I'm not sure how you even came to the conclusion that the posters are from the gaming side.
You quoted the entirety of my post, so I'm not sure how you misunderstood the thrust of it, especially since that means you at least looked at it twice before responding and hitting post. The post is referring to people's opinions that can be classified as "hate." There are many critical opinions that don't come off that way, so those all get set to the side. But for the ones that
do, even
then they're not so much hateful as they are hyperbolic for the sake of getting attention in a thread that's moving 5 million miles an hour - meaning the opinion is being expressed loudly and artlessly but there's some actual thought behind it if you actually stop to poke at it.
Or it's a bunch of people who obviously don't know what the fuck they're talking about trying to pretend like they
do know what they're talking about in the hopes you won't stop and poke at it to show how
clueless they are about the concepts they're mangling in an effort to appear sophisticated. It becomes easier to spot that mess when their main frames of reference for criticizing the storytelling... come from games, or conventions heavily deployed (or even created) in gaming.
Am I not supposed to think they then wandered over from gaming side when we're on a giant gaming forum?
Yeah it's pretty cool to be elitist about which forum you post on a video game forum website right? That doesn't seem ridiculous at all.
Why is my jab at people fronting at film criticism without any proficiency with the tools required setting you off? So far as I know you haven't done that. There's no reason for you to get heated by the notion such a thing could be (and is) happening, is there?
It'd be no different if there was a diet thread and some dude posted in it like he was a nutritionist while he was polishing off a bag of Sun Chips and the ass end of a Jimmy Johns 12" BBQ Pork Po'Boy.