• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

7 killed at Jerusalem school plus 2 gunmen killed too :-(

Status
Not open for further replies.
JERUSALEM - Two gunmen infiltrated a Jewish seminary in Jerusalem and opened fire in a dining hall Thursday night, killing at least seven people, police and rescue workers said.


Channel 2 TV said police special forces killed the two infiltrators.

Rescue workers said at least 10 people were wounded although Israeli media reported a larger number hurt.

The attack came a day after Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice persuaded moderate Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas to return to peace talks with Israel. It came on the same day as Egyptian officials were trying to mediate a truce between Palestinian militants and Israel.

Jerusalem police spokesman Shmuel Ben Ruby said one of the gunmen was wearing what at first appeared to be an explosives vest but turned out to be a belt holding extra ammunition.

He said students were being evacuated from the building. Hundreds of police surrounded the area and searched the campus as ambulances raced to the scene.

"One or two terrorists infiltrated the Mercaz Harav seminary and opened fire in all directions," the police spokesman said. "One terrorist was killed in an exchange of fire, and apparently he had an explosives belt."

The gunmen entered a dining hall where about 80 people were gathered and opened fire, witnesses said.

"There are at least seven killed and 10 people wounded," said Eli Dein, director of Israel's rescue service.

The seminar is the Mercaz Harav yeshiva in the Kiryat Moshe quarter at the entrance of Jerusalem, a well-known center of Jewish studies identified with the leadership of the Jewish settlement movement in the West Bank.

There were no attacks by Palestinian militants in Jerusalem during 2007, though police and the military claimed to have foiled many attempts. Between 2001 and 2004, at the height of Palestinian-Israeli fighting, Jerusalem was a frequent target of Palestinian attacks, including suicide bombings on buses.

In Gaza City, residents went out into the streets and fired rifles in celebration in the air after hearing news of the attack on the seminary.

Fucking jerks. You destroy your own cause.

http://news.yahoo.com/s/nm/20080306/wl_nm/palestinians_israel_violence_dc
 

SUPREME1

Banned
I know I'll get flamed for this, but..

Can someone posts stats on how many children have been killed on both sides?

I'm curious to what the number actually might be.
 

AmMortal

Banned
ImperialConquest said:
I know I'll get flamed for this, but..

Can someone posts stats on how many children have been killed on both sides?

I'm curious to what the number actually might be.

The loss of even one is way too high.
 

KRS7

Member
Hope this isn't true, but I heard on CNN that there are celebrations in Gaza now because of this event. That is real classy.
 

Atrus

Gold Member
"In Gaza City, residents went out into the streets and fired rifles in celebration in the air after hearing news of the attack on the seminary."

Any of those carrying a gun, and especially firing it, should be acceptably marked for death. While the Israeli's should be pressured to keep more efficient accountability of their military tactics, these gun-totters have clearly indicated to everyone that they are not a part of the civilian contingent.
 

AmMortal

Banned
Atrus said:
"In Gaza City, residents went out into the streets and fired rifles in celebration in the air after hearing news of the attack on the seminary."

Any of those carrying a gun, and especially firing it, should be acceptably marked for death. While the Israeli's should be pressured to keep more efficient accountability of their military tactics, these gun-totters have clearly indicated to everyone that they are not a part of the civilian contingent.


no doubt, there are extremist people on both sides, we should remember though that not all Isrealis and Palestinians want war. Victims on both sides, although I have to say that Palestinians suffer more, just on a humanitarian level.
 
speculawyer said:

Their only cause seems to have been bringing pain and misery to innocent Israelies.

They haven't done anything to the Palestinian cause however, that isn't being brought on them by Israel already. Until they can find some kind of agreement that marginalises the extreme elements within the likes of Hamas, and stop curbing the freedom of innocent people, shit like this is gonna keep happening for many more years to come.
 

vangace

Member
Jason's Ultimatum said:
Palestinians need to realize that in order for them to have any kind of future, they need to repudiate Hamas.

So sad about the news, though. :(


That will never happen as long as Isreal keeps dropping bombs in the street. I think Isreal needs to be proactive in reassuring the palestinian people that they are really interested in a peace that will help both their countries. However, if you a talking peace today and tommorrow you drop a bomb in the street killing innocent people, the situation becomes a lost cause. Isreal should start using its drone technology more rather than dropping bombs which kill innocent people indiscrinately.

I wish both sides should take a pause and take a look at the burden of war that is put on the innocent people. However, I still put the onus on Isreal to take the lead in trying to end this bloody war.
 

pewye

Banned
the story is on cnn frontpage.

30 palestinians were killed the other day, and CNN didn't even bother to put it as a headline. :|

I fucking hate American media.
 

AmMortal

Banned
pewye said:
the story is on cnn frontpage.

30 palestinians were killed the other day, and CNN didn't even bother to put it as a headline. :|

I fucking hate American media.


I know what you mean, Al jazeera & BBC are more credible
 

Jeff-DSA

Member
Warrior300 said:
I know what you mean, Al jazeera & BBC are more credible

Al Jazeera isn't biased.

:lol :lol :lol :lol :lol :lol :lol :lol :lol :lol :lol :lol

BBC is much better, yes. But Al Jazeera?
 

GSG Flash

Nobody ruins my family vacation but me...and maybe the boy!
And Israel will kill another 50 Palestinians in response. I don't condone this action, but it's hard to feel much sorrow or remorse for this when 60 Palestinians were killed by Israel the other day.
 

Atrus

Gold Member
Warrior300 said:
no doubt, there are extremist people on both sides, we should remember though that not all Isrealis and Palestinians want war. Victims on both sides, although I have to say that Palestinians suffer more, just on a humanitarian level.

Of course. I just support the complete and utter liquidation of groups dedicated to murdering civilians and indoctrination of children into martyrdom. These enemies of the species cannot be allowed to exist.

When the Palestinian peoples can be separated from the militants and has a representative sovereign government for these peoples, then some real inroads can be made. Unfortunately, they have no such representative as of this moment.
 

AmMortal

Banned
Atrus said:
Of course. I just support the complete and utter liquidation of groups dedicated to murdering civilians and indoctrination of children into martyrdom. These enemies of the species cannot be allowed to exist.

When the Palestinian peoples can be separated from the militants and has a representative sovereign government for these peoples, then some real inroads can be made. Unfortunately, they have no such representative as of this moment.


Exactly, if the people made clear on where they stand instead of hiding what they intend , then it would go smoothly.
 

KarishBHR

Member
How about instead of debating who is wronger, we just settle it at the fact that 8 innocent people died today... while studying, any 60 other people (some innocent, some not) died the other day

Both are sad sad sad
 

SUPREME1

Banned
OgnodoD said:
Israel better retaliate hard. (Can't wait for the whining this comment will receive.)


But, it was the Palies who retaliated to Israel murdering 30 Palie civilians.

Lulz at you.


Lemme guess,"Bring it on!", amirite?

getabrainmorans.gif
 
BigJonsson said:
And the leader of Hamas will be killed in.........

Hamas were not responsible for this attack. The gunmen came from the west bank according to the information released thus far.

"The school is a well-known centre for Jewish studies and most students are aged between 18 and 30." - BBC

So these victims are not counted as children.

OgnodoD said:
Israel better retaliate hard. (Can't wait for the whining this comment will receive.)

I hope the Palestinians retaliate even harder....

....
 

AmMortal

Banned
Both governments are acting childish. They need to just stop. period.

Isreal gives back what the Palestinians have owned until it was taken from them in 1950's(?)
Remember in the times of Jesus it was Palestine not Isreal. Because Isreal was a minority like the immigrants in the EU/US.

BUT
Palestinians need to stop blowing shit up.
 

SUPREME1

Banned
Thudmaster said:
Hamas were not responsible for this attack. The gunmen came from the west bank according to the information released thus far.

"The school is a well-known centre for Jewish studies and most students are aged between 18 and 30." - BBC

So these victims are not counted as children.



Wow, the way the US media portrayed it, it seemed like kids are the ones that died.

Shady.
 

SUPREME1

Banned
Warrior300 said:
Both governments are acting childish. They need to just stop. period.

Isreal gives back what the Palestinians have owned until it was taken from them in 1950's(?)
Remember in the times of Jesus it was JUDEA not Isreal. Because Isreal was a minority like the immigrants in the EU/US.

BUT
Palestinians need to stop blowing shit up.

Fix'd.
 

Wraith

Member
pewye said:
http://www.ifamericansknew.org/stats/deaths.html

Children Killed :

Israelis: 119

Palestinians: 982


Civilians* Killed:


Israelis: 705

Palestinians: 2,087 - 2,974


Look at the number of children killed in 2007. Only one Israeli kid was killed, and he was palestinian with Israeli citizenship!!!

And 59 palestinian kids died last year

That site is moderately to extremely biased. Here's a (probably equally biased) refutation of it:

http://www.themiddleeastnow.com/ifamericansknew.html

My point is that numbers like that coming from an organization with an obvious agenda should be viewed skeptically.
 

SUPREME1

Banned
Regardless, it's clearly one-sided in terms of power...

Whatever the numbers, I'm sure Isreal is ahead by a lot in terms of children killed.


That's all the bothers me, the kids being killed... Let Mr. Cohen and Mr. Hamza kill themselves til the cows come home, but the kids should be left alone, period.


Adults killing kids FTL.
 

AmMortal

Banned
ImperialConquest said:
Regardless, it's clearly one-sided in terms of power...

Whatever the numbers, I'm sure Isreal is ahead by a lot in terms of children killed.


That's all the bothers me, the kids being killed... Let Mr. Cohen and Mr. Hamza kill themselves til the cows come home, but the kids should be left alone, period.


Adults killing kids FTL.

Good post
Period.
 

bob_arctor

Tough_Smooth
"We bless the (Jerusalem) operation. It will not be the last," Hamas said in a text message sent to reporters.

Text message! :lol Unreal.

Hezbollah's Al-Manar television in Lebanon said a previously unknown group called the Martyrs of Imad Mughniyeh and Gaza claimed responsibility for the attack.

Mughniyeh, a top Hezbollah commander, was killed Feb. 12 by a car bomb in Syria. Hezbollah blamed his assassination on Israel, which denied any role.

LINK
 

Chichikov

Member
Wraith said:
That site is moderately to extremely biased. Here's a (probably equally biased) refutation of it:

http://www.themiddleeastnow.com/ifamericansknew.html

My point is that numbers like that coming from an organization with an obvious agenda should be viewed skeptically.
Short skimming through this site reveals it's absolutely full of shit.
I don't think you'll be able to find a single sane person that would argue that there are less Palestinian casualties than Israelis.
And anyway, I don't know the point of such death math; it's meaningless and reduces the tragic loss of innocent human lives into a suffering pissing contest.
 

Wraith

Member
ImperialConquest said:
Regardless, it's clearly one-sided in terms of power...

Whatever the numbers, I'm sure Isreal is ahead by a lot in terms of children killed.


That's all the bothers me, the kids being killed... Let Mr. Cohen and Mr. Hamza kill themselves til the cows come home, but the kids should be left alone, period.


Adults killing kids FTL.

It's not as though Israel specifically targets children, while suicide bombers certainly do so...

Either way, I agree with the second part of what you say.

Chichikov said:
Short skimming through this site reveals it's absolutely full of shit.
I don't think you'll be able to find a single sane person that would argue that there are less Palestinian casualties than Israelis.
And anyway, I don't know the point of such death math; it's meaningless and reduces the tragic loss of innocent human lives into a suffering pissing contest.

Neither I nor that site is arguing that the number of Palestinian deaths is smaller(or even close, really) to the number of Israeli deaths.
 

pewye

Banned
ImperialConquest said:
Regardless, it's clearly one-sided in terms of power...

Whatever the numbers, I'm sure Isreal is ahead by a lot in terms of children killed.


That's all the bothers me, the kids being killed... Let Mr. Cohen and Mr. Hamza kill themselves til the cows come home, but the kids should be left alone, period.


Adults killing kids FTL.

Children they killed, or Israeli children killed?

I am pretty sure that the number of Palestinian kids killed is way higher
 
Chichikov said:
Short skimming through this site reveals it's absolutely full of shit.
I don't think you'll be able to find a single sane person that would argue that there are less Palestinian casualties than Israelis.
And anyway, I don't know the point of such death math; it's meaningless and reduces the tragic loss of innocent human lives into a suffering pissing contest.

Wow, your way of writing amazes me.

( I'm serious)
 
Wraith said:
It's not as though Israel specifically targets children, while suicide bombers certainly do so...

Either way, I agree with the second part of what you say.



Neither I nor that site is arguing that the number of Palestinian deaths is smaller(or even close, really) to the number of Israeli deaths.

Are you sure?

There were anti-Israeli demonstrations across the West Bank. A number of protesters were reported to have been injured in clashes in Hebron, and a teenager was shot dead near Birzeit university in Ramallah, reportedly by a Jewish settler. -BBC
 

Wraith

Member
Thudmaster said:
Are you sure?

There were anti-Israeli demonstrations across the West Bank. A number of protesters were reported to have been injured in clashes in Hebron, and a teenager was shot dead near Birzeit university in Ramallah, reportedly by a Jewish settler. -BBC

I was speaking of Israeli military, of course, who I believe have caused much of the death count. Civilians are a completely different story.
 

140.85

Cognitive Dissonance, Distilled
Hamas 'blesses' terror attack at Jerusalem seminary

"We bless the (Jerusalem) operation. It will not be the last," Hamas said in a statement.

Gaza: Thousands celebrate Jerusalem attack

Gaza's streets filled with joyous crowds of thousands on Thursday evening following the terror attack at a Jerusalem rabbinical seminary in which eight people were killed.

In mosques in Gaza City and northern Gaza, many residents went to perform the prayers of thanksgiving.

Armed men fired in the air in celebration and others passed out sweets to passersby.

Yeah...you do that.

Jerusalem police chief says gunman who opened fire on yeshiva students shot by IDF officer, eight people reported killed

Yitzhak Dadon, a student, said he was armed with a rifle and waited on the roof of a nearby building. ''He came out of the library spraying automatic fire ... the terrorist came to the entrance and I shot him twice in the head,'' he said.
 
Warrior300 said:
no doubt, there are extremist people on both sides, we should remember though that not all Isrealis and Palestinians want war. Victims on both sides, although I have to say that Palestinians suffer more, just on a humanitarian level.
But what really sucks is that it only takes a small number on each side that do want war to keep the violence going. And both sides do have extremists. There are the hard-right Israeli settlers and hardcore Islamist Hamas fighters..
 

Atrus

Gold Member
Thudmaster said:
Are you sure?

There were anti-Israeli demonstrations across the West Bank. A number of protesters were reported to have been injured in clashes in Hebron, and a teenager was shot dead near Birzeit university in Ramallah, reportedly by a Jewish settler. -BBC

Most Palestinian casualties on the part of Israeli's are the result of military operations against militants. The militants on the other hand attack civilians, typically in scenarios where they are unarmed or unable to respond because the delivery vehicle is a suicide bomber.

To suggest like you just did that the Israeli's may be specifically targeting children based on one-off situations between settlers is not only disingenuous, it makes you part of the same inhuman coalition of blood-letters.
 

SUPREME1

Banned
Atrus said:
The Israeli military on the other hand attack civilians, typically in scenarios where they are unarmed or unable to respond because the delivery vehicle is a bomb.


See how when you switch up two words, how nicely it still fits.

Lol at trying to justify Palie deaths as simply being collateral damage.


How is a suicide bomber any different than a tank suddenly rumbling down the street and taking out a building? People can't defend themselves against such things.

Anyway, like I said...

The IDF are a shameful bunch of monsters for killing children willy-nilly and so are the parents who would turn their kids into child soldiers.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom