I think there isn't really a consensus, since Play Arts did such ambivalent jobs on their figures. Some are just horrible, others pretty decent. I have four Play Arts Kai: Meryl Silverburgh, FemShep, Harley Quinn, Lara Croft and Lupo and I can see both sides on them. Play Arts has a huge quality control problem. None of my figures is bad but some are just not the same quality as others. By the time PA paint jobs got better, I don't think I would call any bad painted but the joints on some like Lupo aren't that good, while Meryl or Harley stand by itself without question. Sometimes the figure feature pretty annoying features in the abdomen section. As much as I love Play Arts FemShep, her "hole" thanks to the diaper pants looking can be very annoying.
I can recommend Play Arts Kai in all conscience but if there is any consensus it's: Look up reviews, don't buy blind or you could regret it.