Support NeoGAF

[Gunstar77]

A true HD version of PSO or Monster Hunters that is not just another port.

 

[Enco]

Worldwide GTA with an airport that lets you travel between cities and countries.

You also get to play inside the airplane and you can crash it and jump out.

 

[herzogzwei1989]

Phantasy Star V
Herzog Zwei 2
Daytona USA 3
Military Madness 3
Altered Beast 2

 

[krYlon]

My dream game would be an adventure game with:

Ys combat and bosses
Zelda puzzles and level design
90s Lucasarts dialogue and story
Team ICO atmosphere and animation

 

[Fine Ham Abounds]

I've always pondered an open world Classic Mega Man game, not really like the Legends games. Unobtrusive minimalist story, destructible environment, just exploring a large varied landscape with enemies who are weak to various abilities. Also, getting terrain traversing/manipulating skills from bosses as well as weapons.

A large city full of NPCs with quests and a large world where you free portions of the map by beating the bosses who control them, with lots of secrets and hidden side quests scattered around. Also, beating bosses creates changes in other bosses' areas a la Mega Man X.

 

[VonRehausen]

SMAC 2

 

[ii Stryker]

An unbuggy and highly balanced Skyrim

 

[Violater]

PSi Ops 2

 

[Kambing]

An AAA budget Fullmetal Alchemist open world RPG game. Damn, i need to start collecting my monnies to do this!

 

[RPG_Fanatic]

A new D&D game that plays like Temple of Elemental Evil.
Multiple campaigns, including a high level campaign, with prestige classes like in Neverwinter Nights. The level cap can be increased to 30.

A really want a new big-budget D&D game, that isn't a MMO.

 

[someguyinahat]

An RPG set in modern day, in a real-world set-to-scale town. It doesn't even have to be a huge town: 25-50K people would do. No need to go full Toronto or New York. The trick is to get as many actual houses, stores, institutions, etc. on board as possible. You'd go around helping various people, get jobs, buy up properties and eventually uncover a main quest plot: maybe there's organized crime or an underground cult, and you can choose which side to be on.

So I guess it would be like a real-world GTA style game with Skyrim or Fallout: New Vegas openness, and maybe a dash of Silent Hill.

 

[Shinjiru]

Shenmue 3
Final Fantasy VII HD Remake
Final Fantasy VI HD Remake

 

[EloquentM]

Metroid dread

 

[Berksy]

Highlander: The Videogame

But in a good way.

 

[ezekial45]

1. Bayonetta X Devil May Cry (with original Dante, cause he's a better fit): Two different storylines with both characters, featuring their own bosses, weapons and characters. Both campaigns culminate to the Co-Op mode where you clear through new missions and face off against harder bosses.

2. Open World One Piece game: It would be like a cross between Wind Waker and Skies of Arcadia. It would be pretty awesome, I'd say.

An unbuggy and highly balanced Skyrim

Just wait a couple years for the modders to handle it.

 

[Lyonaz]

A Space Opera Combat Flight Dating Sim.

You start at an interstellar flight academy and choose your path, either to become an Ace Pilot or Fleet Commander. During the academy years the game turns into social RPG like Persona 3/4. You attend classes, socialize, date people and get flight training. It's all third person view like Uncharted.

Depending on your path choice, gameplay changes for the Interstellar War portion of the game.
For the Ace Pilot path,the game is like Rogue Squadron when the battles are fought on a planet and like Freespace 2 when in space.
For Fleet Commander path it plays like Homeworld, more rts like.

The game should feel like Macross when battles are fought, Missile Barrages, awesome mechas, sexy fighter jets and radio chatter with pilots bickering over their personal teen dramas and atleast one popsong played during an important battle.