Mmmh, probably between First Class and Origins. Your list is pretty similar to mine but do you really prefer Origins to the first X-Men film? How dare you.
Lol I know. I just think people hate that movie because of what they did to all the characters. It's ok for Singer to butcher all the characters, but somebody else does it, it's a bad movie.
Liev and Hugh's interactions make it really enjoyable for me. Also I never gave a shit about Deadpool so I didn't care what they did to him.
The action scenes in it were far better than X-men. All the characters were likeable, unlike X-Men. The plot was better imo.
Stryker's motives made more sense than Magneto's water making machine.
Like his whole motive is to convert everyone to a mutant, but then he finds out it just kills everybody, and he's like fuck it gonna use it anyways. Rogue, Cyclops, Storm were annoying as hell. Only reason Rogue is there is to be used as a stupid plot device.
Couldn't stand Halle's and Marsden's acting. Everyone's complaining that JLaw is just there to collect paychecks, yah so were these guys.
Wolverine is shown in the beginning to be some badass dude, (which was the best part of the whole movie), then he gets turned into a giant wuss who just gets owned all the time. (all Singer movies he's a wuss. The guy never even read a wolverine comic yet he claims he's his fave, yah sure there buddy).
The only reason the movie is watchable, is because of Patrick, Ian, Rebecca, and Hugh. Yet we only get one scene at the beginning when Prof X and Magneto are face to face.
Cycloos, the leader of the team is a goddamn push over in these movies, made sense to just kill him off in Last Stand (best thing they did).
I could go on but I digress, not here to pick apart a 16 year old movie.