• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D. |OT| Tahiti is a Magical Place (to...Hey guys, I found it!)

Status
Not open for further replies.
Breaks in between new eps due to the Olympics is most responsible for the drop. Even Arrow, which many on the forum prefer to SHIELD, saw it's own season low.

SHIELD is still very likely getting a S2 and has plenty opportunity to gain viewers in the off season if S1 moves to Netflix. People will binge watch through eps they don't like on Netflix and if there's enough of a grab, they'll continue watching the show when it goes live. This is actually exactly what happened with Arrow, where S1 being on Netflix allowed viewers to push through the eps they didn't like and get to the action without waiting on the show week to week to progress. If SHIELD's change of direction continues forward, it could have a similar trajectory of steady improvement in S2, similar to what Arrow has done.
 

kirblar

Member
Details for upcoming episode titled "End of the Beginning" are up on marvel.com. Returning characters are
Agent John Garrett, Agent Victoria Hand, Agent Jasper Sitwell, Agent Felix Blake, Agent Antoine Triplett and Deathlok.

Has
Agent Blake's first name
been revealed before?

These spoiler tags are probably a bit excessive but I figured some people might like to go into each episode totally fresh.
Yeah, betting that
Hand is the fake-out with Garrett as the reveal.
 

dabig2

Member
Just watched the last episode. Much better than the usual. McCreary was partially unshackled here which added to my enjoyment of the episode.

And that's totally some dead Kree. Though I'm not sure how its blood has such powerful regenerative properties. It obviously isn't a regular, boring Kree. And god I hope Skye isn't Ms Marvel. Carol Danvers is a longtime Avenger and deserves to be Ms Marvel in the MCU.

But I like the Ultra-girl theory though. Makes much more sense and could tie in with the whole "we have no idea wtf she is" plotline
one of the original prevailing theories being she's either an Inhuman or a Kree mutant/human hybrid
 
But I like the Ultra-girl theory though. Makes much more sense and could tie in with the whole "we have no idea wtf she is" plotline
one of the original prevailing theories being she's either an Inhuman or a Kree mutant/human hybrid

She's Squirrel Girl. Once her Squirrel powers develop, she'll make May look like an amateur.
 
Details for upcoming episode titled "End of the Beginning" are up on marvel.com. Returning characters are
Agent John Garrett, Agent Victoria Hand, Agent Jasper Sitwell, Agent Felix Blake, Agent Antoine Triplett and Deathlok.

Has
Agent Blake's first name
been revealed before?

These spoiler tags are probably a bit excessive but I figured some people might like to go into each episode totally fresh.

Odd that there's no air date given; is the schedule still in flux? Looks like another three-week wait after next week. :/
 
As much as I enjoy seeing the show improving, I don't know if I can take another multi-week break. It's really damn hard to stay invested when the airing schedule is so sporadic, and I'm sure that has a lot to do with the ratings drops.
 

gazele

Banned
As much as I enjoy seeing the show improving, I don't know if I can take another multi-week break. It's really damn hard to stay invested when the airing schedule is so sporadic, and I'm sure that has a lot to do with the ratings drops.

Yep, i'm not sure if tv companies will learn that breaks are bad but especially with the way netflix and HBO do shows having breaks is such a momentum killer
 

Joni

Member
Yep, i'm not sure if tv companies will learn that breaks are bad but especially with the way netflix and HBO do shows having breaks is such a momentum killer

ABC is learning. They're doing half season full runs for Scandal and Grey's.
 
I can't seem to finish an episode of this show without falling asleep. I made it halfway through this recent one before I became incredibly bored.

Why so much trouble over Skye again? I mean, why use all that manpower and tax payer money if she is just another trainee? What?
 

SRG01

Member
I can't seem to finish an episode of this show without falling asleep. I made it halfway through this recent one before I became incredibly bored.

Why so much trouble over Skye again? I mean, why use all that manpower and tax payer money if she is just another trainee? What?

The whole point is because they're learning to be a team and not to treat others as being disposable. That, and Skye is a 084...
 
I can't seem to finish an episode of this show without falling asleep. I made it halfway through this recent one before I became incredibly bored.

Why so much trouble over Skye again? I mean, why use all that manpower and tax payer money if she is just another trainee? What?

She is an 084 - object of unknown origin
She also hacked into SHIELD systems like it was a 6 piece puzzle, so she is much more than a trainee. She is potentially a very important asset.

Oh, and yeah, she is part of the team, one that went far out of her way to save members the team too.
 

odiin

My Apartment, or the 120 Screenings of Salo
Details for upcoming episode titled "End of the Beginning" are up on marvel.com. Returning characters are
Agent John Garrett, Agent Victoria Hand, Agent Jasper Sitwell, Agent Felix Blake, Agent Antoine Triplett and Deathlok.

Has
Agent Blake's first name
been revealed before?

These spoiler tags are probably a bit excessive but I figured some people might like to go into each episode totally fresh.

When the hell are Benny and Claire going to show up? At this point they're pretty much the only SHIELD agents not to show up on the show.
 

pulga

Banned
Great job murdering those two security guards who were only doing their jobs, guys. Stand up good guys you are.
 
Squirrel Girl is a mutant, marvel doesn't have the rights for her.

She's not associated with the X-Men. She's a character who premiered in Iron Man, is most associated with the Great Lakes Avengers, and was recently Luke Cage's nanny in New Avengers. They just need to redefine the source of her powers. She could be an Inhuman now.
 

ZeroGravity

Member
Great job murdering those two security guards who were only doing their jobs, guys. Stand up good guys you are.
If someone opens fire on you, I think you're entitled to defend yourself.

Also if you think SHIELD stands for everything that's good and wholesome, I've got a bridge to sell you.
 

pulga

Banned
If someone opens fire on you, I think you're entitled to defend yourself.

Also if you think SHIELD stands for everything that's good and wholesome, I've got a bridge to sell you.

Yeah no prob, let's just murder these two guys who were only doing their jobs, weren't bad guys in any way, shape or form and whom probably have families waiting for them at home, for the sake of saving a shit character.

and the guards fired on them because Coulson and co were invading the place they are supposed to protect

and we're not talking about SHIELD as a whole, we're talking about a Coulson led team, should be held to a higher standard.

should change your name to ZeroMorality smh
 

ZeroGravity

Member
Yeah no prob, let's just murder these two guys who were only doing their jobs, weren't bad guys in any way, shape or form and whom probably have families waiting for them at home, for the sake of saving a shit character.

and the guards fired on them because Coulson and co were invading the place they are supposed to protect

and we're not talking about SHIELD as a whole, we're talking about a Coulson led team, should be held to a higher standard.

should change your name to ZeroMorality smh
I don't know if you've actually watched the show, but even Coulson's team is violating someone's civil liberties every five minutes.

It's just what SHIELD does.
 

pulga

Banned
I don't know if you've actually watched the show, but even Coulson's team is violating someone's civil liberties every five minutes.

It's just what SHIELD does.

violating civil liberties is a wee bit different from straight up murder

RIP Security Guards
I hope the ride to Heaven is better than the one from Istanbul
 

neoanarch

Member
Fox doesn't have the rights to all mutant characters, just those tied to the X-Men property. If they did, Marvel wouldn't have any rights to Quicksilver or Scarlet Witch.

She's not associated with the X-Men. She's a character who premiered in Iron Man, is most associated with the Great Lakes Avengers, and was recently Luke Cage's nanny in New Avengers. They just need to redefine the source of her powers. She could be an Inhuman now.

According to some interviews all Mutants are X-men for the purpose of the rights. Special deals were made for the Twins. Cases like Namor where they were introduced before mutants are separate.

No, it'd kind of left ambiguous. The episode actually made it a point to state that the bunker was not a SHIELD installation.

The facility itself was offgrid and not technically SHIELD but they were agents following SHIELD orders. I can't see that as anything but cold blooded. But thats the SHIELD I know, morally bankrupt.
 
Yeah no prob, let's just murder these two guys who were only doing their jobs, weren't bad guys in any way, shape or form and whom probably have families waiting for them at home, for the sake of saving a shit character.

and the guards fired on them because Coulson and co were invading the place they are supposed to protect

and we're not talking about SHIELD as a whole, we're talking about a Coulson led team, should be held to a higher standard.

should change your name to ZeroMorality smh

violating civil liberties is a wee bit different from straight up murder

RIP Security Guards
I hope the ride to Heaven is better than the one from Istanbul

Why are you assuming the guards were good? We know they weren't SHIELD and there's no other "good" agency that we know of that rivals SHIELD's knowledge and tech.. and whoever that facility belongs to, seems as if their knowledge and tech surpasses SHIELD's.

I mean they're either some blackbox segment of the gov't that's somehow higher security level than SHIELD or they're ambiguously neutral.. which means they could be evil or good at any point in time, it would just depend on their client... or they're bad and Fury worked out some kind deal.

And there's no way that people who have positions guarding a site like that have any family that they go home to. There's no way they could be trusted to guard that kind of installation if they had any weaknesses to be leveraged.
 

LaNaranja

Member
Just saw todays episode, it is good to see the episodes have been getting better lately. I hope we get a quick cameo next week of Nick Fury bitch slapping Coulson and telling him off for killing his alien.
 

pants

Member
Decided to watch this episode for whatever reason, the way they killed those two guards pissed me off so much i stopped immediately. wtf.
 

Trike

Member
Let me correct myself.

The fact that they killed those guards made me stop watching. This is way beyond Captain Janeway murder shit

SHIELD is not a superhero team. They are not to trying to be heroes, they are a force that tries to protect the world at any cost. They will lie, steal, betray and kill in order to maintain peace. They are not evil, but will commit what they deem to be necessary evils. The question of whether the ends justify the means is why Skye was hesitant to trust them, and is what I assume Captain America 2: Legends Parachute Once is about. So killing two guards who got in the way of saving a team member's life isn't out of the ordinary.

I mean, they could have just used the Night-Night Gun. But that would have required writing a happy ending for the guards, which is clearly too much work. Or required them to interrogate them to find out who they are and what that place really is, which is obviously a plot point. So basically they had to die due to lazy writing.
 

Mariolee

Member
Yeah no prob, let's just murder these two guys who were only doing their jobs, weren't bad guys in any way, shape or form and whom probably have families waiting for them at home, for the sake of saving a shit character.

and the guards fired on them because Coulson and co were invading the place they are supposed to protect

and we're not talking about SHIELD as a whole, we're talking about a Coulson led team, should be held to a higher standard.

should change your name to ZeroMorality smh

So then you admit that the guards knew what they were signing up for and have responsibility over the jobs chosen, unless shown otherwise. Coulson and co. clearly stated they were friendlies, but that if shot at they would defend themselves. The guards knew what they were in for, while Coulson and his team did not. Thus, the death of the guards was merely out of self-defense, not intent of murder.

And while we're making up stories about how these guards who are defending an ultra secret if-anyone-finds-out-about-this-base-they-need-to-be-erased-off-the-earth base that is sucking the life force out of an alien is otherwise living a normal life with a family at home as you imply, then I think the problem is with you, not the show. I will criticize the show and have done so many times, but this is not a big flaw or even a flaw at all.

Don't know why I'm even arguing over this, I'm pretty sure you're just trying to rustle us up.
 
SHIELD is not a superhero team. They are not to trying to be heroes, they are a force that tries to protect the world at any cost. They will lie, steal, betray and kill in order to maintain peace. They are not evil, but will commit what they deem to be necessary evils. The question of whether the ends justify the means is why Skye was hesitant to trust them, and is what I assume Captain America 2: Legends Parachute Once is about. So killing two guards who got in the way of saving a team member's life isn't out of the ordinary.

I mean, they could have just used the Night-Night Gun. But that would have required writing a happy ending for the guards, which is clearly too much work. Or required them to interrogate them to find out who they are and what that place really is, which is obviously a plot point. So basically they had to die due to lazy writing.

I mean... they had no idea who was in the facility or how many of them were there until after both guards were critically injured, we have no idea how far ahead the night night gun ammo is manufactured (I'd assume not very far considering the team was shocked to find that the enemies they faced last episode have a variation of the same thing), and they were racing the clock to save Skye and THEN to gtfo before the facility blew up...

But sure.. the writing was "lazy" even though it's actually much easier to write convenience like no one dying and people taken into custody spilling all the pertinent info quickly enough that you can save the dying team member with time to spare....

But they basically killed two SHIELD guards for doing their jobs.

The show was adamant in dialogue that they were not SHIELD. Should the guards have had uniforms that said "Definitely not SHIELD" on them? I kid a bit buy yeah.. they weren't SHIELD. Could be allied with SHIELD, but not SHIELD as far as we know.
 

golem

Member
If someone opens fire on you, I think you're entitled to defend yourself.

Also if you think SHIELD stands for everything that's good and wholesome, I've got a bridge to sell you.

Coulsen and Co. were the aggressors. They had no right to invade that place, I wonder if there will be repercussions

Probably not
 

Jonogunn

Member
I think people seeing coulson kill the 2 guards as wrong is perfectly valid given the way they portrayed the team throughout the season. They are the "good guys" of shield. They don't do these kind of things.
 

odiin

My Apartment, or the 120 Screenings of Salo
SHIELD is supposed to be this shadowy government organization not happy friendship funtime hour. People die. Honestly this is what the show should have been from the beginning. Maybe then the show might not be hemorraghing viewers like it is. Instead they turned it into a complete joke.
 

Joni

Member
The show was adamant in dialogue that they were not SHIELD. Should the guards have had uniforms that said "Definitely not SHIELD" on them? I kid a bit buy yeah.. they weren't SHIELD. Could be allied with SHIELD, but not SHIELD as far as we know.
But they basically are SHIELD. They're guarding SHIELD stuff, they are SHIELD-adjacent. They're not bad guys, they were people put there by an organisation that clearly has ties to SHIELD and is opposing the same people as them. It is like US troops killing English troops in Iraq or Afghanistan. They're not US troops, but it is still a bad idea, especially if they want us to cheer on these guys. I wouldn't mind a good antihero, but they're supposed to be heroes, not antiheroes.
 

Mariolee

Member
You guys act like they went in hankering for a killing. They went in to save Skye, who is not only like family but also an important 084, and went into the Guest House not knowing what to expect and being extremely extremely polite about it. They explained their position, how they were friendlies, and how they didn't want to kill the dudes but that if the dudes shot at them they would defend themselves. At no point were they on the offensive in terms of weaponry.
 
But they basically are SHIELD. They're guarding SHIELD stuff, they are SHIELD-adjacent. They're not bad guys, they were people put there by an organisation that clearly has ties to SHIELD and is opposing the same people as them. It is like US troops killing English troops in Iraq or Afghanistan. They're not US troops, but it is still a bad idea, especially if they want us to cheer on these guys. I wouldn't mind a good antihero, but they're supposed to be heroes, not antiheroes.

Why do they "clearly have ties" to SHIELD exactly? Everything about the episode showed that the facility isn't under the control of SHIELD. I mean.. they could be allies... but allies are easily enemies given circumstance.

Edit: To be specific.. they weren't guarding SHIELD stuff at all to our knowledge. Literally everything about the facility was unknown except it's location and code name and only Fury was high enough security level to know that.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom