-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
American Idol: Season 4
- Thread starter MIMIC
- Start date
- Status
Unresponsive Bee Victim
Member
Man Fantasia made me wanna pull our my hair, she is awful, she sounded like a cat dying.
Vonzell's performance grated for me, Nikko bores me and Scott sucks ass. I like this Bottom 3...I'd put Federov over Vonzell by far, though.
After the first two, I saw it coming with the Rapid Fire Bottom Three. Scott deserves to go.
In other news, the production of thosse Ford commercials keeps getting better. And yeah, Carrie = teh hot in that thing.
After the first two, I saw it coming with the Rapid Fire Bottom Three. Scott deserves to go.
In other news, the production of thosse Ford commercials keeps getting better. And yeah, Carrie = teh hot in that thing.
Memles said:
You've got to be kidding me. Nikko has really comeback after his miserable performance that got him originally kicked off the show, and Vonzell...she and Carrie are the ONLY finalists who actually have outstanding, natural vocals.
Scott does not suck, although his recent performances have (which, ultimately, is why he needs to go).
Spectral Glider
Member
Who the flying fuck keeps voting for Anthony?
The Chosen One
Member
America Sucks
psycho_snake
I went to WAGs boutique and all I got was a sniff
I cant stand Anthony, if he gets any further then I will shoot myself in the foot, the pain will probably feel better then listening to him.
Im gonna disagree with you mimic, I liked John Stevens, I thought he was really good...but dont worry, I do agree with your comment about Carrie, she looks so damn sexy! Personally apart from her looks, I think she is one of the best singers left, as I said before, Bo and Carrie will be in the finals.
Im gonna disagree with you mimic, I liked John Stevens, I thought he was really good...but dont worry, I do agree with your comment about Carrie, she looks so damn sexy! Personally apart from her looks, I think she is one of the best singers left, as I said before, Bo and Carrie will be in the finals.
Can't hate...Anthony was actually pretty good this week.MIMIC said:
Fuck the hell off. That song was perfect. Fuck Country already...I'm tired of it. It's a boring ass genre in terms of song variety. She is immensely more ENTERTAINING when she sings Rock songs. And "Love is a Battlefield" is a classic. That was a really good song choice, because I didn't even consider surfing channels. And yeah...Carrie with straight hair is damn hot.
Bohemian Rhapsody...oh dear god, Constantine.
EDIT: He needs to sing songs where his voice doesn't matter more often. That was really quite good...he definitely stole the show from a standpoint of showmanship. Voice...uh no.
Vonzell - 9 (Perfect song)
Anthony - 6 (Sorry, he still can't really sing all that great. Inoffensive may seem good for him, but it's stiill dull as shit)
Scott - 5 (Sorry, Simon was right. Very simply, his verses were TERRIBLE. He can't just sing the chorus well and pretend he doesn't suck anymore. And, dude, it just looks awkward when he moves)
Bo - 7 (He's a good singer, and he has good stage presence...but he kind of bores me. He hasn't done anything REALLY energetic or interesting for me.
Anwar - 5 (I'm really sorry, dude, but you have the same problem as Scott. You sing verses almost under your own breath, and then pretend you're awesome in the chorus. Doesn't cut it. He can sing...once he decides to. It wasn't a five performance, but he's been doing the same thing for weeks now)
Carrie - 9 (Maybe it's my genuine appreciation of the song, how hot she was or just that it was an energetic, interesting performance, but this one really reached me. It was like her singing Heart, but with much better hair. She needs to do more of this, I think.)
Nadia - 6 (Poor song choice, but she's the only female left who can really just sit there are sing a song like that. In terms of ballads, she's the only one who can do one with Whitney Houstonin' it. (I'm looking at you, Vonzell))
Constantine - 8 (His voice was good for the song, he had genuine charisma, but I felt like he was fucking me...with his eyes. And that's all kinds of wrong. He needs to realize that males watch this show too.)
Top 3 - Carrie, Vonzell, Constanting
Bottom Three - Anwar, Scott, Anthony
Safe, but borderline boring - Bo and Nadia
Anthony - 6 (Sorry, he still can't really sing all that great. Inoffensive may seem good for him, but it's stiill dull as shit)
Scott - 5 (Sorry, Simon was right. Very simply, his verses were TERRIBLE. He can't just sing the chorus well and pretend he doesn't suck anymore. And, dude, it just looks awkward when he moves)
Bo - 7 (He's a good singer, and he has good stage presence...but he kind of bores me. He hasn't done anything REALLY energetic or interesting for me.
Anwar - 5 (I'm really sorry, dude, but you have the same problem as Scott. You sing verses almost under your own breath, and then pretend you're awesome in the chorus. Doesn't cut it. He can sing...once he decides to. It wasn't a five performance, but he's been doing the same thing for weeks now)
Carrie - 9 (Maybe it's my genuine appreciation of the song, how hot she was or just that it was an energetic, interesting performance, but this one really reached me. It was like her singing Heart, but with much better hair. She needs to do more of this, I think.)
Nadia - 6 (Poor song choice, but she's the only female left who can really just sit there are sing a song like that. In terms of ballads, she's the only one who can do one with Whitney Houstonin' it. (I'm looking at you, Vonzell))
Constantine - 8 (His voice was good for the song, he had genuine charisma, but I felt like he was fucking me...with his eyes. And that's all kinds of wrong. He needs to realize that males watch this show too.)
Top 3 - Carrie, Vonzell, Constanting
Bottom Three - Anwar, Scott, Anthony
Safe, but borderline boring - Bo and Nadia
Carrie looked pretty damn hot. Like a slutty, skinnier Kelly Clarkson. Her singing was average. That last note was brutal.
Top 2: Constatine and Vonzell.
Those in danger: Nadia (horrible song choice), Scott (first two verses were atrocious).
Hopefully, Scott goes home ... his homeboy attitude sucks.
Top 2: Constatine and Vonzell.
Those in danger: Nadia (horrible song choice), Scott (first two verses were atrocious).
Hopefully, Scott goes home ... his homeboy attitude sucks.
Spectral Glider
Member
Scott was like fingernails on a chalkboard bad. Terrible. Yet another week goes by where nobody jumps out and grabs the show. Everyone just seemed to hover around the OK mark.
krypt0nian
Banned
Memles said:
Its frightening how much I agree with you here.
Right now I say Constantine and Carrie for the finals.
Constantine fucking NAILED the first half of that song. And that is fucking impressive when you're singing Freddy Mercury. Definitely my favorite performance this week.
Was kinda funny hearing Bo cover Freebird....that backup band sounded so fucking lame where the solo shoulda kicked in :lol :lol
I thought Nadia was worse than Scott. Hope she gets the boot tomorrow.
Was kinda funny hearing Bo cover Freebird....that backup band sounded so fucking lame where the solo shoulda kicked in :lol :lol
I thought Nadia was worse than Scott. Hope she gets the boot tomorrow.
So who is safe so far? I had it on mute. I know Carrie, at the very least, is safe. Hopefully she sings more rock songs now.
The third member of the Bottom Three HAS to be shocker, considering that they didn't leave the shocking Bo freefall until the last. Constantine? Vonzell? Anthony/Nadia wouldn't be surprising in the least. I'm so confused as to why they announced Bo second...if they wanted a real shock, third would have made a lot more sense.
Nadia is gone...no question about it.
The third member of the Bottom Three HAS to be shocker, considering that they didn't leave the shocking Bo freefall until the last. Constantine? Vonzell? Anthony/Nadia wouldn't be surprising in the least. I'm so confused as to why they announced Bo second...if they wanted a real shock, third would have made a lot more sense.
Nadia is gone...no question about it.
FUCK THIS SHOW TO HERPES HELL!!!!!!!!!!!!
I'm so sick of the judges I don't know what to do....they have their fucking biases plain as day....Randy...i'm not even going to give him the time of day here....Paula...i'm sick of her fucking pussy-radar, this bitch just lets her over-the-hill boy crushes dictate her every praise. And Simon...i'm sure he's writing to a pro-Carrie blog right now...he clearly wants either her or one of "the rockers" to win. He's all about trends and where money can be made next. I wouldn't be surprised if he tries to make a country or rock version of his new "IL DIVO" concoction.
Fuckin' hypocrites....always knocking the "safe" songs, calling it boring and predictable...and Nadia has ALWAYS done the opposite of that...always took risk whether it be her song choice, her look, or both...damn producers just want the next winner to be white...yeah I said it, wanna fight about it?
Well, at least now i can stop giving a shit about the results show and watch Alias LIVE instead of taping it.
I'm so sick of the judges I don't know what to do....they have their fucking biases plain as day....Randy...i'm not even going to give him the time of day here....Paula...i'm sick of her fucking pussy-radar, this bitch just lets her over-the-hill boy crushes dictate her every praise. And Simon...i'm sure he's writing to a pro-Carrie blog right now...he clearly wants either her or one of "the rockers" to win. He's all about trends and where money can be made next. I wouldn't be surprised if he tries to make a country or rock version of his new "IL DIVO" concoction.
Fuckin' hypocrites....always knocking the "safe" songs, calling it boring and predictable...and Nadia has ALWAYS done the opposite of that...always took risk whether it be her song choice, her look, or both...damn producers just want the next winner to be white...yeah I said it, wanna fight about it?
Well, at least now i can stop giving a shit about the results show and watch Alias LIVE instead of taping it.
Every year this happens. Someone that is awesome leaves .. and worthless people like Joshua Gracin or that Opie looking kid from last year hangs around, because 13 yrs old sit and vote a million times.
Oh well, I guess it doesn't matter, Nadia wasn't going to win anyways ... It's good to see Bo getting a little taste of reality. He is getting lazy.
Oh well, I guess it doesn't matter, Nadia wasn't going to win anyways ... It's good to see Bo getting a little taste of reality. He is getting lazy.
Ninja Scooter
Member
dont underestimate the power of doing a Hall and Oates song.
The Chosen One
Member
Bah...
I don't even watch the show anymore. I just check this thread every week for the results. Disappointed is I.
I don't even watch the show anymore. I just check this thread every week for the results. Disappointed is I.
Spectral Glider
Member
Yeah, Nadia wasn't going to make it to the end, but she did go earlier than expected. Now, if Scott and Anthony survive past the next two weeks then there is something seriously wrong.
Ryan Seacrest on tonight's results show, speaking about the Tsunami Single: "We're going to celebrate death as a group".
I love it. It's very clear that these people can't play those instruments...only three of them did, and Bo sucked ass. At least when Canadian Idol did this they were generally able to play the instruments.
I love it. It's very clear that these people can't play those instruments...only three of them did, and Bo sucked ass. At least when Canadian Idol did this they were generally able to play the instruments.
- Status