There's a lot of great wrestling throughout the indies, but booking is another matter - if you're looking for intricate, well booked storylines, they're in short supply at the moment. It's not like 2003-2006 when Gabe was kicking ass as booker for ROH. A lot of his recent stuff for DGUSA & EVOLVE has fallen flat, imo. CHIKARA do long-term stuff really well, but the problem is that, sometimes, the storyline doesn't always seem that great while it's occurring. ROH have a nice storyline going at the moment which seems to be leading to the redemption of Kevin Steen, but it'll take time to see if Delirious can sustain the current good booking for any length of time. PWG are much more storyline-light, but make up for it with a kick-ass in-ring product.
I always get the feeling that Gabe is limited by what he can do with talent from Japan, and with Japan taking his USA talent so he can't really do anything long term with anyone. Chikara hasn't been that great in the storyline department for a while now....honestly since their first PPV it has been kinda dragging.
As I said on the last page, the only company that really seems to be trying with big storylines right now is TNA. Whether you like them or not, they always have a storyline going behind their wrestling, and Bishoff and Co. usually have it planned out for months.