchise has historically stood for. There are only so many times you can read "If you loved Uncharted, you'll love Uncharted" before it becomes predictable.
For instance, Enslaved is linear. Mirror's Edge is linear. PoP 2K8 is a non-linear collection of linear levels. In Enslaved, you pretty much can't jump off a ledge to your death, because the only valid platforming control options are the ones that move you between the ledges and stuff you need to get to. Each button press in Prince of Persia is a shorthand for an elaborate set of motions, turning complex movements through 3D space into something closer to a QTE. Mirror's Edge, on the other hand, leaves an enormous amount of room for player agency in its platforming. There are many ways to succeed or fail any given platforming challenge.
Having not played Uncharted 3, it's hard to tell where on the continuum of controlled gameplay scenarios it falls. What I'm trying to illustrate is that it's possible to like some linear, directed experiences while finding others too limiting, just as some open world games are more "open" than others.
Of course, there's no reason any review should agree with every reader, so I don't get why everyone thinks the Eurogamer review absolutely has to come from the place of someone who is in total agreement with everything the franchise has historically stood for. There are only so many times you can read "If you loved Uncharted, you'll love Uncharted" before it becomes predictable.
zoukka said:
How does he (or you) know you can't explore U3's desert? Or that Zelda or Skyrim will have a desert you can explore?
zoukka said:
Heck I do this too. I just don't expect my ventures to be successful all that often. Unless of course it's a sandbox game. To be fair, I thought U2 was pretty good at this and allowed you to explore a fair bit.
Auto_aim1
MeisaMcCaffrey
That's not really true. They have complete freedom to give whatever score they want, especially in a large site like Eurogamer. I think Shane was really vocal about Killzone 3's 9.4 review in GT, as he whined about it later in Invisible Walls. So yeah I doubt it.Famassu said:
D
Deleted member 30609
Unconfirmed Member
I actually laughed out loud, right herenib95 said:
- Status