Now that I'm home from work, I can explain my lucky situation.
Got to Meijers right at Midnight, there was only about 3 other guys (one being my Nintendo-obsessed co-worker), all the amiibo were on a pushcart. There was about....maybe 4 or 5 each, maybe 3 of Olimar (which I thankfully looked at, almost got one with a "freckle")? In any case, was easily able to nab Ganondorf, ZSS, Olimar, & 8-bit Mario, plus there was some kind of discount for college students (I think), so I got 10% off each one, saving me $5.
I'll check my Target around 4 p.m. after getting some sleep & picking up my copy of Super Mario Maker, then hoping to hear from my friend on Bowser Jr.