Rentahamster
Rodent Whores
No, OP, I don't want to come on you.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Vikings is better than Game of Thrones - come at me
Halo is Back
Member
Never watched it but GOT killed itself
Last edited:
Halo is Back
Member
And Spartacus was better than them both.
In all seriousness, Spartacus was the shit! Lucy Lawless naked was gift from the gods
Fox Mulder
Member
Even with GOT ending like shit and tanking its legacy and popularity, the show was still top tier most of its run and the peak was greatest of all time good tv that millions were watching.
I never got into Vikings because it’s on the history channel.
I never got into Vikings because it’s on the history channel.
Brian Fellows
Pete Carroll Owns Me
Spartacus was an actively terrible show. Bad acting. Worse dialogue. And a budget that appeared to be about 10 cents.
Kadayi
Banned
The first season of Vikings was pretty terrible, but after that, it hits its stride. However, the show kind of hits a downward spiral in the later seasons after Ragnar dies and it is all about the sons. Kathryn Winnick is hot as hell though, that cannot be denied.
Game of Thrones, great up until the Showrunners ran out of book material to pull from and were having to work off of GRRMs outline. Bit of a rock and a hard place IMHO. The breakneck pacing definitely did the reception of the series no favours but at the same time the lack of material to draw from meant that they were already having to stretch storylines. Ultimately if GRRM spent less time doing anything but writing the books, things wouldn't have gone the way they did. It's easy to point the finger at the Showrunners solely, but ultimately if the fat cunt had spent less time feathering his nest with peripheral projects like 'The World of Ice and Fire' and the utterly wank 'Fire and Blood' Targaryan History book and more time working on the Winds of Winter etc things wouldn't have gone the way they did.
The Last Kingdom. First season is a little modest in budget as it was just a BBC production, However, Netflix came in from the second season and the bigger budget definitely shows. Doesn't quite have the grandiose stylings of Vikings or GOT, but it's an enjoyable enough series. Cromwell is a bit of formulaic writer though and it kind of shows at times. What I would say though is that the main protagonist Utred is quite flawed and a bit of a dick at times, which I kind of dig.
Spartacus. Guilty pleasure Television. Never bothered with the Later seasons but the first season and the prequel were highly entertaining. Real shame about the main dude dying of Cancer after season 1 as he was quite engaging. Not sure how his replacement did filling in his role.
Game of Thrones, great up until the Showrunners ran out of book material to pull from and were having to work off of GRRMs outline. Bit of a rock and a hard place IMHO. The breakneck pacing definitely did the reception of the series no favours but at the same time the lack of material to draw from meant that they were already having to stretch storylines. Ultimately if GRRM spent less time doing anything but writing the books, things wouldn't have gone the way they did. It's easy to point the finger at the Showrunners solely, but ultimately if the fat cunt had spent less time feathering his nest with peripheral projects like 'The World of Ice and Fire' and the utterly wank 'Fire and Blood' Targaryan History book and more time working on the Winds of Winter etc things wouldn't have gone the way they did.
The Last Kingdom. First season is a little modest in budget as it was just a BBC production, However, Netflix came in from the second season and the bigger budget definitely shows. Doesn't quite have the grandiose stylings of Vikings or GOT, but it's an enjoyable enough series. Cromwell is a bit of formulaic writer though and it kind of shows at times. What I would say though is that the main protagonist Utred is quite flawed and a bit of a dick at times, which I kind of dig.
Spartacus. Guilty pleasure Television. Never bothered with the Later seasons but the first season and the prequel were highly entertaining. Real shame about the main dude dying of Cancer after season 1 as he was quite engaging. Not sure how his replacement did filling in his role.
Last edited:
Richard Packer
Member
bitbydeath
Gold Member
Men_in_Boxes
Snake Oil Salesman
I watched the first Season and a few episodes of Season 2, of Vikings.
OP, you're insane. GoT had far more interesting characters, put in far more interesting situations, in a far more interesting world.
OP, you're insane. GoT had far more interesting characters, put in far more interesting situations, in a far more interesting world.
Richard Packer
Member
Who to believe.
Do you get to see her tits?
bitbydeath
Gold Member
Yeah, most of the women on the show strip off at some point.
Richard Packer
Member
Nice.
BlueAlpaca
Member
Vikings is garbage and only good for killing time. I saw first five seasons and I'll regret it for the rest of my life.
Game of Thrones was only garbage in seasons 7/8, otherwise it was pretty good. Lots of problems but good all the same.
I read on a Slate Star Codex blog regarding genius and shakespeare many comments on how we have 100 shakespeares today, all working on TV shows. With an audience like that no wonder everybody's singing praise of a TV golden age. I myself can only count two good shows - sopranos and breaking bad - and neither of those I'd consider anything more than decent entertainment.
Game of Thrones was only garbage in seasons 7/8, otherwise it was pretty good. Lots of problems but good all the same.
I read on a Slate Star Codex blog regarding genius and shakespeare many comments on how we have 100 shakespeares today, all working on TV shows. With an audience like that no wonder everybody's singing praise of a TV golden age. I myself can only count two good shows - sopranos and breaking bad - and neither of those I'd consider anything more than decent entertainment.
Last edited:
OmegaSupreme
advanced basic bitch
You watched 5 seasons of something even though you hated it? Wow. You must be bored af all the time.
manfestival
Member
Interesting... I did watch the following season since I was genuinely interested in seeing where they were going to take the show. It felt almost natural to have ended things there considering it is supposed to be historic fiction. I watched some more but what ultimately killed my interest in the show is that mid season "break" garbage where they ultimately create 2 short seasons and pretend it is one(unless you watch a show after completion).
The show kinda got hard for me to watch but I think it is because I really liked how mental Ivar was. That is all I can and will say. I did not watch any of the latest or even maybe the 2nd half of the last season. In fact, I can't remember where I actually left off at.
As for the thread, to me Game of Thrones was just so revolutionary in a sense. It paved the way for Vikings to be in its own greatness. Since many shows were trying to get that GoT crowd at the time. I remember my buddy pitching Vikings to me like a more PG GoT and it worked. I do think GoT is much better up until t he end of season 6. The story started losing its congruency there. Vikings fortunately has stayed solid but my gripe above turned me off from keeping up.
Tesseract
Banned
you are a fucking monster
D
Deleted member 17706
Unconfirmed Member
I like it better if only for it being a bit closer to actual historical events. Alexander Dreymon (Uhtred's actor) is great in my opinion. Perhaps not as good as Fimmel, but close in my book.
I'm also currently reading through The Saxon Stories that The Last Kingdom is based on and they are fantastic, so that might be coloring my opinion a bit.
Oberstein
Member
I'm more of Judith guy myself. She gave up an ear for her man and took our her own shitty son when it had to be done.
Not to mention Lagertha was just as terrible as Bjorn at coming up with battle plans.
I still think Kathery Winnick should have been Captain Marvel though.
Agreed, but she's hotter as a blonde.
Mistershine.
Banned
Norsemen is better than both.
SirTerry-T
Member
Vikings is great, though I prefer TLK.
Can't excuse Vikings for making every guy with a sleeve tattoo and a wardrobe full of leather thinking they are some berserker fucking warlord though just because they have a man bun.
That's just plain wrong.
Can't excuse Vikings for making every guy with a sleeve tattoo and a wardrobe full of leather thinking they are some berserker fucking warlord though just because they have a man bun.
That's just plain wrong.
Last edited: