This post is going to be my impressions from memory. I'm looking at the thing on the front page with all the players so if I leave someone out, it's not because I forgot about them but because they have flown under my radar so much that I have nothing to say about them
Stanleypalmtree - Has met his posting requirement but is not actively participating, a safe lynch target because we can't fall back on him getting replaced but we know nothing about him - Null read
UltraJay - Has been generally around and optimistic about participating. Tries to breed discussion but isn't getting much of anything going. I read overeager town from him for now - Leaning Town
Trigger - Was really under my radar for awhile but the "I am town!" post and Squidy kind of reaffirming my own suspicion has put him towards scum side for me. The best way to put it is really to echo Squidy, this player cares more about their appearance than hunting scum and that is usually a dead give away of a first time mafia - Leaning Scum
Unmasked Ferret - Dude is as smooth as silk and for that I'm treating him as a dangerous entity. This is the player that I feel like I won't ever be able to pin down with reads until it is too late and because of that I am going to be skeptical of him all game. I'm sure I'm not the only one thinking that though so this seems like a prime framer target if there is one in play. Investigators beware if you want to check him, just my two cents. - Leaning Scum
Darklighter - You can read my description for Stanley above, I have the same thoughts here - Null Read
Boo Boo'n - I pressed him for awhile today and so far I haven't seen anything particularly scummy come out of the press. Am I sold that he is town? Nah but I'm less sure that he is scum now. - Neutral Read (meaning he could go either way, I'm not saying he is neutral aligned)
TL21xx - The Scrafty slip up from earlier today in his reads list does not sit well with me. Reads lists are more of a chore for scum because they already know who the good and bad guys are, they are more likely to have inconsistencies or safe choices because they aren't trying to piece together the puzzle like we are. Mix that with some other inconsistencies like saying that his RNG vote was just there as a beginning of day type deal and then defending it later as a reason to hold his vote on Seath or Setre or whoever, it just all smells like crap to me. - Leaning Scum, this is where I am voting right now.
Ty4on - I had a little thing with him early in the day phase because he was my RNG target but I did actually attempt to extract information from him. He did engage me when I had a vote on him but I notice he slipped off the map once he didn't have that motivation on him anymore. I could very much believe that this was a scum lurking back to the shadows. Keeping my eyes on you - Leaning Scum
Pop-O-Matic - Always quiet, and I'm not surprised at that at all but today has seemed particularly heavy on the fluff and standing back. I still find his Scrafty vote odd but I don't disagree with it. Her character gets in the way of making a proper read on her and it is distracting. That being said though, Pop is another one that I feel cares more about appearances than helping town. - Leaning Scum
AbsolutBro - Very quiet but has been helpful in most/all of his posts. Having a big post count like me isn't a requirement to being a good and helpful townie. Absolut has been quality over quantity for sure and I've been appreciating that all day - Leaning Town
Mike_Hawk - Mostly getting a null read from him. He deflects a lot but has also interjected some sage advice here and there when it comes to other players or thoughts on game/mechanics. - Null read
Mazre - Honestly, I almost didn't put you on my list but you are playing the exact same as Archer from what I remember and your reads seem mostly solid. That's really all I have to say. - Leaning Town
Razmos - I did go back over your posts earlier today with what Squidy said in mind but I'm still not feeling the same as him. I think you are acting super guarded because of past trauma (caused by squidy apparently) but I'm not seeing anything one way or another from you. Will be watching - Null Read
Scrafty - Oh Scrafty, I don't know what to think about you. You believe that your vote HAS to be on a contender for some reason and that got me in MGS but you still believe it here. Ignoring that because even though I find it scummy, it seems like that is your play style, past that I still didn't like your reasoning for switching the Dark vote, it was an inconsistency from earlier in the day and you didn't even try to play it off as a mistake or anything. You were leaning scum but you've come back center for now - Neutral Read (meaning I could see her either way, not that I think she is neutral aligned).
Seath - Fireblend is already berating him for that shitty claim as I write this. As far as reads go, this is a null but that unneeded claim is policy lynch territory for me. - Null Read policy lynch
Coppa - Has been generally helpful and insightful as the day has been going. Did pop in earlier today to say that he would post more but never did, that is kind of suspect but otherwise has seemed to be on the ball. Super helpful Coppa was neutral in MGS though so I have to be careful but - Leaning Town
Squidy - I don't know. On the surface, he is here to catch scum. You can see if when he actually posts which has felt pretty sparse and I recall him being a lot more enthralled with the game as a town member in gafia and Archer. I'm leaning scum on a gut level but not enough where I would feel comfortable voting for him. he is an asset for whatever team he is on and losing him early if he is town could be detrimental. - Neutral read (could go eitehr way, don't mean alignment)
Fireblend - A lot of the same as Coppa, just generally helpful and insightful. My only issue here is that I have felt like me and him have been echos of each other on almost every policy today. We have had similar play styles in the past so it isn't the end of the world but it's something I need to keep an eye on because I may not be able to make proper reads when I'm being mirrored like this. - Leaning Town
gryvan - I explained this a little earlier but he is playing like someone who has no communication outside of this chat. That doesn't excuse him from being scum since we have seen scum players that were divided from their team in other cases but he doesn't appear to be a part of the main contingent to me. - Leaning Town
That being said, this is the list of players that I am willing to vote for today. Barring no extravagantly new information, I will not be voting outside of this block so if you chucklefucks (couldn't help myself
) decide to bring someone else to the forefront, don't expect my vote to help unless it has to break a tie.
Stanleypaltree, Trigger, Ferret, Darklighter, Boo Boo'N, Tl21xx, Ty4on, Pop, Mike_Hawk, Razmos, Scrafty, or Seath
That being said, for the reasons that I posted above, this is the person I will be pressing towards death today from here on out until I see a reason not to.
VOTE: TL21xx
Stanleypalmtree - Has met his posting requirement but is not actively participating, a safe lynch target because we can't fall back on him getting replaced but we know nothing about him - Null read
UltraJay - Has been generally around and optimistic about participating. Tries to breed discussion but isn't getting much of anything going. I read overeager town from him for now - Leaning Town
Trigger - Was really under my radar for awhile but the "I am town!" post and Squidy kind of reaffirming my own suspicion has put him towards scum side for me. The best way to put it is really to echo Squidy, this player cares more about their appearance than hunting scum and that is usually a dead give away of a first time mafia - Leaning Scum
Unmasked Ferret - Dude is as smooth as silk and for that I'm treating him as a dangerous entity. This is the player that I feel like I won't ever be able to pin down with reads until it is too late and because of that I am going to be skeptical of him all game. I'm sure I'm not the only one thinking that though so this seems like a prime framer target if there is one in play. Investigators beware if you want to check him, just my two cents. - Leaning Scum
Darklighter - You can read my description for Stanley above, I have the same thoughts here - Null Read
Boo Boo'n - I pressed him for awhile today and so far I haven't seen anything particularly scummy come out of the press. Am I sold that he is town? Nah but I'm less sure that he is scum now. - Neutral Read (meaning he could go either way, I'm not saying he is neutral aligned)
TL21xx - The Scrafty slip up from earlier today in his reads list does not sit well with me. Reads lists are more of a chore for scum because they already know who the good and bad guys are, they are more likely to have inconsistencies or safe choices because they aren't trying to piece together the puzzle like we are. Mix that with some other inconsistencies like saying that his RNG vote was just there as a beginning of day type deal and then defending it later as a reason to hold his vote on Seath or Setre or whoever, it just all smells like crap to me. - Leaning Scum, this is where I am voting right now.
Ty4on - I had a little thing with him early in the day phase because he was my RNG target but I did actually attempt to extract information from him. He did engage me when I had a vote on him but I notice he slipped off the map once he didn't have that motivation on him anymore. I could very much believe that this was a scum lurking back to the shadows. Keeping my eyes on you - Leaning Scum
Pop-O-Matic - Always quiet, and I'm not surprised at that at all but today has seemed particularly heavy on the fluff and standing back. I still find his Scrafty vote odd but I don't disagree with it. Her character gets in the way of making a proper read on her and it is distracting. That being said though, Pop is another one that I feel cares more about appearances than helping town. - Leaning Scum
AbsolutBro - Very quiet but has been helpful in most/all of his posts. Having a big post count like me isn't a requirement to being a good and helpful townie. Absolut has been quality over quantity for sure and I've been appreciating that all day - Leaning Town
Mike_Hawk - Mostly getting a null read from him. He deflects a lot but has also interjected some sage advice here and there when it comes to other players or thoughts on game/mechanics. - Null read
Mazre - Honestly, I almost didn't put you on my list but you are playing the exact same as Archer from what I remember and your reads seem mostly solid. That's really all I have to say. - Leaning Town
Razmos - I did go back over your posts earlier today with what Squidy said in mind but I'm still not feeling the same as him. I think you are acting super guarded because of past trauma (caused by squidy apparently) but I'm not seeing anything one way or another from you. Will be watching - Null Read
Scrafty - Oh Scrafty, I don't know what to think about you. You believe that your vote HAS to be on a contender for some reason and that got me in MGS but you still believe it here. Ignoring that because even though I find it scummy, it seems like that is your play style, past that I still didn't like your reasoning for switching the Dark vote, it was an inconsistency from earlier in the day and you didn't even try to play it off as a mistake or anything. You were leaning scum but you've come back center for now - Neutral Read (meaning I could see her either way, not that I think she is neutral aligned).
Seath - Fireblend is already berating him for that shitty claim as I write this. As far as reads go, this is a null but that unneeded claim is policy lynch territory for me. - Null Read policy lynch
Coppa - Has been generally helpful and insightful as the day has been going. Did pop in earlier today to say that he would post more but never did, that is kind of suspect but otherwise has seemed to be on the ball. Super helpful Coppa was neutral in MGS though so I have to be careful but - Leaning Town
Squidy - I don't know. On the surface, he is here to catch scum. You can see if when he actually posts which has felt pretty sparse and I recall him being a lot more enthralled with the game as a town member in gafia and Archer. I'm leaning scum on a gut level but not enough where I would feel comfortable voting for him. he is an asset for whatever team he is on and losing him early if he is town could be detrimental. - Neutral read (could go eitehr way, don't mean alignment)
Fireblend - A lot of the same as Coppa, just generally helpful and insightful. My only issue here is that I have felt like me and him have been echos of each other on almost every policy today. We have had similar play styles in the past so it isn't the end of the world but it's something I need to keep an eye on because I may not be able to make proper reads when I'm being mirrored like this. - Leaning Town
gryvan - I explained this a little earlier but he is playing like someone who has no communication outside of this chat. That doesn't excuse him from being scum since we have seen scum players that were divided from their team in other cases but he doesn't appear to be a part of the main contingent to me. - Leaning Town
That being said, this is the list of players that I am willing to vote for today. Barring no extravagantly new information, I will not be voting outside of this block so if you chucklefucks (couldn't help myself
) decide to bring someone else to the forefront, don't expect my vote to help unless it has to break a tie.Stanleypaltree, Trigger, Ferret, Darklighter, Boo Boo'N, Tl21xx, Ty4on, Pop, Mike_Hawk, Razmos, Scrafty, or Seath
That being said, for the reasons that I posted above, this is the person I will be pressing towards death today from here on out until I see a reason not to.
VOTE: TL21xx
