• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

United States Election: Nov 6, 2012 |OT| - Barack Obama Re-elected

Status
Not open for further replies.

Tex117

Banned
Yes he is.

For this particular election if you vote 3rd party you are throwing your vote in the garbage. No one will care. All that matters is if Romney or Obama wins. That's all the media will cover because the stakes are so high right now. Your vote won't send a message as all it will do is help either side win depending on the state.

Coward.

Edit: of course you are right, but its so cowardly. So "controled...
 

Kingbrave

Member
Voted here in Soutwest Virginia. I believe I'm one of only 5 or 6 people who voted for Obama. I didn't get a sticker. I'll beat people with my cane for my damn sticker!
 
The problem with your stance is that on one hand you say voting third party won't change anything. And then on the other hand you act like voting for the main parties will make any more difference. Sorry but you can't have it both ways. Either vote for you who you think is best, or don't vote at all.

Nonsense. If you're in a swing state and your vote could have mattered then voting third party could fuck things up, still with your guy getting single digits. Vote to change, bit to play college boy PolySci feel good games.

If you're not in a swing state, it doesn't matter anyway. Feel good.

Again, push to change how the system works grassroots, locally upwards. Don't waste your time when nothing changes with 5% candidates on a two party ballot.
 
Maybe we should spin the discussion of the validity/worthwhileness of voting third party into another thread? I'd do it, but I'm too lazy to make threads and respond to people.

There's a difference between "throwing your vote away" and "your vote would be better served elsewhere"
This is true. My statement at the end of my previous post was a bit too absolute/judgmental.
 

RDreamer

Member
That's exactly what I did. Instead of letting the people around me falsely limit my choices, I looked at every choice, considered my traditional write in vote (because fuck Ron Paul) and decided on Johnson.

But you chose one that you know will not work. The people around you aren't falsely limiting your choice. Reality is. Johnson isn't going to win. Period. So now one of the other two candidates will win, and you will have had exactly zero say in which one.
 
Look, voting for someone doesn't mean you support every single thing they do. It means it was the best choice to make given the choices.

And none of those other candidates on the ballot are actually 'choices'?

The rest of your post is equally sheep-minded bullshit.
 

Jonm1010

Banned
He certainly swung the 1992 election in Bill Clinton's favor. Also, his party won governorship of Minnesota in 1998 with Jesse Ventura as their nominee. I'd say the reform party had a decent impact. However, infighting and lack of Perot's billions have collapsed the party. It'll take another billionaire to setup a third party that can compete in state/national elections. It's certainly possible. I'd love to see Romney win the PV but lose the Electoral College. Both parties getting "screwed" by that might cause changes.

And again I say, what has it really changed? Clinton would have still won. Perot's ideas largely didn't materialize into the mainstream longterm and his party is all but finished.

His model shows us a billionaire can temporarily have an outlier affect to a marginal group of people and in a small area.

I still contend the tea party has it right. Local elections, influence and pressure from within. In the case of establishing third parties that needs to be coupled with a strong push for voting reform laws that make third parties more likely and possible going forward and will allow them sustainability.
 

Hitokage

Setec Astronomer
+1 Obama in NC

McCrory's probably going to win governor, but even though I don't have huge issues with him I voted Dalton to help remind him his seat isn't safe.
 

equap

Banned
green/third party voters, why go out of your way to not matter?? just stay home. and stop bragging about how you just threw away your vote.

like vegans telling people they're vegans. WHO GIVES A SHIT? when you tell me you voted for Jill or whoever, you're just an attention whore. LOOK AT ME I'M SPECIAL I VOTED FOR THE GREEN PARTY.

stop it!
 

RDreamer

Member
The rest of your post is equally sheep-minded bullshit.

And what others are posting is just idealist bullshit.

I still contend the tea party has it right. Local elections, influence and pressure from within. In the case of establishing third parties that needs to be coupled with a strong push for voting reform laws that make third parties more likely and possible going forward and will allow them sustainability.

I'm going to keep re-emphasizing this guy's posts. This is what you do. Influence from the bottom up. Trying to sway the highest and hardest office in the land every four years by voting in a party with no infrastructure or support system because it hasn't been voted in anywhere else really is just idealist BS. We have a system in place. Use it.
 

TheNatural

My Member!
But you chose one that you know will not work. The people around you aren't falsely limiting your choice. Reality is. Johnson isn't going to win. Period. So now one of the other two candidates will win, and you will have had exactly zero say in which one.

And you have?

So that's what it is. You just want to make yourself feel important by saying 'hey those two guys on TV all the time the media told me to choose between I picked one of them, so I made a difference!'

Sounds like a lot of bullshit to make yourself feel significant and a part of something rather than actually effecting the vote.

Get back to me when your state is decided by even a thousand votes, much less one. Otherwise, get off your voting high horse.
 
But you chose one that you know will not work. The people around you aren't falsely limiting your choice. Reality is. Johnson isn't going to win. Period. So now one of the other two candidates will win, and you will have had exactly zero say in which one.

What if you wouldn't choose either of the potential winners, for whatever reason?

Everyone just assumes a 3rd party vote is taking a vote away from your 2nd choice guy, but that's not always the case.
 
green/third party voters, why go out of your way to not matter?? just stay home. and stop bragging about how you just threw away your vote.

like vegans telling people they're vegans. WHO GIVES A SHIT? when you tell me you voted for Jill or whoever, you're just an attention whore. LOOK AT ME I'M SPECIAL I VOTED FOR THE GREEN PARTY.

stop it!

Save the gas, and and carbon footprint today. That at least is useful.
 

Crazyorloco

Member
im seeing "if you don't vote for obama im unfriending you. please put who you are voting for up" on facebook.

for me this is a bit extreme. i love the entertainment though. Tonight I await meltdowns no matter who wins.
 

eznark

Banned
But you chose one that you know will not work. The people around you aren't falsely limiting your choice. Reality is. Johnson isn't going to win. Period. So now one of the other two candidates will win, and you will have had exactly zero say in which one.

I voted for the only candidate that hasn't thoroughly disgusted me over the last decade. I voted for the only one who I think could possibly work.
 

The Technomancer

card-carrying scientician
+1 in Minnesota for my man B-Rock "The Shock" and Ol' Uncle Joe

Voting experience was great in this location, amazingly fast and smooth, even during lunch hour. It was at the gay-friendly church a few blocks from my apartment, staffed by nice and attentive people, and my registration took about three minutes from start to finish. When the booths were full they said we could spill over into a sitting room if we didn't mind the lack of privacy.
 

devilhawk

Member
But you chose one that you know will not work. The people around you aren't falsely limiting your choice. Reality is. Johnson isn't going to win. Period. So now one of the other two candidates will win, and you will have had exactly zero say in which one.

If the vote totals was separated by more than 1, technically your vote meant exactly zero.
 

bjb

Banned
green/third party voters, why go out of your way to not matter?? just stay home. and stop bragging about how you just threw away your vote.

like vegans telling people they're vegans. WHO GIVES A SHIT? when you tell me you voted for Jill or whoever, you're just an attention whore. LOOK AT ME I'M SPECIAL I VOTED FOR THE GREEN PARTY.

stop it!

This guy lol
 

Tex117

Banned
"Usefulness" arguments aside, what's brave about anonymously voting for a third party candidate?

Not being controled by a two party system. Knowing that in the grand scheme of "usefulness" your vote probably wont matter.

Voting for the person you believe in inspite of all the other bull shit, admirable. A person of conviction.
 
green/third party voters, why go out of your way to not matter?? just stay home. and stop bragging about how you just threw away your vote.

like vegans telling people they're vegans. WHO GIVES A SHIT? when you tell me you voted for Jill or whoever, you're just an attention whore. LOOK AT ME I'M SPECIAL I VOTED FOR THE GREEN PARTY.

stop it!

Because I'd rather vote for someone I agree with rather than who wins. If I were in a swing state, I would gladly vote for Obama, but since I'm in Texas, voting Dem is just as worthless as voting Green so why not throw them a bone and inch them towards 5% of the popular vote. Also, we have local elections to participate in as well, so we're not going to just stay home.
 
green/third party voters, why go out of your way to not matter?? just stay home. and stop bragging about how you just threw away your vote.

like vegans telling people they're vegans. WHO GIVES A SHIT? when you tell me you voted for Jill or whoever, you're just an attention whore. LOOK AT ME I'M SPECIAL I VOTED FOR THE GREEN PARTY.

stop it!

haha, get off your high horse kid. This is a thread about the election, we're not preaching veganism unsolicited.
 

TheNatural

My Member!
green/third party voters, why go out of your way to not matter?? just stay home. and stop bragging about how you just threw away your vote.

like vegans telling people they're vegans. WHO GIVES A SHIT? when you tell me you voted for Jill or whoever, you're just an attention whore. LOOK AT ME I'M SPECIAL I VOTED FOR THE GREEN PARTY.

stop it!

Sounds like more attention whoring from people like you bringing up and crying about who voted what, and pretending that because you voted for one of the two main options, that you're more significant than anyone else when you're not.
 

Jonm1010

Banned
And you have?

So that's what it is. You just want to make yourself feel important by saying 'hey those two guys on TV all the time the media told me to choose between I picked one of them, so I made a difference!'

Sounds like a lot of bullshit to make yourself feel significant and a part of something rather than actually effecting the vote.

Get back to me when your state is decided by even a thousand votes, much less one. Otherwise, get off your voting high horse.

He's using logic and reasoning to make a point, even if you dont agree with it. you're using character attacks and straw men. Think about that for a minute.
 

Tobor

Member
Statistically speaking, voting for a third party candidate is no different than not voting at all.

It's removing a vote from whichever of the two candidates with a chance of winning you would have otherwise voted for.

At the local levels, this is obviously not the case, I'm just referring to national elections.
 
I'm going to keep re-emphasizing this guy's posts. This is what you do. Influence from the bottom up. Trying to sway the highest and hardest office in the land every four years by voting in a party with no infrastructure or support system because it hasn't been voted in anywhere else really is just idealist BS. We have a system in place. Use it.

And for those of us that do, we're going to vote for our guy in the 'big' race. Deal with it.

It's removing a vote from whichever of the two candidates with a chance of winning you would have otherwise voted for.

Good, so I took away a vote from no one.
 

Puddles

Banned
Manufactured debt limit crisis? Granted, it was turned into a PR opportunity for the Republicans, but I think it's a stretch to suggest the crisis itself was manufactured.

The crisis was completely manufactured. Increasing the debt ceiling should have been a formality, because no one who holds public office in this country should be so economically illiterate as to actually consider default.
 

TheNatural

My Member!
He's using logic and reasoning to make a point, even if you dont agree with it. you're using character attacks. Think about that for a minute.

He's using logic by saying people are attnetion whoring, while I'm using simple 1st grade math to show that no one's single vote matters. Think about that one for a minute. I'm not the one being a keyboard warrior sitting in a thread on a videogame forum lecturing people on how they should vote.
 

eznark

Banned
Statistically speaking, voting for a third party candidate is no different than not voting at all.

It's removing a vote from whichever of the two candidates with a chance of winning you would have otherwise voted for.

At the local levels, this is obviously not the case, I'm just referring to national elections.

Why would you assume people that don't vote for the dem or rep would vote at all?
 

Tex117

Banned
Because I'd rather vote for someone I agree with rather than who wins. If I were in a swing state, I would gladly vote for Obama, but since I'm in Texas, voting Dem is just as worthless as voting Green so why not throw them a bone and inch them towards 5% of the popular vote. Also, we have local elections to participate in as well, so we're not going to just stay home.

Literally, this is exactly my reasoning, though reversed. Probably voting for Johnson...Not sure yet.
 
Everyone has the right to vote for whomever they want. Stop trying to tell them not to vote. That's some fucked up shit.

I don't see anyone telling anyone else not to vote. I see some people telling others that they're are dumb for voting a certain way. That's just par for the course of political discussion.
 
He's using logic by saying people are attnetion whoring, while I'm using simple 1st grade math to show that no one's single vote matters. Think about that one for a minute. I'm not the one being a keyboard warrior sitting in a thread on a videogame forum lecturing people on how they should vote.
those damn keyboard warriors ain't about this life
 

grkazan12

Member
+1 for Obama here in Pennsylvania. Was a bubble ballot. Took a little pic too, gotta love them fall colors.

A7CRd28CIAEuT4q.jpg
 

RDreamer

Member
What if you wouldn't choose either of the potential winners, for whatever reason?

Everyone just assumes a 3rd party vote is taking a vote away from your 2nd choice guy, but that's not always the case.

This only makes sense if both people are absolutely 100% exactly the same. They're not. There are huge differences. Vote for which one of the two would help the country the best. If you can't do this then I question how you get through life, since life presents two seemingly bad options all the fucking time. It's your job to discern which one is better and choose it, if not for you but for someone else or for society as a whole. As I said before MILLIONS of people's healthcare are riding on this election, along with quite a few other big issues. One of these two will be in office next. That is a fact. Do your part to help choose which one of the two.
 
What if you wouldn't choose either of the potential winners, for whatever reason?

Everyone just assumes a 3rd party vote is taking a vote away from your 2nd choice guy, but that's not always the case.

That's true. How could it be stealing votes when it probably wasn't going to go to the other two guys in the first place?
 
The crisis was completely manufactured. Increasing the debt ceiling should have been a formality, because no one who holds public office in this country should be so economically illiterate as to actually consider default.

Again, the crisis (meaning, the fiasco surround it): yes, manufactured. The fact that we are perpetually running up against the debt ceiling is a real (ongoing) crisis.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom