-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
adamsapple
Or is it just one of Phil's balls in my throat?
And finished. Finished the post-game chapter as well. Kinda bummed that there's no major changes in the finale narrative if you do all that extra content but ah well. At least it puts a nice bow on everything.
I am really surprised how much I enjoyed my time with the game. Wasn't expecting it to be this fun. Probably the best JRPG I've played this year, or very close behind P3 Reload, and one of the best Square games through this generation as a whole.
NGL the ending-ending got me a bit misty eyed.
Ending context for those who won't play but might be curious:
I am really surprised how much I enjoyed my time with the game. Wasn't expecting it to be this fun. Probably the best JRPG I've played this year, or very close behind P3 Reload, and one of the best Square games through this generation as a whole.
NGL the ending-ending got me a bit misty eyed.
Ending context for those who won't play but might be curious:
The primary 'magic girl love interest' who the hero swears to protect through their journey, where she is supposed to sacrifice herself at the end ala Yuna in FFX anyway, dies about 30% of the way through the game. The game does a pretty ballsy thing by keeping her dead through the rest of the game, no magical resurrections. After you beat the game, there's a flash cut to xyz number of years and your hero is dying as an old man, after he dies, he 'wakes up' in the sanctuary of mana location, a key location in the story, where he sees the magic girl love interest waiting for him, they run and hug each other, and that's how the game ends.
Last edited:
jshackles
Gentlemen, we can rebuild it. We have the capability to make the world's first enhanced store. Steam will be that store. Better than it was before.
What was your total playtime?And finished. Finished the post-game chapter as well. Kinda bummed that there's no major changes in the finale narrative if you do all that extra content but ah well. At least it puts a nice bow on everything.
I am really surprised how much I enjoyed my time with the game. Wasn't expecting it to be this fun. Probably the best JRPG I've played this year, or very close behind P3 Reload, and one of the best Square games through this generation as a whole.
NGL the ending-ending got me a bit misty eyed.
Ending context for those who won't play but might be curious:
The primary 'magic girl love interest' who the hero swears to protect through their journey, where she is supposed to sacrifice herself at the end ala Yuna in FFX anyway, dies about 30% of the way through the game. The game does a pretty ballsy thing by keeping her dead through the rest of the game, no magical resurrections. After you beat the game, there's a flash cut to xyz number of years and your hero is dying as an old man, after he dies, he 'wakes up' in the sanctuary of mana location, a key location in the story, where he sees the magic girl love interest waiting for him, they run and hug each other, and that's how the game ends.
adamsapple
Or is it just one of Phil's balls in my throat?
28~ hours give or take. I stopped doing the random NPC quests in the 2nd half cause 99% of them just give you small amounts of money and I was rolling in it before the end. Same for hunting after each blue circle treasure icon on the map, stopped after a while cause they were all giving minor healing items etc that I didn't really need.
Last edited:
NeoIkaruGAF
Gold Member
I want to live in your world, where you can enter and loot anyone’s house without people caring and you find $100 bills lying around instead of pennies caked into the pavement.
Thank god there’s still games where most of the scenery is just that, inaccessible props. I want to play a fantasy game, not a tour of virtual houses I could never own anyway.
jshackles
Gentlemen, we can rebuild it. We have the capability to make the world's first enhanced store. Steam will be that store. Better than it was before.
PC players... I found out that during cutscenes, if you press F11 (exit full screen) then F11 again (enter full screen) - the cutscenes now run at the proper FPS (in my case 140fps to match my monitor). I thought at first it was just Steam's overlay reporting incorrectly, but it does indeed seem to smooth out the video more than the default 30fps.
Can anyone else confirm this?
Can anyone else confirm this?
adamsapple
Or is it just one of Phil's balls in my throat?
Is it even a game if you can't enter every NPC house and go through their dirty laundry?
sigmaZ
Member
Yeah, it works. I've been doing the same.
DonkeyPunchJr
World’s Biggest Weeb
Playing on hard mode, seems like there was a pretty big difficulty spike. The water benevodon just whupped my ass big time.
One big pet peeve about this game: you’re constantly getting sidequests AFTER you just passed through the area where the objective was. And none of the “kill X of this enemy” count until after you accept the quest. Also lots of “collect X of this item dropped by this enemy” but they won’t even start dropping that item until after you accept the quest. WTF?
One big pet peeve about this game: you’re constantly getting sidequests AFTER you just passed through the area where the objective was. And none of the “kill X of this enemy” count until after you accept the quest. Also lots of “collect X of this item dropped by this enemy” but they won’t even start dropping that item until after you accept the quest. WTF?
Crystal Winters
Member
Last edited:
Shake Your Rump
Banned
I just had this at the port town. I rode through this huge area, passing by a few quest givers, arrive at town, receive another handful of quests, a story scene triggers, talk to some NPCs to progress that, and suddenly it's "let's hurry and get on the ship".
I went back and did all the side quests, but I think I may just skip them unless they are convenient from this point on.
DonkeyPunchJr
World’s Biggest Weeb
Yeah thankfully you can see the rewards so you can decide which ones are worth doing. Most of them just give you money.
NeoIkaruGAF
Gold Member
Yes, and it was as useless as it would be today.
If entering a house is only worth it for useless banter from a random NPC and/or an apple hidden in a jar, then the devs can surely spare me the hassle of entering a house to give me the same content.
Nobody needs the 100 houses in any country village to be fully accessible and explorable. A dozen was always too many already. I don’t need to enter a house to know it has tables, chairs, beds, and a host of trinkets that only 1% of players would ever take a closer look at - and shouldn’t anyway.
Mister Wolf
Member
CutsceneFPS_v3_60-240.zip (CutsceneFPS_v3_60-240.zip) ダウンロード | day0508 聖剣伝説 Visions of Mana のMOD置き場 | uploader.jp
修正160件追加カットシーンFPS変更とスキップ有効化
Use this mod to unlock cutscenes to the framerate of your choice.
Extract it. Pick the folder with the new frame cap you want for the cutscenes. Copy contents from that folder and put in this location:
SteamLibrary\steamapps\common\VisionsofMana\VisionsofMana\Content
At this location create a new folder named ~mods and place those files within it.
I'm using this mod amongst others.
Last edited:
jshackles
Gentlemen, we can rebuild it. We have the capability to make the world's first enhanced store. Steam will be that store. Better than it was before.
I have the same mod, but it doesn't work for every cutscene (whereas the trick of exiting and entering full screen does). It'll get there, the PC version with mods is already running circles around the console versions.CutsceneFPS_v3_60-240.zip (CutsceneFPS_v3_60-240.zip) ダウンロード | day0508 聖剣伝説 Visions of Mana のMOD置き場 | uploader.jp
修正160件追加カットシーンFPS変更とスキップ有効化ux.getuploader.com
Use this mod to unlock cutscenes to the framerate of your choice.
Extract it. Pick the folder with the new frame cap you want for the cutscenes. Copy contents from that folder and put in this location:
SteamLibrary\steamapps\common\VisionsofMana\VisionsofMana\Content
At this location create a new folder named ~mods and place those files within it.
I'm using this mod amongst others.
Mister Wolf
Member
I saw that this one is version 3 of the mod. Hopefully this one addresses more of the cutscenes.
Crystal Winters
Member
Last edited:
Crystal Winters
Member
.
Last edited:
Shake Your Rump
Banned
Both?
Just kidding. The game seems to be standard JRPG fare, so it depends on if that is your thing. It's definitely a "mana" game like the others.
Crystal Winters
Member
.
Last edited:
Danjin44
The nicest person on this forum
Yeah I’m pleasantly surprised how much I like the story.
I liked Trials of Mana but it’s story is pretty much very simple and straight forward, it’s product of it’s time.
Last edited:
kurisu_1974
Member
The game is OK but it could have been much better
- I hate the fast travel system, there are like 2 systems in place (one with the map, one with the meridians) but neither do what I wish they'd do
- The endless quests could be fun, but there's this weird thing where your collecting or discovering only starts when you accept the quest. I like it when you accept a quest and already have the materials or whatever. Not so here. I even got the achievement for discovering all eight dungeons and then the quest to discover them says 3/8 because I only accepted the quest after already having discovered some...
- The combat hasn't clicked, there is nothing meaningful to do, no blocking, parrying, and there is a dodge but it doesn't feel satisfying. I want to dodge last minute and then do crits or slow time or whatever, this makes fighting addictive.
- Equipment and weapons are very standard and a bit lacklustre, no upgrading, nothing.
- A lot of chests but man, there is really nothing worthwile in 99% of them
- It's kinda buggy, had a crash, had a party member just lock up in a battle, some weird framerate issues and flickering of the UI too.
I'm only in chapter 6 fighting these Benevodons so maybe it'll get better... I tried to do all content up to this point but honestly I feel like beelining for the ending as it stands now.
- I hate the fast travel system, there are like 2 systems in place (one with the map, one with the meridians) but neither do what I wish they'd do
- The endless quests could be fun, but there's this weird thing where your collecting or discovering only starts when you accept the quest. I like it when you accept a quest and already have the materials or whatever. Not so here. I even got the achievement for discovering all eight dungeons and then the quest to discover them says 3/8 because I only accepted the quest after already having discovered some...
- The combat hasn't clicked, there is nothing meaningful to do, no blocking, parrying, and there is a dodge but it doesn't feel satisfying. I want to dodge last minute and then do crits or slow time or whatever, this makes fighting addictive.
- Equipment and weapons are very standard and a bit lacklustre, no upgrading, nothing.
- A lot of chests but man, there is really nothing worthwile in 99% of them
- It's kinda buggy, had a crash, had a party member just lock up in a battle, some weird framerate issues and flickering of the UI too.
I'm only in chapter 6 fighting these Benevodons so maybe it'll get better... I tried to do all content up to this point but honestly I feel like beelining for the ending as it stands now.
Last edited:
DonkeyPunchJr
World’s Biggest Weeb
The dialog scenes are definitely a snooze fest at times. Just way, way too much talking for this style of story/characters.
I’m in chapter 7 now and I’ve started skimming most of the dialog snd skipping the VA. They’ve reached the part of the game where they need to wrap up all the character arcs and some of these scenes are so corny and long-winded.
Still enjoying the combat and exploration but I’m pretty much ready to wrap it up and move on to something else.
Crystal Winters
Member
.
Last edited:
darth.shrimp
Member
Just got my last achievement, loved the game from start to finish.
The secret boss was definitely at its strongest in this game, holy... Granted, I was playing in Hard, but it's been the hardest and longest fight I've had in a JRPG in a long while.
Careena still best girl, Ash best overall, Julei was great too.
The secret boss was definitely at its strongest in this game, holy... Granted, I was playing in Hard, but it's been the hardest and longest fight I've had in a JRPG in a long while.
Careena still best girl, Ash best overall, Julei was great too.
NotMyProblemAnymoreCunt
Biggest Trails Stan
This game knows how to attract the 'male gaze'.
Around 20 hours in and I usually main as her
Shake Your Rump
Banned
Tried to get back into the game tonight and just wasn't having fun. I finally took the ship and had a fight with a Kraken. Of course the AI just gets slapped around as they don't even try to avoid the obvious red danger marks. Combat in general is too busy for me. There is too much going on to keep track of everyone's status effects, buffs, elements, etc. It reminds me of Xenoblade 2 where combat has all these nifty systems, but ultimately it is just chaos.
Towns are boring. Tons of NPCs that say nothing even remotely interesting. I reached the water town and was filled with dread. I think I burned myself out by doing everything in the prior towns and areas.
The music and art is great, but the rest pales in comparison to my other JRPGs I have going (Octopath and Daybreak). If the combat was more simple or slower, and the game had fewer systems... this just makes me want to play Trials of Mana again.
Towns are boring. Tons of NPCs that say nothing even remotely interesting. I reached the water town and was filled with dread. I think I burned myself out by doing everything in the prior towns and areas.
The music and art is great, but the rest pales in comparison to my other JRPGs I have going (Octopath and Daybreak). If the combat was more simple or slower, and the game had fewer systems... this just makes me want to play Trials of Mana again.
sigmaZ
Member
Finally getting back into it myself. I think the biggest issue is the way everything is spaced out. Looks nice and all, but the OG games were nice in how they were content dense.
The Luka Ruins track is the best in the game I've heard so far. This sounds like a proper SNES-era Mana track.
The Luka Ruins track is the best in the game I've heard so far. This sounds like a proper SNES-era Mana track.
Just finished this game. What an absolutely mediocre RPG. Honestly, I've no idea why I kept playing to be honest. I guess the thought of wasting money was weighing on me, and instead I wasted 30 hours of my time on top of the money already spent.
It's just so unbelievably generic. The characters aren't interesting, the world isn't interesting, the story is not a PATCH on Xenoblade 2 or 3 (despite borrowing heavily in some themes), the combat is horrific, and just annoying. Most of the combat you just spend running toward baddies that have been knocked back. It's infuriating, and a mess.
The loot is boring, the menus are all over the place - a complete mess, the music is annoyingly repetitive, the dialogue is HILARIOUSLY bad, and the story is idiotic, trying SO hard to manufacture emotion where there is none. The side quests are 99% pointless, and even leveling is pointless as enemies just level with you, so you can just make a beeline for chests and then leave the area. Oh, and the game has cutscene after cutscene after cutscene, and they're 99% trite. Walk forward, cutscene. Walk forward 10ft. Another cutscene. It's mind boggling. And if I have to hear Val yell "GRIZZLY!" one more time... well - I won't, as this is getting deleted. Please don't waste your time on mediocre games like this, when there are far, far better ones out there. Play DQXI instead, which is a masterclass.
It's just so unbelievably generic. The characters aren't interesting, the world isn't interesting, the story is not a PATCH on Xenoblade 2 or 3 (despite borrowing heavily in some themes), the combat is horrific, and just annoying. Most of the combat you just spend running toward baddies that have been knocked back. It's infuriating, and a mess.
The loot is boring, the menus are all over the place - a complete mess, the music is annoyingly repetitive, the dialogue is HILARIOUSLY bad, and the story is idiotic, trying SO hard to manufacture emotion where there is none. The side quests are 99% pointless, and even leveling is pointless as enemies just level with you, so you can just make a beeline for chests and then leave the area. Oh, and the game has cutscene after cutscene after cutscene, and they're 99% trite. Walk forward, cutscene. Walk forward 10ft. Another cutscene. It's mind boggling. And if I have to hear Val yell "GRIZZLY!" one more time... well - I won't, as this is getting deleted. Please don't waste your time on mediocre games like this, when there are far, far better ones out there. Play DQXI instead, which is a masterclass.
Last edited:
It really is. An utter design idiotic moment, and you're at the mercy of the stupid AI.
cireza
Member
Your post was kinda OK until I read this. DQ XI is unplayable because of the shit music alone. It is as bland and generic as RPGs get.
Last edited:
Shake Your Rump
Banned
It seems like a joke, but you are absolutely correct. I never did finish XI. I think I was halfway through. A few months ago, I thought I would give it another try. As soon as I heard the overworld music, I just shut the game off. I can't fathom going through another few dozen hours of that.
I hear and have heard the argument about the DQ XI music, and of course that's subjective, but I really liked it. Even aside from the music in EITHER game then, DQXI's story and character arcs and voice acting and dialogue and the way it actually RESPECTS your time is in another league. It's rare a game leaves me angry for spending 30 hours on it, but Vision of Mana accomplished it. It's a by-the-numbers generic RPG. Literally just landscapes with some random monsters dotted around, with annoying load times, and a complete disrespect for the player when it comes to side quests and idiotic/pointless cutscenes that break in the middle, have you walk forward a few feet, just to bash you over the head with another cutscene.
ALSO, the number of let's-blind-the-player fade to pure white backgrounds is just on another level. Perhaps the worst I've seen. And did anyone even use the mount? What a waste of time.
Anyway, this game sucks. I'd describe it as... GRIZZLY!
ShadyAcshuns
Member
Is this thang on sale yet?
cireza
Member
You could have easily seen this with the demo. I did, and decided to skip the game. I am currently playing Trials of Mana and it is the far superior game.
DragoonKain
Neighbours from Hell
I started this game last week and so far I think it's solid, but isn't wowing me in any way. The most annoying thing by far is how there are still tutorials like 5+ hours into the game. I fucking hate when games do this. Enough interrupting me already, my god.
I think the combat is ok, I'm a little bored by it tbh. The world design is better than I expected, I'm actually having the most fun going around and collecting everything.
Overall so far a solid game that I'm not foaming at the mouth to play, but I like it enough.
I think the combat is ok, I'm a little bored by it tbh. The world design is better than I expected, I'm actually having the most fun going around and collecting everything.
Overall so far a solid game that I'm not foaming at the mouth to play, but I like it enough.
Doomtrain
Gold Member
What was the overall consensus on this? I loved Trials, but people seem more lukewarm on this one so far. I was considering making this one of my next RPG playthroughs, but reading through the last page of this thread, I'm not so sure anymore.
Also, can anyone confirm if enemies actually do scale with the player? That's a pet peeve of mine and a big nope if so.
Also, can anyone confirm if enemies actually do scale with the player? That's a pet peeve of mine and a big nope if so.
Shake Your Rump
Banned
I'd advise against playing this. I also really enjoyed Trials. This is nothing like that. I found it bland and tedious. I quit 23 hours in, and I wanted to quit earlier, but I kept trying. I recall leaving some city and seeing yet another huge field of those goddamn grizzly honey and boring enemies, so I shut it down. Traded my copy into GameStop for $35.
There are many games more worth your time. This isn't worth playing even if you pay nothing.
There are many games more worth your time. This isn't worth playing even if you pay nothing.
DonkeyPunchJr
World’s Biggest Weeb
I think it would’ve been much better without all the pointless open world exploration and quests. I would much rather have a focused ~25 hour game like Trials of Mana.
Soooo often you will leave town A for town B, spend an hour exploring the zone in between and getting all the treasures etc, reach town B… then get a bunch of sidequests that send you right back into that zone you explored. And none of the objectives are attainable until after you’ve accepted the quest, even if it’s a “kill 5 of this monster” type quest and you’ve already killed way more than that.
The story/writing/characters are all pretty bland and generic. Not terrible but nothing memorable either. And they talk too damn much.
Combat is fun but it got repetitive and the enemies can be very spongy.
The class system was cool but it felt like a missed opportunity. I wish you could mix and match abilities from different classes (I guess you finally can do this in the postgame). As it is, you basically just pick whichever class is your favorite and stick with it the entire game unless there’s some elemental ability you need. And Morley’s starting Luna class is so OP there’s almost no reason to ever change it.
Overall it’s not terrible, just mediocre. Maybe give it a shot if it’s on sale.
And no enemies don’t scale to your level, except for these little optional challenges you can do.
Soooo often you will leave town A for town B, spend an hour exploring the zone in between and getting all the treasures etc, reach town B… then get a bunch of sidequests that send you right back into that zone you explored. And none of the objectives are attainable until after you’ve accepted the quest, even if it’s a “kill 5 of this monster” type quest and you’ve already killed way more than that.
The story/writing/characters are all pretty bland and generic. Not terrible but nothing memorable either. And they talk too damn much.
Combat is fun but it got repetitive and the enemies can be very spongy.
The class system was cool but it felt like a missed opportunity. I wish you could mix and match abilities from different classes (I guess you finally can do this in the postgame). As it is, you basically just pick whichever class is your favorite and stick with it the entire game unless there’s some elemental ability you need. And Morley’s starting Luna class is so OP there’s almost no reason to ever change it.
Overall it’s not terrible, just mediocre. Maybe give it a shot if it’s on sale.
And no enemies don’t scale to your level, except for these little optional challenges you can do.
jshackles
Gentlemen, we can rebuild it. We have the capability to make the world's first enhanced store. Steam will be that store. Better than it was before.
I would recommend the Romancing SaGa 2 over this one, all day every day.
I enjoyed Visions of Mana a lot, but as others said it's pretty bland and the class system is a bit of a letdown.
I enjoyed Visions of Mana a lot, but as others said it's pretty bland and the class system is a bit of a letdown.
darth.shrimp
Member
I think some of you guys are a bit tto harsh lol; It had been a while since a game made me play until 1 or 2am without noticing the time, so I'm going to say I enjoyed it quite a bit. Actually I enjoyed it more than space Marine 2, and maybe even Echoes of Wisdom.
SkylineRKR
Member
The demo bored me to tears. Mainly the obligatory open world and traversal. I like the Mana franchise a ton, but I would've wished they kind of went for a 2D approach with this one.
I think Trials was better. It has more focused design. I also think LoM remaster is better. I took a guide and beat that game like it was y2k again.
I think Trials was better. It has more focused design. I also think LoM remaster is better. I took a guide and beat that game like it was y2k again.
sigmaZ
Member
All of this. I'd kill for a new HD2D original mana game similar in tone to "Trials".