As a Mac user, why would you ever consider buying a high-end router other than Apples AirPort Extreme? Easy, because some non-Apple-specific routers cost less, offer more features, and deliver better performance. When I pitted the AirPort Extreme against the highly rated
Asus RT-N66U, the Asus boxed its ears on most of the benchmarks I ran.
But benchmark performance isnt everything; youll also want to consider the experience of installing and using a non-Apple device. Apples think different concept isnt just advertising copy. So in addition to performance, Ill also discuss the feature sets offered on each router.
...
Which router should a Mac user buy?
In addition to the differences in features between Apple and non-Apple routers, you should consider the prospect of dealing with two tech-support resources should you run into a problem. All too often, one company will blame problems you might on the others equipment. Theres also the fact that many non-Apple routers dont work with Apples Time Machine backup service, even though every high-end router has at least one USB port to support an external hard drive these days.
In terms of performance, Id pick the Asus RT-N66U all day long. It delivers substantially higher performance on the 2.4GHz frequency band, much better range on both the 2.4- and 5GHz frequency bands, it offers a number of features the AirPort Extreme does not, and its street-priced $10 less than the AirPort Extreme.
The absence of Time Machine support doesn't bother me, because I don't rely on router-attached storage. I use a dedicated NAS box, because it delivers much higher performance, several times more capacity, and even more features. But if you intend to make use of a hard drive plugged into your routers USB port, or if you want Time Machine support, be sure to pick a router that supports it. As I mentioned earlier, there are non-Apple routers delivering those features today, and Asus plans to offer it with the RT-N66U in the near future.
No one will laugh at you if you decide to stick with Apple for your networking needs, but you wont kick yourself for buying a non-Apple router, either.