Just saw it. I really enjoyed it even though there are plenty of flaws. If like me you happen to be an old-school X-Men reader who also loves the Singer version despite the many "adjustments", you will probably have a good time.
Here are my thoughts, keep in mind that I am not a native english speaker so my apologies if my ramblings are difficult to read:
The highlight was definitely the Quicksilver scene, which is one of my favorite superhero action scenes. Maybe even better than the airport scene in Civil War. CW is the better film though and I say this as someone who generally prefers the Singer films to the MCU. But the cinematography and soundtrack are definitely better here and it's absolutely exhilarating and hilarious at the same time and it really comes out of nowhere.
Cyclops is also very good in the film and has a nice arc, same with Nightcrawler. Storm doesn't have much to do but I like the actress, I loved her look and accent and I hope she will still have her badass mohawk in the next one. There is a certain elegance in the way Singer puts together his films and that is definitely still the case here, it is a very beautiful movie at times and the shots and cuts are very well orchestrated.
Unfortunately there are also a lot of issues with the film. They didn't ruin the experience for me but I understand the reviews. I think after 3 films Singer ran out of story ideas and decided to please the fans and give them what he thinks they want which is often a mistake. To do that, he had to go outside of his comfort zone as a filmmaker and it doesn't always work. Here are my biggest issues with the film :
- Apocalypse. He doesn't look good and just isn't an interesting villain. I actually wanted him to give an evil monologue to clearly explain his plans even though that is a cliché. His motivations for wanting to destroy the world are pretty murky. A small monologue about the survival of the fittest would have helped.
- The horsemen are mostly wasted. Psylocke fans, you will not be pleased.
- The characters motivations in the third act make no sense. I won't go into details but considering the stakes and the millions of lives lost (probably, none of it is really shown), there should be no redemption possible for anyone who associated with Apocalypse even though some of them turn against him at the last second.
- Jean Grey has a great story arc in the movie but my god Sophie Turner is TERRIBLE. I agree that Jennifer Lawrence isn't great as Mystique either but she is still tolerable. I have nothing against Turner and I like her on GoT but a lot of the film rests on her shoulders and she is the weakest actor in the film by far. Her line delivery is absolutely awful.
The X-men movies that I love:
1) X2
2) Days of Future Past
3) First Class
That I like:
4) X-Men
5) Apocalypse
6) The Wolverine (to be honest, 5&6 are pretty much a tie for me I think, I will need a second viewing)
Feel indifferent about:
7) Last Stand
Absolutely hate:
8) Wolverine Origins