• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Winter of Anime 2013 |OT -6| How much lower can we go?!

Status
Not open for further replies.

Theonik

Member
Extollere's is better than some of the professional anime stuff.
To be fair to professional anime stuff Extollere doesn't have to pop those out in 5 minutes while spending a week sleeping under his desk eating instant ramen noodles. Now if he does that anyway power to him!
 

Syrinx

Member
Futari wa Pretty Cure 19

Introduction to Pretty Cure of a potentially awesome new villain ruined by wwwaaaaaayyyyyy too much facetime for Mepple and Mipple.
 

firehawk12

Subete no aware
i have been really enjoying chihayafuru. i still dont have any interest in karuta and i tend to zone out when theyre explaining which cards are left, or why they confused one card for another, but the characters are great and engaging. at first i thought i was like how come everyone isnt some super attractive model like in most animes but i grew to like them all, and the two new characters in the second season have been pretty good so far too.

i also like how even the minor characters show some growth such as chihayas mom and sister. its nice to see characters fail and work on their shortcomings and watching their progress instead of a 5 year flash forward when theyre already amazing. its got some great humor too. the females all throwing taichi a towel during a match a few episodes back was hilarious.

regarding the latest episode, i doubt arata is going to be disqualified. or rather there will be some way for him to play in the individual tournament. the flashbacks were too much though. it was also stupid of him to take his mask off and his friends referring to him by his real name when they lost. he could have just left first so even if reader dude knew it was arata, he wouldnt have any hard proof. just dumb of him all around but i guess he really felt bad for that team he tried to help.

On the last point, I want to believe that it was a matter of being caught up in the excitement. That, and well, a guy in a mask just doesn't make for a good postcard moment... so it's possible they just threw logic out the door for a decent shot, much like the ending of the previous episode.
 

OceanBlue

Member
Remember when the Key dude was whining that KyoAni turned them down for Angel Beats (Little Busters?).

The only thing he said was that the the project they turned them down for was a Kadokawa property (Hyouka, it seems).

I wish more studios had KyoAni's balls to turn down projects they know they can't do.

I don't know if their consistent quality is due to great scheduling or due to a lot of talented people (maybe both?), but KyoAni is great at keeping general quality up. Even back during Clannad After Story, when they were apparently at their busiest, I didn't really notice anything wrong. I really hope they stick with doing a few (sometimes one) shows a year and not doing two shows in the same season.

Even KyoAni recognized the show for the proper shit it was.

I dunno. They did do Air.
 
To be fair to professional anime stuff Extollere doesn't have to pop those out in 5 minutes while spending a week sleeping under his desk eating instant ramen noodles. Now if he does that anyway power to him!
Are the promotional artworks for anime shows, like posters and such, also done by the animators?
Remaining episodes of GIRLS und PANZER fans are dated for crunchyroll.
Does that mean free users and paid users get episode 11 at the exact same time?
 

cajunator

Banned
I guess what I really wanted to say is I'd like if you give some sort of context as to why you liked it or what parts of the episode you liked/didn't like. I'm not looking for a thesis here.

Oh no...

The thick yet clean lines really make this piece. The hover bike is really well drawn too!
As is the butt, but that's to be expected.

I try to show my reactions to things when I write impressions. Observe how I have written about precure and sailor moon for example.
you will rarely see character analysis by me but expect to know exactly how I feel about it lol.

To be fair to professional anime stuff Extollere doesn't have to pop those out in 5 minutes while spending a week sleeping under his desk eating instant ramen noodles. Now if he does that anyway power to him!

man, he draws while fapping. If that aint impressive I dont know what is!
 

Moonlight

Banned
Remember when the Key dude was whining that KyoAni turned them down for Angel Beats (Little Busters?).

The only thing he said was that the the project they turned them down for was a Kadokawa property (Hyouka, it seems).

I wish more studios had KyoAni's balls to turn down projects they know they can't do.
This is amazing.

And there's almost something poetic about getting Hyouka instead of Angel Beats!.
 

wonzo

Banned
Remember when the Key dude was whining that KyoAni turned them down for Angel Beats (Little Busters?).

The only thing he said was that the the project they turned them down for was a Kadokawa property (Hyouka, it seems).

I wish more studios had KyoAni's balls to turn down projects they know they can't do.
KyoAni giving that hack the finger by working on a good series like Hyouka just owns so hard.
 
I try to show my reactions to things when I write impressions. Observe how I have written about precure and sailor moon for example.
you will rarely see character analysis by me but expect to know exactly how I feel about it lol.

I know, I'm basically complaining against ronpaulitshappening.gif
 

Articalys

Member
Does that mean free users and paid users get episode 11 at the exact same time?
That's the way it reads to me. Since the airdates of episodes 11 and 12 are March 18 and 25, respectively -- CR clearly wanted to air them as a full hour-long block for subscribers (unlike how the Japanese TV stations did it), and episode 11 would be over 9 days old, but episode 12 would still be too recent for the normal free user one-week-wait rules.
 

OceanBlue

Member
That brings something up as well. Do the character designers for a show often work on the same show as an animator?
I guess. The original character designer probably gets consulted, but as far as I know, every anime has its own character designer to adapt the designs to something more easily animated.
This is amazing.

And there's almost something poetic about getting Hyouka instead of Angel Beats!.
It was Little Busters (although whichever one it was probably isn't that important, lol). I wonder if Angel Beats would have ever gone to KyoAni considering it was an Aniplex original. Didn't PAWorks have significant investment in it as well?
 
The amount of effort being put into this is really surprising.
I guess they figure since it is a really popular series.
That's the way it reads to me. Since the airdates of episodes 11 and 12 are March 18 and 25, respectively -- CR clearly wanted to air them as a full hour-long block for subscribers (unlike how the Japanese TV stations did it), and episode 11 would be over 9 days old, but episode 12 would still be too recent for the normal free user one-week-wait rules.

Ah, I guess that would make sense.
 
I guess. The original character designer probably gets consulted, but as far as I know, every anime has its own character designer to adapt the designs to something more easily animated.
Interesting, would there still be that strata within the animation studio if they're working on an adaptation of like a manga or something?
What do you mean? That outburst got you on the Friends' List!

It's rather hard to get your feelings across with purely written word, don't you think?
 

firehawk12

Subete no aware
Pet Girl 22

At this point, I guess I'm really the only one to blame for still watching this show. Fool me four times, then I deserved to be fooled. That's how that George W. Bush saying goes, right?

Just thinking about it for a moment, there's no reason why this couldn't have achieved pseudo-classic the status of Toradora (sorry jman, the ending is still way too Japanese). At the time - namely around the first four episodes - Kanda-kun was a decent, likable lead surrounded by a cast of somewhat interesting misfits. It's just too bad that the writer essentially had one good idea and recycled it four times. There is a point of diminishing returns when it comes to drama period, but when you use the same drama over and over again?

I mean, fucking hell, they let
Aoyoma :Kanna herself, but given how this show ends up, I have to imagine she'll find a way to properly confess before the show ends properly
. The other unfortunate side-effect is that the drama surrounding the Sakurasou itself is rendered meaningless by seeing the same drama played out over and over again. If the show doesn't even care, why should I? Even the Inn closing plot in HanaIro didn't have that many distractions and served as a way to actually set up the characters' end games.

At this point, I almost expect Sakurasou to be saved by some magical deus ex machina to be revealed in the last episode by virtue of the writer being creatively bankrupt. Or maybe this has been an extremely long con, that the last 16 episodes have been so poorly written because they wanted to lull me into a sense of brain dead complacency and that it turns out that they've been trapped in a video game for the last few years, doomed to repeat the same level over and over again, and that Pet Girl is actually set in the Sword Art Online universe... the show that bridges SAO and Accel World. It makes as much sense as anything the show has done so far anyway.
 

RurouniZel

Asks questions so Ezalc doesn't have to
Pet Girl 22

At this point, I guess I'm really the only one to blame for still watching this show. Fool me four times, then I deserved to be fooled. That's how that George W. Bush saying goes, right?

Just thinking about it for a moment, there's no reason why this couldn't have achieved pseudo-classic the status of Toradora (sorry jman, the ending is still way too Japanese). At the time - namely around the first four episodes - Kanda-kun was a decent, likable lead surrounded by a cast of somewhat interesting misfits. It's just too bad that the writer essentially had one good idea and recycled it four times. There is a point of diminishing returns when it comes to drama period, but when you use the same drama over and over again?

I mean, fucking hell, they let
Aoyoma :Kanna herself, but given how this show ends up, I have to imagine she'll find a way to properly confess before the show ends properly
. The other unfortunate side-effect is that the drama surrounding the Sakurasou itself is rendered meaningless by seeing the same drama played out over and over again. If the show doesn't even care, why should I? Even the Inn closing plot in HanaIro didn't have that many distractions and served as a way to actually set up the characters' end games.

At this point, I almost expect Sakurasou to be saved by some magical deus ex machina to be revealed in the last episode by virtue of the writer being creatively bankrupt. Or maybe this has been an extremely long con, that the last 16 episodes have been so poorly written because they wanted to lull me into a sense of brain dead complacency and that it turns out that they've been trapped in a video game for the last few years, doomed to repeat the same level over and over again, and that Pet Girl is actually set in the Sword Art Online universe... the show that bridges SAO and Accel World. It makes as much sense as anything the show has done so far anyway.

I said GODDAAAAAAMN! XD
 

Ultimadrago

Member
It's rather hard to get your feelings across with purely written word, don't you think?
0527a9f0ef72357a6e7beh1rcd.gif

.
 

Steroyd

Member
2deep4u
Is this really what counts as ecchi now? It seemed pretty graphic for animated lewd stuff.

There are a few series where smutgaf meets animegaf, they're usually called "borderline hentai", Yosuga no Sora was similar in that sense.
 
Hidamari Sketch x ☆☆☆ 12 (rewatch - END)


Absolutely loved my rewatch of this, though it didn't dethrone x365 as my favorite season. The introduction of Nori and Nazuna and the more frequent appearance of supporting characters (especially Oyasan) do certainly bring some freshness to the show that was largely missing in the previous seasons. In the new freshman's case, I think they shine way more in xHoneycomb, but that's for a different day since that only finished airing last season.
 
Pet Girl 22

At this point, I almost expect Sakurasou to be saved by some magical deus ex machina to be revealed in the last episode by virtue of the writer being creatively bankrupt. Or maybe this has been an extremely long con, that the last 16 episodes have been so poorly written because they wanted to lull me into a sense of brain dead complacency and that it turns out that they've been trapped in a video game for the last few years, doomed to repeat the same level over and over again, and that Pet Girl is actually set in the Sword Art Online universe... the show that bridges SAO and Accel World. It makes as much sense as anything the show has done so far anyway.

It's like every bad show has to recon itself into SAO somehow for you. :p
 

zeroshiki

Member
It was Little Busters (although whichever one it was probably isn't that important, lol). I wonder if Angel Beats would have ever gone to KyoAni considering it was an Aniplex original. Didn't PAWorks have significant investment in it as well?

You're right, I looked it up and its Little Busters.

I think KyoAni has shown with Chuuni that, for better or worse, they can do Key without actually licensing anything from Key.
 
courtesy of Zettai Karen Children: The Unlimited - Hyoubu Kyousuke 10
tumblr_mjivacvK2L1qe0v75o3_250.gif


Start was really good playing out as I had hoped and then with Andy being all dedicated and such to Hyoubu. I guess that is what I will miss out of this franchise just the two. Perhaps it could be extended into its own side spinoff series and get future sequels or something. Oh well. At least in this universe it seems no matter who one choose to support, BABEL, PANDRA, or even USEI, they all have just odd and bad backstories, still will go with hoping those aligned with Hyoubu are successful in their endeavour.
 

dimb

Bjergsen is the greatest midlane in the world
I guess they figure since it is a really popular series.
In most situations I find that developers with hot properties tend to rely on the strength of that IP and don't feel the need to deliver a fulfilling product. Just looking at the Accel World game makes me laugh.
 

Branduil

Member
In most situations I find that developers with hot properties tend to rely on the strength of that IP and don't feel the need to deliver a fulfilling product. Just looking at the Accel World game makes me laugh.

Or conversely, the Persona 4 anime.
 

Defuser

Member
Pet Girl 22

At this point, I guess I'm really the only one to blame for still watching this show. Fool me four times, then I deserved to be fooled. That's how that George W. Bush saying goes, right?

Just thinking about it for a moment, there's no reason why this couldn't have achieved pseudo-classic the status of Toradora (sorry jman, the ending is still way too Japanese). At the time - namely around the first four episodes - Kanda-kun was a decent, likable lead surrounded by a cast of somewhat interesting misfits. It's just too bad that the writer essentially had one good idea and recycled it four times. There is a point of diminishing returns when it comes to drama period, but when you use the same drama over and over again?

I mean, fucking hell, they let
Aoyoma :Kanna herself, but given how this show ends up, I have to imagine she'll find a way to properly confess before the show ends properly
. The other unfortunate side-effect is that the drama surrounding the Sakurasou itself is rendered meaningless by seeing the same drama played out over and over again. If the show doesn't even care, why should I? Even the Inn closing plot in HanaIro didn't have that many distractions and served as a way to actually set up the characters' end games.

At this point, I almost expect Sakurasou to be saved by some magical deus ex machina to be revealed in the last episode by virtue of the writer being creatively bankrupt. Or maybe this has been an extremely long con, that the last 16 episodes have been so poorly written because they wanted to lull me into a sense of brain dead complacency and that it turns out that they've been trapped in a video game for the last few years, doomed to repeat the same level over and over again, and that Pet Girl is actually set in the Sword Art Online universe... the show that bridges SAO and Accel World. It makes as much sense as anything the show has done so far anyway.
VWyOK9G.gif
 

firehawk12

Subete no aware
It's like every bad show has to recon itself into SAO somehow for you. :p
SAO is the ur bad show, the bad show to end bad shows. So everything must be born from SAO. So it is said!

I said GODDAAAAAAMN! XD
The worst part is that it's all my fault for putting up with the abuse, so I can't even be mad. Much like Mashiro herself, I suppose. :p

I'm not sure how I should interpret this gif. lol
 
Sakurasou no Pet na Kanojo 22

Ok, DRAMA resolved.

I look forward to the next DRAMA for next episode just so it can get a giant resolution in the last episode.
 

CorvoSol

Member
Actually no , their goal is to unify the world , and that begins by stopping the chain of conflicts across the globe. They just choose to do it by force since hey it's the faster way.
Even if they are considered a threat.

Uniting the world through conquest is the stupidest plan of all time. Tell me again how well that really worked out for Napoleon. You cannot conquer the world. It doesn't work. Especially not if your military strength is FOUR MOBILE SUITS.

I don't like saji , but his role is to show how the world change thanks to the actions of the cast ( for better or worse ).
The first season take a global conflict approach and that's why it's intresting. His role is to be the normal guy caught in the mess.

You know how they could've worked that? Showing Saji caught in the mess. Instead it's been Saji sitting on a couch with his overly attached girlfriend.

As for the wanabe gauron ..there aren't enough character like that in anime when you're dealing with war ... People enjoying war, making profit with war and wanting war to happen are actually realist people that unfortunatly exist IRL and that make his character even if he is exagerated much better to watch as an antagonist than a durandal or an ezelcant that wish for an utopia that won't work in the long term.

Wait wait wait. How do you dismiss Durandal's plan, when in the same post you've affirmed that it is essentially what Pretentious Being is aiming for in this show? I'm lost here. Oh, I don't disagree that Gauron is a better villain than Ezelcant (except for the fact that Ezelcant was the hero in AGE and Flit the villain), and certainly more entertaining than Durandal, but that's not the point. I've given the show plenty of space to breathe about this whole war orphan and royally evil mercenary deal. Been all over my posts, it has. The problem is that the guy is TOO Gauron. All he needs is the anguished declaration of love for Setsuna to cement it. I have no problem reusing similar conventions, I mean, it's Gundam, I accept space colonies and Char Clones and so on and so forth. I just ask that they not be so damn blatant.

The plot was "let's prevent manipulation of information leading to civil war, that'll stop war for a moment".
The plot wasn't to kill people but to stop those manipulating others to fight for their own benefit.

No, no it was not. The plot was "Let's kill like, 20 guys and see if it stops war in areas." and the worst part is that it's worked from time to time. Which makes no sense. You don't get to just fly in, shoot twenty guys and intimidate people. That the combined military strength of the entire planet just lost because 3 more Gundams popped up ruins any credibility this story has. Not even Kira's Freedom got away with standing up to the entire military force of a world and winning.

Exploited war children is again a theme totally new in gundam and even if they went too far with it . it's something much more realist than the happy go lucky world that hapenned when a country was destroyed in other shows.

No it isn't! What was Amuro, if not a child exploited by the Earth Forces for their war? What was Heero, if not a war-child exploited by the Barton Foundation for Operation Meteor? What was Kira, if not a child exploited by the Earth Forces for their war? Gundam is basically only about children being exploited for war. Just that most protagonists don't have the laughably asinine origin story of "Shot mommy and daddy because a man with a goatee said God said to do it."

Sorry if full metal panic , despite his alien stuff had actually war , information manipulation and 2 organisations clashing.
Funny how you can draw parallels when they treat the same subject.

That's precisely the point of drawing parallels. Except that one does it with wit, and the other does it with all the rhetorical skill of a junior high student. Why would I draw parallels on disparate matters? It makes no sense to compare The Big O and Azumanga Daioh because they're completely different. It makes sense to compare Full Metal Panic! and Gundam 00 because Gundam 00 makes pathetic attempts at replicating Full Metal Panic!'s story.


But that's her job .. her goal is to turn each event at their advantage and to think x moves ahead .. that's why she works with a freaking super computer that analyse information.
How do you expect to win anything if you can't predict and anticipate the unknow ? Especially if the world is your ennemy ! You have to spy at everything anticipate alliances and think of counter mesures ...
I would understand the conplain if she was alone but she is backed by the entire celestial being network and a centuries-ahead computer dedicated to this task.

Forecast for weather are done the exact same way. You gather information , you run it in various scenarios run by a super computer ..and then you let a human check it. Once it's good you give that info to the public.

But weather behaves in one way, and people do not. You cannot say with any certainty at all that people will do x if you do y. You can say that in the past people have done x when subject to y, but the group today isn't the same as the group yesterday. It's unreliable, which makes her CONSTANT BITCHING when something ANYTHING goes awry, insufferable. This isn't how social science works. If I do a study of armed conflicts responding to armed interventions by a third party and conclude that it's likely that in any given case the two parties will both respond with hostility to the third, I shouldn't cry like a bitch when I'm wrong. I should go back and see what I overlooked, yeah, but Sumiragi's whining is ridiculous.

Besides, if 3 fucking Gundams can throw the entire combined strength of the world's military for a loop, tell me again why we need to plan ANYTHING?
 
In most situations I find that developers with hot properties tend to rely on the strength of that IP and don't feel the need to deliver a fulfilling product. Just looking at the Accel World game makes me laugh.

But SAO sold several times more than Accel World, didn't it?
 

survivor

Banned
Remember when the Key dude was whining that KyoAni turned them down for Angel Beats (Little Busters?).

The only thing he said was that the the project they turned them down for was a Kadokawa property (Hyouka, it seems).

I wish more studios had KyoAni's balls to turn down projects they know they can't do.

Oh thank god they turned them down and worked on Hyouka instead.

Pet Girl 22

At this point, I guess I'm really the only one to blame for still watching this show. Fool me four times, then I deserved to be fooled. That's how that George W. Bush saying goes, right?

Just thinking about it for a moment, there's no reason why this couldn't have achieved pseudo-classic the status of Toradora (sorry jman, the ending is still way too Japanese). At the time - namely around the first four episodes - Kanda-kun was a decent, likable lead surrounded by a cast of somewhat interesting misfits. It's just too bad that the writer essentially had one good idea and recycled it four times. There is a point of diminishing returns when it comes to drama period, but when you use the same drama over and over again?

I mean, fucking hell, they let
Aoyoma :Kanna herself, but given how this show ends up, I have to imagine she'll find a way to properly confess before the show ends properly
. The other unfortunate side-effect is that the drama surrounding the Sakurasou itself is rendered meaningless by seeing the same drama played out over and over again. If the show doesn't even care, why should I? Even the Inn closing plot in HanaIro didn't have that many distractions and served as a way to actually set up the characters' end games.

At this point, I almost expect Sakurasou to be saved by some magical deus ex machina to be revealed in the last episode by virtue of the writer being creatively bankrupt. Or maybe this has been an extremely long con, that the last 16 episodes have been so poorly written because they wanted to lull me into a sense of brain dead complacency and that it turns out that they've been trapped in a video game for the last few years, doomed to repeat the same level over and over again, and that Pet Girl is actually set in the Sword Art Online universe... the show that bridges SAO and Accel World. It makes as much sense as anything the show has done so far anyway.

Sounds like I dodged a bullet by dropping this after 4 episodes.
 

fertygo

Member
@Corvo

Your 00 review post seem like you already determine to hate it from the start :(
I mean one silly thing that less than 10 second and its all that you mention in your one paragraph episode impression.

00 S1 was cool, its Wings copy, the gundam are sexy, the pacing was smooth, have Ali Al-Sachez, very easy to watch.
 

Syrinx

Member
Futari wa Pretty Cure 20

Was a little skeptical going in when the title revealed there was going to be a "two Honoka" plot (though two Honokas would be awesome), but I have to say, this was probably my favorite episode so far.

Props to Nagisa for figuring out something was up, though Poisonny kinda gave herself away. Her encounter with both Honokas on the train was great. Love how they tied it back to the episode where the two were feuding and read each others diaries. Also liked how nobody on the train noticed what was going on.

Then Poisonny really wasn't fucking around. She really kicked the crap out of them. And she even dodged a marble screw! It wasn't an automatic win button for once. They actually had to use the attack to their situation.

This show has kinda gotten into a nice rhythm for the most part. Hope Porun doesn't ruin it.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom