• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Ace Attorney Community Thread - MUNCHMUNCHMUNCHMUNCHMUNCH

F

FluxWaveZ

Member
Neat, something to look forward to, though I don't want to take in too much AA6 info. Mainly want to hear more about the anime.
 
L

Lusankya

Member
Yeah, there was some internet drama and now both translation groups of DGS stopped working. What the heck, my faith in humanity is at a new low point.
 
D

daydream

Banned
Lusankya said:
Yeah, there was some internet drama and now both translation groups of DGS stopped working. What the heck, my faith in humanity is at a new low point.
Click to expand...

that's too bad

were they working on a translation patch or just a script (as in, to be used for a subbed yt playthrough, for example)? since i wouldn't have had much use for the latter myself
 
F

FluxWaveZ

Member
daydream said:
that's too bad

were they working on a translation patch or just a script (as in, to be used for a subbed yt playthrough, for example)? since i wouldn't have had much use for the latter myself
Click to expand...

The latter probably would be a waste of time, considering dowolf's ongoing trasnlated YouTube playthrough. It was probably the former.
 
G

GSR

Member
daydream said:
that's too bad

were they working on a translation patch or just a script (as in, to be used for a subbed yt playthrough, for example)? since i wouldn't have had much use for the latter myself
Click to expand...

FluxWaveZ said:
The latter probably would be a waste of time, considering dowolf's ongoing trasnlated YouTube playthrough. It was probably the former.
Click to expand...

You misunderstand - it was the two YouTube subbers (DoWolf and "DGS") that stopped due to each having issues with the other. As far as I know the rom-hacking fan translation group is same as it ever was (whatever that means here.)

Frustrating all around.
 
F

FluxWaveZ

Member
GSR said:
You misunderstand - it was the two YouTube subbers (DoWolf and "DGS") that stopped due to each having issues with the other. As far as I know the rom-hacking fan translation group is same as it ever was (whatever that means here.)

Frustrating all around.
Click to expand...

...Huh? So it's what I was talking about that halted instead, while the other effort is still ongoing? That's really odd, I was thinking of watching the videos as a last resort if the fan translation never came about.
 
G

GSR

Member
FluxWaveZ said:
...Huh? So it's what I was talking about that halted instead, while the other effort is still ongoing? That's really odd, I was thinking of watching the videos as a last resort if the fan translation never came about.
Click to expand...

As far as I know the situation is:

There were two YouTube subbers, DoWolf and a pair calling their channel "Dai Gyakuten Saiban". DoWolf aimed at more of a localization, was slower, and uploaded as he went; "DGS" was more focused on speed, had a more literal/awkward translation, and uploaded big chunks of the cases before subbing them.

The two apparently talked prior, but more friction showed up recently which resulted in DoWolf calling out the other group in the most recent video and deciding to quit out of frustration. Then the callout led to the "DGS" pair quitting as well, though they may have walked that back slightly.

Like I said, frustrating all around.
 
C

ColossalLazy

Member
Ace Attorney anime starts Spring

Directed by Ayumu Watanabe at A-1 Pictures, series composition by Atsuhiro Tomioka and Kaowru Wada doing the music.

Starring Yūki Kaji as Phoenix, Aoi Yūki as Maya Fey, Masashi Tamaki as Miles Edgeworth, Chie Nakamura as Mia Fey.

Source
 
K

KuwabaraTheMan

Banned
ColossalLazy said:
Ace Attorney anime starts Spring

Directed by Ayumu Watanabe at A-1 Pictures, series composition by Atsuhiro Tomioka and Kaowru Wada doing the music.

Starring Yūki Kaji as Phoenix, Aoi Yūki as Maya Fey, Masashi Tamaki as Miles Edgeworth, Chie Nakamura as Mia Fey.

Source
Click to expand...

Ayumu Watanabe? That's very promising. Wada is a strong composer, too.
 
G

GSR

Member
Japanese Twitter does not seem happy that they keep changing up the voice cast, heh.

Also, Jump Festa stages start in half an hour.
 
N

Not75Drops

Member
I caved and watched the 1st case of DGS translated on Youtube. Even in the first case, there's a number of things that would make localizing this weird, but I don't think it's impossible. On the other hand, AA6 probably won't be released until late next year and with NX rumoured to be releasing next year with a mobile unit, along with the fact that Capcom now seems to ignore any non-Phoenix games, I doubt they'll even bother.

Speaking on case itself, it was pretty interesting for the first case, the one major problem was
is that it was way too long, especially the last section which they obviously dragged out. Having no motive is weird as well. They did a similar concept with Kristoph but with how much I've heard that this game relies on potential sequels, I wonder if it will even be answered in this game, since the victim is clearly related to one of the other characters.
 
Shouta

Shouta

Member
I've actually been playing Dai Gyakuten Saiban myself. On case 2 in fact.

Case 1 is long and honestly, somewhat easy in regards to the whodunnit but path to unravel it is pretty good for a first case.
 
T

The Scollard

Member
Hey everybody. I've been an Ace Attorney fan for years (played the trilogy on DS back in 2009), and I just recently found this thread (though I've been a more of a lurker for the past while).

However, I'm working on a writing an AA case and I'm trying there's some information about characters, their ages, and the dates of certain big cases in the series. First off, I was wondering if any of you have played AAI Case 4 recently, and could tell me what was Miles' age during that case (working on a timeline to figure out how old he should be in my case).

Also, I was wondering one what date exactly did the KG-8 Incident (Cece Yew's murder) take place. The Ace Attorney Wiki and Court Records.net seem to contradict each other, with CR saying it takes place in 2008 and the wiki saying 2009. I'm more inclined to believe CR, since the wiki messed up on some ages because they didn't realize the majority of AA3 takes place in 2018, but I want to make sure. In the same vein, I was also wondering what date AAI Case 4 took place on.

If any of you could give me some help with this info, I'll be really grateful.
 
G

GSR

Member
Shouta said:
I've actually been playing Dai Gyakuten Saiban myself. On case 2 in fact.

Case 1 is long and honestly, somewhat easy in regards to the whodunnit but path to unravel it is pretty good for a first case.
Click to expand...

Yeah, case one is fun but just too long for its own good. Looking forward to your thoughts on case two, I really liked it. (Import thread is over here, by the way.)

The Scollard said:
Hey everybody. I've been an Ace Attorney fan for years (played the trilogy on DS back in 2009), and I just recently found this thread (though I've been a more of a lurker for the past while).

However, I'm working on a writing an AA case and I'm trying there's some information about characters, their ages, and the dates of certain big cases in the series. First off, I was wondering if any of you have played AAI Case 4 recently, and could tell me what was Miles' age during that case (working on a timeline to figure out how old he should be in my case).

Also, I was wondering one what date exactly did the KG-8 Incident (Cece Yew's murder) take place. The Ace Attorney Wiki and Court Records.net seem to contradict each other, with CR saying it takes place in 2008 and the wiki saying 2009. I'm more inclined to believe CR, since the wiki messed up on some ages because they didn't realize the majority of AA3 takes place in 2018, but I want to make sure. In the same vein, I was also wondering what date AAI Case 4 took place on.

If any of you could give me some help with this info, I'll be really grateful.
Click to expand...

Hoo boy. Timeline stuff in AA is not fun. Lemme see if I can suss this out.

The only hard date in the series is that the DL-6 incident was on December 28th, 2001. That's fifteen years before AA1 (2016-2017). AA2 takes place over the following year (2017-2018). AA3 is 2018-2019 and AAI is strictly 2019.

AAI-4 takes place seven years before AAI. So AAI-4 should be in September 2012, right...?

Except then a contradiction pops up. AA3-4 takes place six years before AA3, which puts it in February 2012. But AAI-4 happened before AA3-4!

So Croik's reckoning back when she put together the timeline was that you have to bump back AAI-4 to September 2011 for the timeline to make sense. And you can kind of fudge it - AAI-4 is September 2011, the rest of AAI is March 2019. Just gotta round down 7.5 years to 7 years. (This doesn't solve a certain issue with Edgeworth's birthday, but that's a whole other problem.)

Now, with AAI-4 placed at September 2011, we look at the case, which says KG-8 was 'three years ago'. Which puts KG-8 sometime in 2008. In other words

AAI-4: 7.5 years before AAI [2011-2019 = '7 years']
AA3-4: 6-ish years before AA3 [2012-2018 = '6 years']
AA3-1: 4.75-ish years before AA3 [2013-2018 ='5 years']

All that said: you can shift all this forward a year depending on how you take AA3-4's placement.

If you take it as six years before 3-5 (rather than before 3-2, 3-3, or some other part of 'present-day' T&T), then it winds up in February 2013, which puts AAI-4 in September 2012 after all, and KG-8 in 2009. This is likely what the AA wiki was using as their reckoning. And to be fair, 3-5 uses "six years ago" in relation to a very firm point in time (
Phoenix in the hospital
), while the ending to 3-1 probably alludes to 3-5 (Phoenix says "something has happened" that brings up memories of 3-1).

Then it becomes:
AAI-4: 6.5 years before AAI [2012-2019 = '7 years']
AA3-4: 6 years before 3-5/AAI [2013-2019 = '6 years']
AA3-1: 4.75-ish years before 3-5/AAI [2014-2019 ='5 years']

And this is without getting into the whole mess that is the characters' ages! Somewhere, someone wishes they'd left that pesky "2001" off a case file...
 
M

Makonero

Member
For those of you who are expectantly awaiting AA6, might I turn your attention to Aviary Attorney? It just launched on Steam and although I've only played Act 1, it has very similar gameplay, a unique artstyle, and very good writing so far! Pick it up!
 
T

The Scollard

Member
GSR said:
Hoo boy. Timeline stuff in AA is not fun. Lemme see if I can suss this out.

The only hard date in the series is that the DL-6 incident was on December 28th, 2001. That's fifteen years before AA1 (2016-2017). AA2 takes place over the following year (2017-2018). AA3 is 2018-2019 and AAI is strictly 2019.

AAI-4 takes place seven years before AAI. So AAI-4 should be in September 2012, right...?

Except then a contradiction pops up. AA3-4 takes place six years before AA3, which puts it in February 2012. But AAI-4 happened before AA3-4!

So Croik's reckoning back when she put together the timeline was that you have to bump back AAI-4 to September 2011 for the timeline to make sense. And you can kind of fudge it - AAI-4 is September 2011, the rest of AAI is March 2019. Just gotta round down 7.5 years to 7 years. (This doesn't solve a certain issue with Edgeworth's birthday, but that's a whole other problem.)

Now, with AAI-4 placed at September 2011, we look at the case, which says KG-8 was 'three years ago'. Which puts KG-8 sometime in 2008. In other words

AAI-4: 7.5 years before AAI [2011-2019 = '7 years']
AA3-4: 6-ish years before AA3 [2012-2018 = '6 years']
AA3-1: 4.75-ish years before AA3 [2013-2018 ='5 years']

All that said: you can shift all this forward a year depending on how you take AA3-4's placement.

If you take it as six years before 3-5 (rather than before 3-2, 3-3, or some other part of 'present-day' T&T), then it winds up in February 2013, which puts AAI-4 in September 2012 after all, and KG-8 in 2009. This is likely what the AA wiki was using as their reckoning. And to be fair, 3-5 uses "six years ago" in relation to a very firm point in time (
Phoenix in the hospital
), while the ending to 3-1 probably alludes to 3-5 (Phoenix says "something has happened" that brings up memories of 3-1).

Then it becomes:
AAI-4: 6.5 years before AAI [2012-2019 = '7 years']
AA3-4: 6 years before 3-5/AAI [2013-2019 = '6 years']
AA3-1: 4.75-ish years before 3-5/AAI [2014-2019 ='5 years']

And this is without getting into the whole mess that is the characters' ages! Somewhere, someone wishes they'd left that pesky "2001" off a case file...
Click to expand...

Thanks... now my head hurts.

I think I'll be using the "AAI-4 is in 2011" timeline, since I always took 3-1 as taking place in 2013.

Do you remember what Edgeworth's age was during AAI-4, since I'm trying to get a grasp of what age he should be in the case (I know that Edgeworth's birthday makes no sense, so I'm planning on using AAI-4 as my anchor). Also, the DL-6 Incident happened when he was eight, correct?
 
F

FluxWaveZ

Member
Wait, where the hell was there a PV for the Ace Attorney anime?

CZ0M8rLUAAIC7QW.jpg:orig
CZ0M8tjUEAAYq_7.jpg:orig
Click to expand...

And how am I only finding about this now? Are these real? Thought there'd be some with it coming out relatively soon, but I didn't think I'd miss it.
 
S

Seven Force

Banned
Wow, the brief bit you can make out of the
evidence room encounter with Von Karma
looks incredibly faithful to the actual art asset for that location from the game.
 
G

GSR

Member
Hold up a sec. While it's true those could be from the anime, a few folks have pointed out it's pretty common for pachinko machines to have specially made scenes. Couple that with the quality, lack of attribution to A-1, and the fact they're showing 1-4 and JFA months before the airdate, and it really starts to look like those are just one-offs for the pachinko.

Still pretty cool.
 
F

FluxWaveZ

Member
GSR said:
Hold up a sec. While it's true those could be from the anime, a few folks have pointed out it's pretty common for pachinko machines to have specially made scenes. Couple that with the quality, lack of attribution to A-1, and the fact they're showing 1-4 and JFA months before the airdate, and it really starts to look like those are just one-offs for the pachinko.

Still pretty cool.
Click to expand...

Yeah, that's true and also why I added the "potentially modified" qualifier in my earlier comment. No clear indication that those scenes are from the anime, but I wish they were because they look great.
 
K

KuwabaraTheMan

Banned
Yeah, there's absolutely 0% chance they're from the anime. This early there's a decent chance they don't even have the first episode finished, never mind stuff from that far along.
 
C

CrimsonFist

Member
uTmYD4A.jpg
Click to expand...

Hey, don't know if there's any interest from people here, but the NeoGAF Mafia community is currently taking signups for it's 5th season, with one of the games being Phoenix Wright themed.

For anyone who hasn't heard of it, Mafia is a forum game which involves trying to identify the killers from amongst the players (or trying to stay hidden if you are one of the killers). The signup thread has a much better explanation than I can give though: http://www.neogaf.com/forum/showthread.php?t=1175429

If it sounds interesting, you should give it a try. I'm assuming that most people here at least like murder mysteries and shouting accusations at innocent people :p
 
Y

Yousefb

Member
Quick question regarding Dual Destinies: do I have to finish the game to access the DLC case? I finished the game a year ago and had downloaded the DLC at the time. But I did not play much of it as I ended up deleting it to make some space for another game on my SD card. Anyway I decided to re-download the game now to play the DLC case but the only selection available is "new game". It's been a while since I played it but I thought the DLC case was available from the beginning.
 
G

GSR

Member
Yousefb said:
Quick question regarding Dual Destinies: do I have to finish the game to access the DLC case? I finished the game a year ago and had downloaded the DLC at the time. But I did not play much of it as I ended up deleting it to make some space for another game on my SD card. Anyway I decided to re-download the game now to play the DLC case but the only selection available is "new game". It's been a while since I played it but I thought the DLC case was available from the beginning.
Click to expand...

You need to finish the first case to access the DLC.
 
O

orthodoxy1095

Banned
Guys. I have been stuck on that case in JFA since last October. I just can't power through it. It's killing me.

You know. That one.

HAHAHAHAHAHA

ugh.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Ace Attorney Fan Game ‘Echoes of a Turnabout: Franziska von Karma’ Revealed Seemingly Out of Nowhere With Free Demo
News Game Dev
12
681
Reaseru replied
Ace Attorney Investigations Collection announced (releases September 6, 2024)
News Trailer
41
2K
Thick Thighs Save Lives replied
Ace Attorney Investigations Collection | Preview Thread
Opinion
10
772
Danjin44 replied
Ace Attorney Investigations Collection | Review Thread
Analysis Review
8
722
Labadal replied
When Capcom planning to make Ace Attorney 7?
Opinion
11
2K
Hudo replied
Top Bottom