Halo 4: Review Thread

Trey said:
It really, truly is. The EG review employs salient criticisms that are articulated far better than their contemporaries have managed. While an apparent 8 would tell a layperson that Eurogamer looks ambivalently upon the game, the actual content of the review is anything but.
Click to expand...

An 8 is a great score - at least if you actually use a 10 point scale with 5-6 being average.
 
IGN video review had slight spoilers imo, but I have been on mostly media blackout for this game for a while so I probably shouldn't watch any and just play it on Heroic when it ships.
 
So basically, this is more Halo business as usual.

Good. I love Halo and I were worried they would turn it into something else.
Click to expand...

Pretty much sums it up - most of the 'negative' points /reviews are criticisms for being too Halo, where a lot of Hardcore fans were worried about it losing that Halo 'feel'.

To a certain extent 343 were always going to be damned if they do, damned if they don't, it looks like they've struck a perfect balance to me.
 
Trey said:
It really, truly is. The EG review employs salient criticisms that are articulated far better than their contemporaries have managed. While an apparent 8 would tell a layperson that Eurogamer looks ambivalently upon the game, the actual content of the review is anything but.
Click to expand...
Exactly, I have so much respect for Parkin. He's pretty much their best reviewer.
 
Biggest-Geek-Ever said:
CVG 8/10 http://www.computerandvideogames.co...nning-reprise-of-classic-halo-moments-review/

The comments about the game's scale have me a little bummed. :/
Click to expand...

Just from watching some parts of the leak streams that doesn't sound right, I remember seeing quite a few enemies on the screen at once and thinking, shit, that's a lot of enemies.

Didn't 343 also say they were building the biggest levels in a Halo game when someone was worried they would be narrow?
 
hi guys

i played this game and had access to the NDA. a few of the reviews i've seen so far have treated the NDA very closely wow lol :)

there's a lot we were not allowed to talk about in the campaign (all good dont worry, MS was just super worried about spoilers)

game is fuck awesome btw

also if someone says the game doesnt have tons of guys on screen at once, they are full of it :)
 
Dennis said:
It plays like Halo?
Click to expand...
If I wanted something that played like the older games, I'd play the older games.

New company, new trilogy, and yet more of the same old same old?

Sorry, but that's just plain boring. Take the gameplay in a new, fresh direction; don't just regurgitate the same shit we've been getting for the past 12 years in a prettier package and call it a day.
 
IGN said:
Halo 4 is a masterstroke everyone can and should celebrate, and its two guaranteed sequels instantly make the next-generation Xbox a must-own system, with Halo 5 its most anticipated title. Halo has been rebuilt. It has been redefined. And it has been reinvigorated. The Xbox's original king has returned to his rightful place on the throne.
Click to expand...

lol IGN can´t wait to get a Durango.
 
Baconsammy said:
Such crap. Gamespot, IGN etc do a fine job articulating their issues with the game too.
Click to expand...

I should have instead said "out of the reviews I've so far read." My mistake for jumping the gun. You must forgive me: in all my prior experiences in consulting these sites for their opinions on games, only in very rare cases does Eurogamer come up short.

Dennis said:
An 8 is a great score - at least if you actually use a 10 point scale with 5-6 being average.
Click to expand...

Tru
 
Baconsammy said:
Gamespot and IGN's video reviews are great. After Gerstmann's shitty Borderlands 2 review, I don't put much stock in anything he says. No biggie.
Click to expand...

I felt the same way about Borderlands2, after putting 150hrs into Borderlands1.
Great game no doubt, but felt like I was playing the exact same game, just in different areas.

Maybe reviews should offer up 3 review scores.
Custom Halo4 scores for you:

8.5 = You've never played this franchise before. You'll like it.
10 = You are a big fan of the franchise, and looking for more. You'll be lovin' it.
7 = You've played the previous games, and am looking for something new to the series. You won't be too impressed.

I put far more stock into the opinions of the GiantBomb guys, than I do GameSpot and esp IGN.
Still remember that 10/10 for GTA4...
 
Good Job Bob said:
If I wanted something that played like the older games, I'd play the older games.

New company, new trilogy, and yet more of the same old same old?

Sorry, but that's just plain boring. Take the gameplay in a new, fresh direction; don't just regurgitate the same shit we've been getting for the past 12 years in a prettier package and call it a day.
Click to expand...

The problem is if they had radically changed it people would have not liked it.

If you don't like halo you wont like H4 but those who like halo will fucking LOVE it

edit: you may as well string me up as well. It is the best halo yet, it was the one that connected most with me, at least since Halo 1. Definately the best of this generation
 
Destructoid said:
Gameplay wise, it's largely what you would come to expect out of a Halo.
Click to expand...

Destructoid said:
10/10
Click to expand...

Uh... huh.

Not that I'm expecting/hoping for low scores, but a lot of these reviews are giving out realllllly high scores for "wow amaze they did it they made Halo again". Very interested to try out the game. I guess the level design is bar none?
 
Trey said:
I should have instead said "out of the reviews I've so far read." My mistake for jumping the gun. You must forgive me: in all my prior experiences in consulting these sites for their opinions on games, only in very rare cases does Eurogamer come up short.
Click to expand...

Except when it comes to not standing up for journalistic integrity.
 
Baconsammy said:
Gamespot and IGN's video reviews are great. After Gerstmann's shitty Borderlands 2 review, I don't put much stock in anything he says. No biggie.
Click to expand...
Except Borderlands 2 was a huge disappointment. I still liked the game and played it to completion, but I played hundreds of hours of Borderlands. BL2 only sucked me in for 25 or so.

You can be disappointed in a game and still like it. Halo 4 will likely be the same. Fun, but a let-down.
 
Good Job Bob said:
If I wanted something that played like the older games, I'd play the older games.

New company, new trilogy, and yet more of the same old same old?

Sorry, but that's just plain boring. Take the gameplay in a new, fresh direction; don't just regurgitate the same shit we've been getting for the past 12 years in a prettier package and call it a day.
Click to expand...

Halo 5 is a Tetris variant confirmed.

Einbroch said:
Except Borderlands 2 was a huge disappointment.
Click to expand...

No it wasn't.
 
4-the_rock_clap_clap_gif.gif


Seriously congrats to 343 for taking the handoff and showing whats in store. I actually said "Jezuz" at a couple of those reviews.
 
I'm a pretty darn happy guy tonight. Can't wait till everyone gets the chance to play on November 6th.
 
I cant take the reviewers that wanted innovation seriously. Halo is Halo is Halo. There has not been innovation to the series whatsoever after the first one, its a great series that improves on each entry, dont break what works.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Mario Kart World Review thread
Business Analysis Review  2
52
70
Shaki12345 replied
Revenge of the Savage Planet | Review Thread
Review 
16
352
Aguero9320 replied
  • Poll
Doom: The Dark Ages | Review Thread
Analysis Review  7 8 9 10 11
533
2K
Super Lemon Drop replied
Lunar Remastered Collection | Review Thread
Opinion Review 
43
3K
anthony2690 replied
Review Fatal Fury: City of the Wolves | Review Thread
Analysis Review 
20
492
March Climber replied
Top Bottom