• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Winter Anime 2015 |OT| ZA WARUDO is not square!

Status
Not open for further replies.

cajunator

Banned
Denki-Gai, from last season, is the closest I can think of right now. Might be a bit lewd for someone relatively new to anime, though.

Denki Gai is pretty adorable and sorta manga related I suppose but really nowhere near like Nozaki kun. It is, however, pretty fun to watch.

Whoever you made a watch-bet with is a good person. Tsuritama is still in my top ten of the last few years.

Agreed. A temporary stay of mercy it seems. Consider yourself fortunate!

Kancolle - 01

Yes! I loved this shit. When I heard they posses souls of warships I expected them to look like this in battle;


So I'm kinda disappointed that they just surf on the water with some gear on. But the concept of firing warplanes from your bow and surfing moe girls firing weapons and submarine missiles at bad guys is something I can get behind.
Surprised to see them launches. Some spotty cg stuff kinda threw me off a bit though. I don't know much of whats going on but I will definitely keep watching this.

It wasnt working for me earlier but seems to be fine now. Gonna watch it in a second.

[Yuri Kuma Arashi] - 1

I think it's fair to say that, over time, Ikhuara's works have transitioned from relatively normal stories with a few very stylized elements to extremely stylized works with very few elements of normal storytelling. It's pretty funny that at this point Revolutionary Girl Utena feels 'quaint' and 'restrained' to something like Penguin Drum which itself pales before Yuri Kuma Arashi. I know that I'm simplifying things quite a bit here, but you get my idea. This first episode does not feel very 'consume friendly'.

It's not wise to draw any conclusions right away and things might change in a few episodes, but for now it feels like traditional ideas of characterisation and even pacing have been pushed aside to allow the show to dive right into Ikuhara's very unusual vision. I don't think that you should be sacrificing characterisation in an attempt to bathe in melodrama and symbolism, but Ikuhara clearly made that choice here as this episodes rushes along at 100 miles an hour. We're swept from event to unusual event in a whirlwind and given no time to breathe.

Theories abound as to why this might be. Penguin Drum certainly felt like a three-cour series told in two-cours, so could this be a two-cour show shoved into a single cour? Considering how long Ikuhara has taken between projects it's conceivable that he just never got the funding to make the shows the length he wanted and instead just squeezes his material down to fit whatever runtime he can work with. If this was true it would certainly explain a lot about his recent works, but it doesn't excuse the problems with Penguin Drum and this first episode.

Perhaps we're all jumping the gun here and the next few episodes will pull things back somewhat to actually develop the characters to the point where we are actually invested in them. I certainly hope so but even if it doesn't happen this will still be something I look forward to watching every week because nothing else is like it.

There really isnt anything like an Ikuhara work. They stick out like sore thumbs but in a good way. If nothing else, the shows are fascinating and told in a very unique way.
This one in particular does seem to be paced extremely quickly but I have been able to make sense of it thus far. Cant really complain.


Added to the list.
 
Took them long enough. It's one of the better shows out this season so far.

It hasn't officially had its premiere yet, it should be mentioned. There was just the pre-air of episode 1 on Bandai Channel. But yet, I'll agree that it's the best first episode of the new season available out there so far.
 

Midonin

Member
One very big reason I don't do pre-airs is because they leave out the OP and ED. What's the point of watching an episode early if there's no theme songs to set the mood?
 

Pancakes

hot, steaming, as melted butter slips into the cracks, drizzled with sticky sweet syrup OH GOD
Kantai Collection 1 - Naah. Not for me. seems that the girls and military vehicles subgenre does not work for me (with the exception of Arpeggio). This one in concept is just a wee bit too silly for me.

Oh damn, this actually got an anime adaption? Might need to watch if doesn't turn out to be complete garbage.

Manga smut >>> Anime smut

Was there ever any doubt?
 
Parasyte 13

Getting real tired of the Murano subplot. To much needless drama in a series that's already dramatic enough. I do want to learn more about how the parasites essentially run society now.
 

Grexeno

Member
Rage of Bahamut: Genesis Episode 1

There is no way this series can maintain this level of quality in animation and sound, can it?
 

Blusby

Member
you mean Prison School

who the fuck calls it Kangoku Gakuen

Non-casuals

Kan Colle 01:
Made it 6 or 7 mins into the episode before exiting the tab, dropped. I expected it to at least put some of the more relatively interesting designs in focus like Bismarck, Takao, etc but no it instead focuses around bland, shitty lolis lol.
 
Rage of Bahamut: Genesis Episode 1

There is no way this series can maintain this level of quality in animation and sound, can it?

Sadly you are correct ) :

Edit: About Kantai, I seriously doubt I will watch the second episode, and will continue unknowingly saving pixiv pics of boat girls
 

Thoraxes

Member
I know Babbitt and those of his ilk view music as some sort of scientific research that should be locked away in an ivory tower for academics to ponder upon in abstraction, but I just can't sympathize with that view. I think art is about expressing something, and to express something you need to speak in a language your audience can grasp. Which is not to say I'm against works that challenge an audience - Messiaen is my second-favorite composer after all, and he's not a simplistic crowd-pleaser by any means - but I think there ideally should be an honest intent to communicate on the part of the artist and an honest intent to understand on the part of the audience. Only then can the conditions for the realization of the ultimate purpose of art arise.

Perhaps some of my perspective is influenced by me being a performer as opposed to a composer/director/writer/etc. A performer is nothing if he doesn't have an audience to perform to.
I can totally understand your viewpoints and where you're coming from. And yeah, I think you're right that our viewpoints are likely influenced by us coming from each of those perspectives. It would definitely explain a lot about my tastes!

I appreciate that you took the time to explain your viewpoints in a rational manner to me though! I always love these kinds of exchanges.
 
Non-casuals

Kan Colle 01:
Made it 6 or 7 mins into the episode before exiting the tab, dropped. I expected it to at least put some of the more relatively interesting designs in focus like Bismarck, Takao, etc but no it instead focuses around bland, shitty lolis lol.
With classics like Kongou, Akagi, Atago, Nagato and Yamato who needs flavor of the month Bismarck? Plus she's an allied ship why would she show up on the first episode? She'd probably show up somewhere mid season or near the end.


~wan
 
Kantai Collection 1

This was awful. It has nothing to offer to people who aren't already fans of the original material, and after watching this, I have no idea why those people exist.

The worldbuilding is incredibly thin, and the characterization is even worse. Maybe the fleet girls outside of Third Torpedo have some excuse (I think Kaga has two lines, and the second is a repetition of the first), but even most of the main group are less than paper-thin. Like Sendai. She likes night battles. And?



It's an incredibly cynical show, trying to offer moe for everyone by just saturating the cast with every single type they can think of at its very shallowest. The lengths the show goes through to hide the Admiral's face (such as making the secretary ship command the battles) makes its charade even more transparent.

If I never watch another episode of this, it'll be too soon.
So slightly better than Strike Witches?
 

Narag

Member
@Crunchyroll
News: Crunchyroll to Stream "JoJo’s Bizarre Adventure: Stardust Crusaders - Battle in Egypt" Anime. Starts Jan/9.
 
@Crunchyroll
News: Crunchyroll to Stream "JoJo’s Bizarre Adventure: Stardust Crusaders - Battle in Egypt" Anime. Starts Jan/9.

Lb8SSFn.png
 

Soma

Member
Manga is superior because there is Kangoku Gakuen on that media.

End of story.

Do not google it if you are at work.

Worlds will collide once the anime adaption is out.

(Even if it will be an inferior product)

(Also no new info on the anime is kinda troubling)
 

Midonin

Member
Friday has Cinderella Girls in the morning and PriPara at night. Talk about whatever you want, but my day is bookended with idols.
 
will continue unknowingly saving pixiv pics of boat girls

ditto. Figured they would loli it up, sad to be right.

Speaking of lolis!

Girls Und Panzer 01-08
Gotta admit... not bad. Heck I might even say I like it so far. The non tank drama is pretty meh, but thankfully this is clearly made for the military tank history otaku crowd so its such a backburner part of the show its not an issue.

Appreciate the amount of tank porn in this show and distinct lack of fan service that I assumed this would have and avoided it. Tank battles are pretty well done and the actual girls themselves are simple enough that they are not annoying... aside from the main character. For w/e reason I don't like her.
 
I can totally understand your viewpoints and where you're coming from. And yeah, I think you're right that our viewpoints are likely influenced by us coming from each of those perspectives. It would definitely explain a lot about my tastes!

I appreciate that you took the time to explain your viewpoints in a rational manner to me though! I always love these kinds of exchanges.

As do I.

Worlds will collide once the anime adaption is out.

(Even if it will be an inferior product)

(Also no new info on the anime is kinda troubling)

Eh, often after an anime adaptation of a manga or whatever is announced there'll be a period of months or even a year before more information is given about it. I don't think it means anything one way or another.
 
Cross posting:

Just watched Kancolle. The two girls with antennas (though they looked like insects) were beautiful, and the background art was superb. The other girls are pretty meh, except for Yuudachi IMO. Also, there is one girl who fires airplanes? Really?

Best girl is the one with the antenna and brown hair, she never spoke a word but managed to entice me.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom