Lords of the Fallen 2 dev hired two souls game veterans (thousands of hours played) , to ensure link to the community and the game hits what fans want
- Thread starter LectureMaster
- Start date
- Game Dev
Dr.Morris79
Gold Member
I don't mind this at all. It's good to hear actual gamers being involved..
Makes a change from weirdo activists
Makes a change from weirdo activists
The Cockatrice
I'm retarded?
Thats stupid for multiple reasons, one of them being the fact that they have over a thousand hours in "souls" game meaning their critical analysis will be biased/flawed. People obsessed with specific genres will be massively ignorant to its issues.
Lorianus
Member
Thats basically what happened any time Blizzard consulted top raiding guilds about feedback.
The Cockatrice
I'm retarded?
Bingo. Miyazaki himself doesnt play his own fucking games and for good reason. Soulslikes arent being bought by only the hardcore fans, in fact the majority are always going to be newcomers, casuals, etc.
Bernardougf
Member
They dont need to be innovative, they are exploring a genre, not creating one .... and with From moving away from classic souls for that godawful openworld dogshit elden ring formula.. all they have to do is to provide a refined classic souls experience and they will set thenselfs apart.. and btw lords of the fallen was already innovative enough for the genre with the "dark world" mechanic.
The first game I consider the best souls like and enjoy it very much .. so I hope for a even better sequel since they pretty much improved the game with every new patch.
Portugeezer
Member
Fine if it mostly affects multiplayer.
LOTF was on the right track and a very solid souls-like game already, hopefully the director sticks to their vision.
LOTF was on the right track and a very solid souls-like game already, hopefully the director sticks to their vision.
Lokaum D+
Member
Also, make the art direction less busy, there is too much shit happening on the screen at the same time.
Last edited:
ecosse_011172
Gold Member
Meh.
As if we need yet another decent but not amazing Souls clone.
Lies of P shat all over their previous attempts.
As if we need yet another decent but not amazing Souls clone.
Lies of P shat all over their previous attempts.
Clear
CliffyB's Cock Holster
Having played both this year, I would strongly disagree with that.
Lies Of P is very good, but is visually inferior to Lords 2.0, is considerably shorter and way more linear, and despite having zero multiplayer elements still has difficulty balance issues.
Its smartly designed (I'm still shocked by how people managed to ignore all the lifts from the Nier games!) with excellent art direction and sound design, but its way more constrained than most Souls' copyists.
Lords (again, judging on the 2.0 release) basically attempts to copy the entire Souls formula, and then add a bunch of Soul Reaver inspired stuff on top... So credit has to be given for ambition. While the story is fairly bog-standard and not terribly memorable, the character voicing and dialogue was as I recall quite decent - it certainly didn't pull me out of the game at any point and honestly, given how FROM have basically recycled the same NPC character arcs multiple times over the past 15 years I was pleasantly surprised that they managed to differentiate theirs while retaining the same template.
I liked both games, so saying one is vastly better or worse than the other is absolutely not something I can agree with.
Giallo Corsa
Member
But that was his whole thing, one layer on top of the other man.
Not only it was impressive technically wise but also gave the game a different kind of depth compared to other games out there,
Clear
is spot on in saying that it was Soul Reaver-ish in its design.Take that out and it becomes yet another run of the mill clone (which it already kind of is).
For me personally, after the 1.5 update, it was one the best Souls-likes out there, great atmosphere, fantastic visuals and - gasp - great art direction, and the fact that it wasn't hard as nails as - say - Lies of P, made it even better as you could concentrate on the exploration part.
RafterXL
Member
Well, if you followed development of the first game, you'd know that they cater to casuals and newcomers quite a bit. There are a ton of settings to make the game easier, or harder, that most Souls type games don't have. You also don't need consultants for casual players, they're literally the easiest people to develop for.
And, yeah, the "good reason" Miyazaki doesn't play his own games is because he says it feels like reliving his work and it's not enjoyable, not because it's some zen developer move.
Signalis
Member
What do you mean? Silent Hill F is perfect in every way, shape and form and there is literally nothing wrong with the story, combat and game design. /s
MidGenRefresh
*Refreshes biennially
I just wish Bethesda would do the same for Fallout. They clearly have no idea what the series was originally about. Hire me, I'd do it for free.
GymWolf
Member
I know it was the game main feature but i just personally don't care much for it.But that was his whole thing, one layer on top of the other man.
Not only it was impressive technically wise but also gave the game a different kind of depth compared to other games out there,
Take that out and it becomes yet another run of the mill clone (which it already kind of is).
For me personally, after the 1.5 update, it was one the best Souls-likes out there, great atmosphere, fantastic visuals and - gasp - great art direction, and the fact that it wasn't hard as nails as - say - Lies of P, made it even better as you could concentrate on the exploration part.
The timer, the shitty enemy inside and the kinda ugly look were all detrimental to my enjoyment when i was in the alternate realm.
Last edited:
genesisblock
Member
The only reason why I see them doing this is probably to make the game stream viral, and then hope that acts as the marketing for new buyers.
Last edited:
Signalis
Member
I don't give a shit what anyone says. But I have a massive soft spot for Dark Souls 2. I really like it a lot, but if you ask me why exactly, then I can't answer that but DS2 is the one I replay the most. Same with Silent Hill 4.
missiles
Member
Why is this dev so obsessed with making other people's games? It shows such a lack of authenticity, creativity and ethics to me, not to mention that their work will always feel like an inferior knock-off. Did they make their own games before they started making bad cover versions of FROM titles?
Angry_Megalodon
Member
This has pros and cons. I like that devs listen to actual players, but certainly this comes with the risk of becoming too derivative.
ecosse_011172
Gold Member
Fortress of Regrets
Member
Epic Game Store exclusive on PC, lol.
Bye, dead game.
Bye, dead game.
Punished Miku
Gaslighter Pro: 16.7 Fireflops
I prefer "souls cultists."
Astray
Member
Very double-edged sword imo, they're basically saying they will adhere to everything From did as blindly as possible.
The entire point of a non-Fromsoft company doing a souls-type game is to have a different take on it, a different flavor. Not to slavishly pursue what they did.
The entire point of a non-Fromsoft company doing a souls-type game is to have a different take on it, a different flavor. Not to slavishly pursue what they did.
AFAIK, they mentioned that PS was their lead platform in sales.
NeverYouMind
Member
For me it is the alure of adventure, freedom in tackling areas, and amount of great builds in Dark Souls II that keeps me coming back. The great mods for it help too.
Going for Elden Ring scope based on promotional footage (despite mainstream fatigue) and the stated Epic exclusivity are surely a double whammy and recipe for disaster.
P.S. They should have hired Bloodborne veterans.
Last edited:
thefool
Member
GHG
Member
But that was his whole thing, one layer on top of the other man.
Not only it was impressive technically wise but also gave the game a different kind of depth compared to other games out there,
Take that out and it becomes yet another run of the mill clone (which it already kind of is).
For me personally, after the 1.5 update, it was one the best Souls-likes out there, great atmosphere, fantastic visuals and - gasp - great art direction, and the fact that it wasn't hard as nails as - say - Lies of P, made it even better as you could concentrate on the exploration part.
Yep the dual realm thing was it's main differentiator and that's what elevated it miles above lies of P for me.
They should lean in to it more and flesh it out further, not abandon it.
Signalis
Member
The Majula theme is also beautiful, sad, hopeful and depressing all at the same time. I listen to it regularly
CrimsonTide
Gold Member
Best hub in the genre
