• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

American Idol: Season 4

Status
Not open for further replies.
top votes - Bo, Carrie, Constantine, Bonzell
bottom - Anwar, Scott, Anthony

GOOD-BYE .......................................

A


N





























Anwar....heh

Sad really as he was way better then Anthony and Scott.....both blow compared to him.
 
Well, there is something seriously wrong with the people voting. Anwar was easily top 5. Scott and Anthony suck. And that's all there is to it. The top 4 is still pretty accurate....but I will never understand how people can vote for those other two mooks.
 

MIMIC

Banned
Just one more week, Scott. :D

When we first saw Scott during the auditions, I called him for the top 5 (I also called Vonzell for the top 10).

If Anthony gets the boot first, my prediction'll be right. :)
 

themadcowtipper

Smells faintly of rancid stilton.
What the hell is wrong with that sweater clay was wearing. It was gray, hlaf the neck was green, one sleeve was yello the other pinks :lol
 

MIMIC

Banned
I just wish they didn't cut down the song like they did. I so wanted to hear her do the full-voice of "...for the will to carry on" instead of the falsetto.
 

AlphaSnake

...and that, kids, was the first time I sucked a dick for crack
AHAHAH. WTF WAS THAT? :lol :lol :lol Nickelback? OMG, I'm crying so hard it hurts.
 

themadcowtipper

Smells faintly of rancid stilton.
That was Bad, so bad i think they need to invent a new word for bad because , bad just dosn't convay the suckeyness off that.
 

MIMIC

Banned
Based on tonight:

1. Vonzell
2. Anthony
3. Bo
4. Carrie
5. Scott (that was so fucking emotionless)
6. Constantine (damn, that was bad)
 

AlphaSnake

...and that, kids, was the first time I sucked a dick for crack
WTF...that wasn't that bad. But man Vonzell and Anthony are the clear finalists.
 

MIMIC

Banned
Hmmm...and I thought Paula was fucking Simon...

Straight up, she'll tell you--Paula Abdul is mad.

Under orders from the diminutive American Idol judge, her lawyer, Martin Singer, fired off a warning to ABC this week, threatening legal action if the network proceeds with its upcoming exposé, Fallen Idol, scheduled to air next Wednesday.

"There's a false story that's defamatory to Paula...Her lawyer responded to that," Abdul's spokesperson told the New York Daily News.

The network has said its Primetime Live report will "explore explosive claims about behind-the-scenes activities at American Idol." Though ABC News has not commented on specifics of the special, published reports have suggested that those claims include allegations by former Idol contestant Corey Clark that he had an affair with Abdul.

Clark, who was booted from the first season of the talent search after his criminal record--which he didn't disclose to producers--was unearthed, is reportedly shopping a tell-all book proposal about his experiences on the show, including how Abdul allegedly offered him financial assistance for his career pursuits and pressured him to keep their romance quiet.


On Tuesday, a spokesperson for Abdul released a statement to Access Hollywood, denouncing Clark as an "admitted liar."

"Paula Abdul will not dignify the false statements made by Corey Clark with a response. Mr. Clark is an admitted liar and opportunist who engages in unlawful activities. He is communicating lies about Paula Abdul in order to generate interest in a book deal," the singer's rep stated.

Simon Cowell and Ryan Seacrest also leaped to their coworker's defense.

"There's no underhandedness going on behind the scenes," Cowell told syndicated newsmagazine Extra. In response to Clark's allegations, the usually surly judge stated, "I do think they're rubbish. I think this guy's out there to publicize a book.

"Paula, to be fair to her, will spend more time backstage with the contestants giving encouragement and everything else. But, that's not a bad thing!"

American Idol producers, on the other hand, apparently aren't quite as sure that Abdul is being honest about her possible fraternization with Clark.

According to the Los Angeles Times, Idol producers are looking into the allegations. A source close to the show told the Times that Abdul denied Clark's claims when initially quizzed by producers.

If the alleged romance did, in fact, occur, Abdul could be in violation of FCC rules pertaining to televised skill contests.

Section 508 of the Communications Act states that it is illegal for anyone "with intent to deceive the listening or viewing public...to supply to any contestant in a purportedly bona fide contest of intellectual knowledge or intellectual skill any special and secret assistance whereby the outcome of such contest will be in whole or in part prearranged or predetermined."

We're not sure if singing qualifies as an "intellectual skill," but "special and secret assistance" could apply to an whole multitude of sins.

No matter how explosive the claims Fallen Idol purports to explore may be, it's doubtful ABC can do much to derail Idol's monster ratings.

The talent search held onto the second and fourth spots in the ratings for the week ended Sunday, drawing 24.1 million viewers Tuesday night and 22.7 million viewers for Wednesday's results show.

Regarding the Corey Clark situation, I don't think it's true. I'll be watching that Primetime Live report, though.
 
MIMIC said:
Hmmm...and I thought Paula was fucking Simon...



Regarding the Corey Clark situation, I don't think it's true. I'll be watching that Primetime Live report, though.

She was also supposedly boning Justin. Those 2 dudes are the ones that she took the biggest liking too on the show also.
 

MIMIC

Banned
Yes!!! Vonzell is safe (but shouldn't have been in the bottom 3 in the first fucking place).

But Scott > Vonzell?? WTF?

But my prediction is right: Scott is in the top 5. :)

I wouldn't be surprised if Constantine was kicked off tonight.
 

MIMIC

Banned
Apparently, Anthony got his shit together, and people are voting more for him now...because for the past couple of weeks, he's been doing really well (performance wise). He's been picking the perfect songs.

Recap:

Bottom 3: Vonzell, Constantine, & Anthony
Voted off: Constantine

EDIT: Why the fuck did they devote that much time to his send-off song????
 

Link1110

Member
Aww, and I was hoping the last show would be Carrie, Bo, and Constantine with Bo or Constantine winning. Now it's all about Bo.
 

Tortfeasor

Member
I think the begining of the end for Constantine was him performing wearing so much mascara the week before. I think middle america was just a bit creeped out.
 
Anthony sucks. He got the sympathy vote after they showed that piece with his parents last night. I've never seen a great performance from him, just so-so to terrilbe. And honestly, how many times can you open your songs by sitting on the fucking steps. Scott fucking blows worse, he can't sing. He was damn terrible again tonight in that butchering of the Bee Gees. He must be getting the average fat guy vote or something. The top 3 are Vonzell, Carrie and Bo. I'll be surprised if the people who were voting for Constatine don't shift their votes to Bo now.
 

jett

D-Member
YES, constantbitch got owned. Fucking horrible voice. He shouldn't have gotten this far, just proves that this show is worthless.
 

Wellington

BAAAALLLINNN'
jiggle said:
WTF!
How can Scott not even be in the bottom three????

This I don't understand. He doesn't have the look, his talent is marginal, and he's not a good performer. It's the terrible trifecta.
 

MIMIC

Banned
Scott not being in the bottom 3 is more shocking than Constantine being voted off.

Constantine messed up by having an extremely horrible night. Apparently, a lot of people are still basing their votes on the most recent performance, instead of picking a favorite and staying with them.

When it got down 8 contestants, I stopped voting for my regular 3 (based on who I believed performed the best that night, regardless of whether they are or aren't my favorite) and funneled all my votes for one person: Vonzell.

Maybe now, people will just vote for one person.

I hope the Constantine fans feel as horrible as us Tamyra Grey fans did during season 1. :)
 

MIMIC

Banned
Vote for the worst :lol

EDIT: The Internet is abuzz with conspiracy theories as to Constantine's shocking (or not) departure.

People are saying that they couldn't get through because an "operator" kept coming up with the familiar "Your call did not go through." Since I'm with Cingular, I text all my votes, so I'm not familiar with any voting problems.
 

tt_deeb

Member
What a TERRIBLE performance by Constantine this week, he deserved to go I'm afraid. No one who does a Nickelback song is a true rocker. I'm glad Scott is doing well, I like him.
 

MIMIC

Banned
The Chosen One said:
Well that explains why Scott has lasted so long...

I highly doubt that enough people know about that site to Sway the outcome.

I'm glad Scott is doing well, I like him.

I like Scott as well, and I WANT to vote for him, but he has been so lifeless when he sings. He simply sings the song and displays no connection to it or with the audience.

Maybe he's been so dead because his confidence has been shot for being in the bottom 3. Maybe this'll boost his confidence and he'll actually PERFORM next week.

EDIT: :lol People be mad http://www.petitiononline.com/mod_perl/signed.cgi?123aifix
 

MIMIC

Banned
:lol The Smoking Gun got some dirt on Bo this time:

"Idol" Finalist Dodged Cocaine Rap

APRIL 28--One of the five remaining "American Idol" finalists was once arrested for felony cocaine possession, but had the charge dismissed last year after completing a so-called "diversion program" for first-time offenders, The Smoking Gun has learned. Harold "Bo" Bice, 29, was busted in June 2001 by Huntsville, Alabama cops and hit with the drug count, a Class C felony, according to the below warrant (Bice posted $1000 bond and was released from the Madison County Jail). After being postponed for a week at the request of prosecutors, a District Court preliminary hearing was set for August 29, 2001. But when a Huntsville Police Department investigator did not show, Judge Susan Moquin dismissed the Bice case, according to a court docket. But with prosecutors prepared to refile the felony count, Bice opted to enter a drug diversion program overseen by the district attorney's office, according to Heather Douglas, spokesperson for the Madison County D.A.. Bice entered the program in 2003 and, after successfully completing it, the coke case was bounced on April 28, 2004, Douglas said. Details of what Bice had to do in the diversion program are confidential, Douglas added. However, similar programs often require enrollees to submit to urine tests, undergo drug counseling, and attend awareness classes. If convicted of the felony charge, Bice would have faced a maximum of 10 years in jail, though a probationary term would have been more likely. A police spokesperson told TSG that the arresting officer, Mike Armstrong, no longer worked for the department and that the administrative officer on the case, Sgt. Michael Izzo, could not recall any details of the Bice bust. Court records do not describe the circumstances of Bice's arrest, except for the address where he was popped, a small strip mall. Bice, who worked at the time in a Huntsville bar, is a long-haired rocker whose gritty appearance and performances have stood out from "American Idol"'s usual pop pablum. On Fox Television's "Idol" web site, Bice reports that his "most embarrassing moment" was when he once "fell off stage during a show." (3 pages)
 

tt_deeb

Member
I didn't even know this until recently but Constantine's band got a record contract (same company who signed William Hung). Could this have been a reason why he's voted off? I doubt it.
 

MIMIC

Banned
More:

Bice, now 29, was arrested by Huntsville, Alabama police in June 2001 for felony cocaine possession, the site reports. The site goes on to say "he was arrested again in July 2003 near Birmingham and charged with marijuana possession, public intoxication, and possession of drug paraphernalia, according to court records."

FOX:

A spokesperson for Fox issued a statement saying “The information disclosed on various salacious gossip websites regarding Bo Bice’s past was already well-known to FOX and the producers of 'American Idol.' From the beginning, Bo was honest and forthcoming in revealing his previous indiscretions and their outcome.”
 

MIMIC

Banned
SHOCK AND AWE:

groupshock042705.jpg
\

:lol Constantine was on Elimidate. http://elimidate.warnerbros.com/video/quicktime3.html?v=clipweek25b
 

MIMIC

Banned
OMG! :lol :lol

From the Vote for the Worst website:

4/30/05
You may notice a lot of changes to the site. First, we've opened the Vote for the Worst store. Get yourself a t-shirt, bumper sticker, teddy bear, or a whole host of other items to show your feelings toward our site! Secondly, the media page has been turned into a page to track the press appearances of the website. It's pretty impressive how much we've been in the news! And lastly, we received a letter from Freemantle (the company that produces American Idol) to remove the audio, video, and pictures that they own. We're pretty sure that if we were an Idol fan site, we wouldn't have to do that. But it just means we need to vote even more for Scott this week. Miss the media? Well, help us vote for Scott and we can send our message to Simon and company this week! Don't worry, this site isn't going anywhere. Only idiots think that this site is illegal. Peace!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom