I guess while everyone's chiming in with their What-I-Want-Out-Of-Wrestling dreams, I'll post mine:
Basically, wrestling just needs two things to be successful: characters and stories. That's it!
The two go hand-in-hand, and when both work harmoniously, magical things happen. No, not magic like
Mordecai. But you, uh, get the point. You don't? OK, analogy time:
To me, wrestling is lot like comics -- you pick your favorite character and want to see them beat up bad guys. Take Superman for instance -- guy is pretty cool, right? Strongest man in the world. Can leap tall buildings and all that jazz. It's fucking awesome watching him beat the shit out of dudes. But the problem with Superman is he's almost too powerful. If no one can beat him, why continue reading? Case in point: Cena, Rey, Orton, etc.
But does that mean there's no good Superman stories? Hell no! Some of the best comics I read have been Superman books (Superman: Secret Identity and All-Star Superman). But the key to success is this: the interesting character needs an interesting STORY. Easy as that. The best comics are the ones where the reader ACTUALLY THINKS their favorite hero might get defeated. You watch WWE now and there's not a whole lot of unpredictability (well, aside from the random depushes some guys get). It's too cookie-cutter. They need to think outside the box. Try new things. When I say that, I mean it's OK for Cena/Rey/Orton to lose big feuds. Because, to me, the best story is the hero coming back for redemption.
So yeah, that's the problem with the WWE right now. They either have A) Interesting characters stuck in uninteresting/predictable stories or worse, B) UNINTERESTING characters stuck in UNINTERESTING stories.
And Vince is a creativity-killer. The dude is so afraid to hurt the status quo that he's keeping anything interesting from happening.
What was everyone's favorite angle of last year? Nexus invading. Why? Because it was a GOOD story. Dudes coming back for revenge, tearing shit up, beating everyone up. But, of course, they couldn't keep interesting. And now we're stuck with option B) Uninteresting characters stuck in uninteresting stories. LOL.