• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Winter 2012 Anime Thread 2.22: You Can (Not) Outpost Cajunator

Status
Not open for further replies.

Defuser

Member
Daily Lives of Highschool Boys ep 6
Poor Tadakuni,always get left out on something even if it's related to his family lol. I love how the Student Council replaces the original trio for this episode,moar Karasawa!!
 

LegatoB

Member
Anncast Sexism Episode 2/10/2012 (I think this fits here?)
The more I think about the things in this podcast the more confused I am. How is Mirai Nikki sexist? The whole show is based around two people who need each other to survive. This is augmented with a strain on that relationship by the psychotic inducing trauma one of the two had, but nothing about the show really strikes me as painting one gender in a specific way.
I don't think it's particularly controversial to say, as the guest on the show did, that if Yuno had been a male character acting the same way toward a female character that she does in this show (abducting them, holding them against their will, requiring them to relieve themself in humiliating but "necessary" way, etc.) that viewers probably would've been outraged. She didn't say you were a bad person for watching and enjoying this show.
 

/XX/

Member
Go the hard way, because you will miss so many great shows if you just watch the animeGAF recommendations.
At least that can be easily solved. With the variety of members in here helping we could certainly recommend a pretty big spectrum of works of all types. You, PdotMichael, are included in that mission, of course!

School Days is simply the second best anime ever made after Infinite Stratos.
moot, is that you?
 

madp

The Light of El Cantare
FMA milos finale spoilers



but isn't it stated right at the end? On the train Ed says to Mustang that Ashley wasn't actually dead, so that wasn't human transmutation after all. Also remember there was no "eye". I guess the Gate glimpse was actually that, a glimpse and not a full-immersion-meet-Truth-kun like Ed and the others have. Julia paid both with the exhaustion of her PS (something like Pride when using dead-Gold Tooth to perform human transmutation) AND her leg 'cause the PS wasn't sufficient to restore health to her brother.

You know, this could have been the case, but I was raging too hard to really pay attention to any of the dialogue after
the escape
. I'll watch the ending again today and see if that conversation actually did take place.
 

DrForester

Kills Photobucket
If you guys are recommending anime to troll people, the only thing you should recommend is Melody of Oblivion, which is a glorious train wreck of failed ideas, bad planning, goofy fanservice, and an ending that just says "well, screw it".
 
Musings on Another 06:

Okay, I just realized that it's actually pretty much obvious why Mei was chosen to be the ignored person. Her cousin died on April 26th. She took her place at the beat-up corner desk on May 1st. During those few days, the class asked her to be the ignored person. Why?

Because her cousin died. Therefore, she could not be the Other, because one of her relatives died! She would therefore be the most obvious candidate for this unpleasant job, since they were certain she wasn't the Other. Furthermore she now knows the pain of losing a family member to the calamity and would be willing to sacrifice herself so that no one else in the class would have to endure such pain, or live in constant fear of death themselves.

The story about the class member 2 years ago who couldn't take the isolation anymore and declared he existed, restarting the calamity that year, is also instructive. The class had to be certain, and Mei had to be certain, that she could handle this burden for a whole year or risk disaster for everyone. In many ways Mei is the strongest of them all for willingly accepting this role. And she's unbelievably cute. <3
 

Blader

Member
Just realized that Madhouse's latest film, The Princess and the Pilot, hits blu in a couple weeks. Did anyone from Japan-GAF see the movie last year? Wondering if it's worth checking out, I've been looking for a good new animu film.
 

Haly

One day I realized that sadness is just another word for not enough coffee.
Daily Lives of Highschool Boys:
Should be retitled "Daily Lives of Student Council".

They are just miles beyond anyone else in the show.
 

Steroyd

Member
Daily Lives of Highschool Boys - 06

First half was okay 2nd half holy crap, so good.

I'll never look at Harry Potter the same way again when I look at it as a magical girl boy show.
 

hellclerk

Everything is tsundere to me
Daily Lives of High School BROS 6

I do not play with the title of my impressions lightly. These guys are bros incarnate. And I wasn't expecting it, but there was even just a tad of melancholy hnnng at the end there. Poor Habara... Well, who knows, maybe some bro will come to her aid.
 
Bakemonogatari Ep. 1

Very sweet style and presentation with beautiful visuals though the animations themselves aren't all that great. Story wise it seems alright. The writing is definitely top notch. Kinda confused at the female leads actions though. For some reason she thought
it was a smarter idea to threaten the main character with death to keep her secret before attempting to even ask nicely.
 

Articalys

Member
Single CD
*5, 14,060 14,060 Papa no Iukoto wo Kikinasai! "Happy Girl"
11, *9,599 *9,599 Ano Natsu de Matteru "sign"
12, *9,440 44,146 Nisemonogatari "Naisho no Hanashi"
13, *8,465 *8,465 Thermae Romae "Thermae Roman"
15, *6,345 *6,345 Senki Zesshou Symphogear "Meteor Light"
18, *5,090 *5,090 Highschool DxD "Study x Study"
20, *4,291 *4,291 Amagami SS+ plus "Kokuhaku"
27, *3,200 *3,200 Gintama' "Wonderland"
34, *2,381 *5,792 Amagami SS+ plus "Check my soul"
35, *2,325 10,096 Rinne no Lagrange "Try Unite!" "Hello!"
39, *2,146 19,717 Senki Zesshou Symphogear Character Song Series vol.1
46, *1,975 71,956 Senki Zesshou Symphogear "Synchrogazer"
50, *1,770 *1,770 Tantei Opera Milky Holmes Dai 2 Maku "Lovely Girls Anthem"
51, *1,757 *1,757 Mirai Nikki (TV) "filament"
52, *1,524 *1,524 True Tears "Prism Sign"
59, *1,325 12,016 Kill Me Baby "Kill me no Baby!" & "Futari no Kimochi no Honto no Himitsu"
66, *1,154 *5,018 Shakugan no Shana III (Final) "Serment"
67, *1,149 *1,149 Inazuma Eleven Go "Hajike-Yo!!"
72, *1,091 13,930 Papa no Iukoto wo Kikinasai! "Coloring"
76, *,976 *1,753 Berserk Ougon Jidaihen I: Haou no Tamago "Aria"

Album CD
*8, 13,921 13,921 Tiger & Bunny Character Song Album "Best of Hero"
27, *3,382 *3,382 Toradora! Best Album "&#8730;Happy End"
41, *2,081 43,738 Hatsune Miku Vocalodream
46, *1,910 18,610 Inazuma Eleven Go Character Song Original Album
47, *1,894 16,216 The iDOLM@STER Animation Master vol.7
 

Haly

One day I realized that sadness is just another word for not enough coffee.
If anything, I've always found that the least plausible thing in the movie, aside from the idea that anyone would design money you could injure people with, is that folk would rather join the Navy/Air Force to become jet pilots while the washouts went into space when in our reality it's quite the opposite. I don't have too much of a problem buying that sort of thing since it's the basic conceit of the plot within the alternate universe presented in the film, tho.
I think it's fair. Honneamise takes place in a world where Sputnik (or whatever the Honneamise equivalent is) never ignited the space race, although the details are too sparse to make any calls about this.

(Also, cylindrical forms of money exists. Wiki turns up a page for Tally Sticks. it's not too farfetched.)
If you'd ever worked a menial job you'd be less surprised at the type of people who espouse philosophically, I suppose, excluding totally incurious idiots - which I don't think anyone in the film quite is.
I hadn't considered it like that, it makes sense, even if it's probably not intended by the writers.
ETA: although, truthfully, I wasn't focussed on the philosophical musings of the characters last time around so I can't really speak to the believability of each or any particular one.
Yeah I tune them out as well, it's a just a reflex from listening to one too many animu inspirational speeches.

In other news, watching Planetes.
 

7Th

Member
"Properly animated" or not, I find difficult to deny how extremely cool in the animation department were some of the moments of Captain Tsubasa J, could you?

Those fucking endless fields, man. They run and run and run and they never get to the other side!
 

Noirulus

Member
Nichibros - 06

Opening skit was weak but thankfully it rebounded well!

i9ehZ.jpg

Saw it coming but it was still fucking hilarious. Poor Hidenori :(


bwahaha this was so damn stupid but I just couldn't stop laughing!


Highschool girls are funky wasn't at its usual level this time but goddamnit just listening to their voices induces laughter.
 

duckroll

Member
I watched Milos again, and having seen it twice now I can pretty accurately pin point the exact moment in the film where it starts to completely fall apart.

Right after Ashley kills Atlas brutally, which was an awesome scene, he does this "I'm the badass final boss" pose while standing on the landing above the characters, and starts making this speech about using the Truth to create a new world. I felt that was the exact moment where the movie suddenly shifted from a relatively above average action movie with a strong political focus, into a totally generic shounen fight movie.

You have Ed and Ashley arguing over totally pointless philosophies while fighting, while the "world" the movie is set in faces certain destruction if Al and Julia fail to stop the lava, etc. All the stakes are suddenly raised to insane levels and all the plot developments in that short span of time basically have nothing to do with the other 90 minutes of the film before it. Yeaaaaaah.
 

Blader

Member
Is this news?

tl,dr:
Miyazaki's next film is due out in 2013
Goro is working on his film, a samurai period piece
Anno is collaborating with Ghibli on a museum exhibit that may or may not be a new movie
 

Dresden

Member
Just realized that Madhouse's latest film, The Princess and the Pilot, hits blu in a couple weeks. Did anyone from Japan-GAF see the movie last year? Wondering if it's worth checking out, I've been looking for a good new animu film.

I don't think anyone on gaf saw it, but I heard it wasn't that good.
 

RurouniZel

Asks questions so Ezalc doesn't have to
Single CD
*5, 14,060 14,060 Papa no Iukoto wo Kikinasai! "Happy Girl"
11, *9,599 *9,599 Ano Natsu de Matteru "sign"
12, *9,440 44,146 Nisemonogatari "Naisho no Hanashi"
13, *8,465 *8,465 Thermae Romae "Thermae Roman"
15, *6,345 *6,345 Senki Zesshou Symphogear "Meteor Light"
18, *5,090 *5,090 Highschool DxD "Study x Study"
20, *4,291 *4,291 Amagami SS+ plus "Kokuhaku"
27, *3,200 *3,200 Gintama' "Wonderland"
34, *2,381 *5,792 Amagami SS+ plus "Check my soul"
35, *2,325 10,096 Rinne no Lagrange "Try Unite!" "Hello!"
39, *2,146 19,717 Senki Zesshou Symphogear Character Song Series vol.1
46, *1,975 71,956 Senki Zesshou Symphogear "Synchrogazer"
50, *1,770 *1,770 Tantei Opera Milky Holmes Dai 2 Maku "Lovely Girls Anthem"
51, *1,757 *1,757 Mirai Nikki (TV) "filament"
52, *1,524 *1,524 True Tears "Prism Sign"
59, *1,325 12,016 Kill Me Baby "Kill me no Baby!" & "Futari no Kimochi no Honto no Himitsu"
66, *1,154 *5,018 Shakugan no Shana III (Final) "Serment"
67, *1,149 *1,149 Inazuma Eleven Go "Hajike-Yo!!"
72, *1,091 13,930 Papa no Iukoto wo Kikinasai! "Coloring"
76, *,976 *1,753 Berserk Ougon Jidaihen I: Haou no Tamago "Aria"

Album CD
*8, 13,921 13,921 Tiger & Bunny Character Song Album "Best of Hero"
27, *3,382 *3,382 Toradora! Best Album "&#8730;Happy End"
41, *2,081 43,738 Hatsune Miku Vocalodream
46, *1,910 18,610 Inazuma Eleven Go Character Song Original Album
47, *1,894 16,216 The iDOLM@STER Animation Master vol.7

Well, we know what Otaku are watching. For better or worse.
 

darkside31337

Tomodachi wa Mahou
Sailor Moon 46:

Yeah. Not feeling this last episode or the conclusion, at all. It looked great but thats really all I got out of this.

The final battle scenes was top-notch stuff.
Mamoru and Usagi slugging it out was nice but the whole Queen Beryl / Metalia stuff was pretty lackluster.
But my real gripes come with the ending of the episode, with
Usagi calling upon the souls of her dead friends for help
, which is so tripe I couldn't help but laugh. And yeah its a Magical Girl anime all right with the
glorious reset at the very end.
I get that it just straight runs into the next season but the entire episode honestly feels lackluster and insignificant which is odd given the events that transpire in the episode itself. It honestly felt like it was just going through the motions, I haven't been so underwhelmed with an Ikuhara episode since last summer.

The season in general I enjoyed but it's pretty flawed. The pacing in the season is completely horrendous especially towards the end. Some episodes are absolutely enjoyable but a lot of the filler is complete dreck. Some of the characters in themselves feel completely pointless, Sailor Venus / Minako is a complete afterthought. All the other girls get significant development and screen time during the series but poor Minako is literally just there. She doesn't even seem to have any significant relationships with any of the other girls at least thats how I take it from the show.

I'd give the first season 7.5 dumpling heads out of 10.

But most importantly,

Rei > Makoto > Ami > Minako > Usagi.
 

dimb

Bjergsen is the greatest midlane in the world
I don't think it's particularly controversial to say, as the guest on the show did, that if Yuno had been a male character acting the same way toward a female character that she does in this show (abducting them, holding them against their will, requiring them to relieve themself in humiliating but "necessary" way, etc.) that viewers probably would've been outraged. She didn't say you were a bad person for watching and enjoying this show.
Setting up alternate realities in which people are or are not outraged over such an imaginary scenario is a rather absurd and meaningless concept to me. Trying to connect dots where there are none is fairly illogical, and yes, her point does become that people should be getting outraged about how the Yuno character works. It's setting her values on top of other people and asking them to comply and see things her way or be sexist.

I also don't really get the point of bringing it up. It has nothing to do with the content of the story, but rather everything to do with reaction and perception of it, which can only be based around anecdotal evidence and fabrication. Their hopeless blame game turns from targeting the creators to targeting viewers, who evidently are not reacting to the piece of media in a manner that isn't sexist.
 
Is School Days actively bad, though? It's a "troll" anime in that the content is pretty horrifying, but does that negate any other qualities it may actually have? Do people regret having watched it in the end?
If you asked me to point out what's good about it, I don't think I could come up with anything, but at the same time I can't bring myself to call it legitimately bad or "so bad it's good."

If nothing else, the writer did an excellent job of letting the characters drive the plot and not the other way around. It just so happens that the characters have absolutely no right to be operating a vehicle.
 

Hitokage

Setec Astronomer
Hmm, I guess I can't imagine why space travel would not hold its own romantic appeal independent of the space race.
"Why spend money on space when we have problems here?"

Americans stopped caring about the moon after we beat the Russians. Americans today still think 0.5% is too big a share of the federal budget for NASA. Why is it so far fetched that some other group of people would also fail to see the point?

Also, jets are pretty expensive too.
 

Envelope

sealed with a kiss
Sailor Moon 46:

Yeah. Not feeling this last episode or the conclusion, at all. It looked great but thats really all I got out of this.

The final battle scenes was top-notch stuff.
Mamoru and Usagi slugging it out was nice but the whole Queen Beryl / Metalia stuff was pretty lackluster.
But my real gripes come with the ending of the episode, with
Usagi calling upon the souls of her dead friends for help
, which is so tripe I couldn't help but laugh. And yeah its a Magical Girl anime all right with the
glorious reset at the very end.
I get that it just straight runs into the next season but the entire episode honestly feels lackluster and insignificant which is odd given the events that transpire in the episode itself. It honestly felt like it was just going through the motions, I haven't been so underwhelmed with an Ikuhara episode since last summer.

The season in general I enjoyed but it's pretty flawed. The pacing in the season is completely horrendous especially towards the end. Some episodes are absolutely enjoyable but a lot of the filler is complete dreck. Some of the characters in themselves feel completely pointless, Sailor Venus / Minako is a complete afterthought. All the other girls get significant development and screen time during the series but poor Minako is literally just there. She doesn't even seem to have any significant relationships with any of the other girls at least thats how I take it from the show.

I'd give the first season 7.5 dumpling heads out of 10.

But most importantly,

Rei > Makoto > Ami > Minako > Usagi.


No pictures?

How disappointing.

Not sure Usagi belongs last, either, but I can let that slide since you finally started watching Sailor Moon again. Now onto R!
 

Jex

Member
Wings of Honnêamise

I don't know what to write here. It is a masterpiece, but for some reason I didn't enjoy it that much. The only time I really felt like the movie had a hold on me was toward the end,
when they were racing against time to launch. I teared up a bit at the end, before the Gainax montage, which I felt was out of place.

Your words are as empty as your soul :(
 

RurouniZel

Asks questions so Ezalc doesn't have to
outsold in a single week by papa something something's ED--how sad.

Yep, it's sad. As I mentioned, for better or worse their choice of singles is very informative of what Otaku are watching. ( ´&#1044;`)y&#9473;&#65381;~~
 

Envelope

sealed with a kiss
I'm not American, and my own country has no realistic hope of ever bothering with a space program of our own, so I don't really care! My soul is dead anyway.

I'm disappointed in you now. At least Hito cares about what's really important!
 
So I haven't ventured into Anime-GAF since the Fall 2011 topic, and the only new show I've watched from then was HxH. I remember being interested in Guilty Crown. According to what I've read around, I guess shouldn't be anymore?

I would say it's been great recently but virtually all of animegaf disagees with me. You could still check it out if you want.
 

Jex

Member
I'm pretty sure if we can get the money together to make the actual thing, he would be happy to work for little to no pay! Still gotta pay everyone else though.

People demanding to be paid is the real cancer killing the anime industry.
 

Envelope

sealed with a kiss
I would say it's been great recently but virtually all of animegaf disagees with me. You could still check it out if you want.

It's a trainwreck, but it's not entertaining, and that's the key difference between something like Guilty Crown and something like Glass Fleet or Code Geass.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom