Support NeoGAF

[Hobohodo]

Of course, if he was town Squidy wouldn't wanna use his ability unless separated from the cop as it would screm over the cop as well, so waiting to be separated there could be seen as pretty pro town as well.

 

[cabot]

I think squidy is town, I think Ezekel is town.

Let's burn Mike, let QB go for one of the other suspicious people.

Yeeny hasn't shagged me and I have no problem with that.

 

[cabot]

I'll update my scum list with QB's claim, which currently I believe:

Scum list in order of preference:

Mike
Hobo
Septimus
Mazre
Quantum

Yes, I still think there's a chance that Mazre could be a ISIS flagged KGB.

Why? Because he's still as suspicious to me as he was before Darryl 'confirmed' him, and possible hints of a mission leak would point in his direction if he was KGB.

I'm going to try and look for clues to support the mole theory.

 

[Mike_Hawk689]

If you all believe that I'm the last kgb, why not let me live this night and have YNNNY block me tonight. That way you guys will have another person to lynch. Killing me will only give you information that has already been post by ouro on post #2. Plus you wont be able to clear YNNNY with my death.

 

[cabot]

these are the people i blocked:
N1 - Haly (no death)
N2 - Seath
N3 - MikeHawk (no death)
N4 - MikeHawk (death inside mission + squidy used ability)
N5 - MikeHawk (no death)

the evidence is already there, friend. I trust Yeeny, I don't trust you.

 

[Palmer_v1]

Vote: Mike_Hawk

He's by far the most logical choice today. Killing him might just end the game. If so, my MVP will be YesNo cause she was on point with her blocks.

If he flips town, we have more to worry about. YesNo could be playing us or we could just be wrong about why people haven't been dying.

BTW, we're at a point now where role claiming is probably okay if it will give us any extra info. Particularly if you are able to refute either YesNo or Squidyj's claims.

After today, I think we have to consider lynching QB to help verify Squidyj and Krisstoffer. We still can't entirely trust anything QB has said or done, since it's in his interest to stay alive by keeping us happy. If I were him, I would happily pretend to target who you want, while continuing to follow my own game plan. We have no way to verify anything he does.

I have no idea why anyone wants to pursue this double agent angle. I really don't think Mafia would have two roles that do the same thing. If you're really concerned, just keep Mazre, ER, and myself on the mission. I'll even volunteer.

Volunteer

I'm more concerned about a Switcher, but even that seems like a remote chance.

 

[cabot]

If you all believe that I'm the last kgb, why not let me live this night and have YNNNY block me tonight.

I didn't think you were the last, but the fact you've raised this is interesting. Was that a slip?

 

[cabot]

After today, I think we have to consider lynching QB to help verify Squidyj and Krisstoffer. We still can't entirely trust anything QB has said or done, since it's in his interest to stay alive by keeping us happy. If I were him, I would happily pretend to target who you want, while continuing to follow my own game plan. We have no way to verify anything he does.

Yes, I too believe lynching QB tomorrow is a very good shout. If he has the potential to clear two people, that makes it a good solid choice

 

[cabot]

The only question mark I have now is why did Topo's kill fail on roy on N1?

Could that have been a PR or was there some miss chance in his role. I know his PM mentions missing as an option but it's pretty vague.

Or did squidy do something n1

 

[Mike_Hawk689]

I didn't think you were the last, but the fact you've raised this is interesting. Was that a slip?

No slip, being completely honest amd working with the assumption that there is either 1 or 2 left.

 

[Mike_Hawk689]

The only question mark I have now is why did Topo's kill fail on roy on N1?

Could that have been a PR or was there some miss chance in his role. I know his PM mentions missing as an option but it's pretty vague.

Or did squidy do something n1

We know theres a role blocker, YNNNY. She who claims that she blocked Haly N1. But actually lying amd blocked Topo?

 

[Palmer_v1]

Here's the current player list, and how everyone stands in my mind.

TheGoddamn - Cleared by Darryl, but he could still be neutral depending on how Darryl's role worked. I need to go back and check.
Arkos - Not HP, Cleared by Ouro
cooljeanius Replaced by [m] Kristoffer - Cleared by Quantumbro
Septimus Prime - ???
cabbeh - Not HP, Cleared by Ouro
Mike_Hawk689 - Accused by YesNo
Enker - ???
EzekelRAGE - Cleared by Darryl and other supporting evidence
YesNOnoNOYes - Accusing Mike
Quantumbro - Claiming Neutral
Palmer_v1 - Not Honeypot, ???
Hobohodo - ???
Mazre - Not HP, Cleared by Darryl
squidyj - Not HP, Cleared by Quantumbro

Of those, this is the pool of players to be concerned about for now:

Septimus Prime - ???
Enker - ???
Palmer_v1 - Not Honeypot, ???
Hobohodo - ???
Mike_Hawk689 - Accused by YesNo
YesNOnoNOYes - Accusing Mike
Quantumbro - Claiming Neutral

 

[Ourobolus]

Here's the current player list, and how everyone stands in my mind.
Arkos - Not HP, Cleared by Ouro
cabbeh - Not HP, Cleared by Ouro

;_;

 

[cabot]

;_;

I love you.

 

[Palmer_v1]

The only question mark I have now is why did Topo's kill fail on roy on N1?

Could that have been a PR or was there some miss chance in his role. I know his PM mentions missing as an option but it's pretty vague.

Or did squidy do something n1

I need to double check, but could Roy protect himself? Generally, if you can self protect, you always do N1.

 

[Mike_Hawk689]

I need to double check, but could Roy protect himself? Generally, if you can self protect, you always do N1.

Pm role said no self protect for any of the krigers

 

[cabot]

You are Krieger #2, the “Clone of Hitler.”

You are aligned with ISIS (the agency, not the terrorist organization).

Sure, you’re not the REAL Krieger (or are you?), but with bowtie in hand you can bring just as much damage help to people that need it. As you don’t want to freak everybody out, you will be unable to perform any actions other than voting until the real Krieger is killed. Once that happens, your role as “Doctor” will be active, and each night you may PM me the command PROTECT: <player> to rescue someone (except yourself) from being assassinated. Your target will not be notified of this action, and you will not receive notification whether or not you are successful.

You win when all KGB players are eliminated.

Feel free to PM me any questions about your role. The public game thread is here.

Yup, definitely couldn't protect himself. Still an open issue

 

[Palmer_v1]

@ouRO:

Can you confirm part of Darryl's role for me?


"Despite Sterling Archer stealing your thunder in the hearts and minds of the enemy, you know you’re the best and brightest secret agent of them all. Every night phase, you may use the ISIS database to investigate one player by PMing the command “SNOOP: <player>” to me. The results will be returned to you at the start of the next day phase, showing you that player’s alignment."

So if Darryl investigated a Neutral player, he would know they were Neutral right?

 

[Ourobolus]

@ouRO:

Can you confirm part of Darryl's role for me?


"Despite Sterling Archer stealing your thunder in the hearts and minds of the enemy, you know you’re the best and brightest secret agent of them all. Every night phase, you may use the ISIS database to investigate one player by PMing the command “SNOOP: <player>” to me. The results will be returned to you at the start of the next day phase, showing you that player’s alignment."

So if Darryl investigated a Neutral player, he would know they were Neutral right?

Yes, he would receive the alignment no matter what it was.

 

[Palmer_v1]

Yes, he would receive the alignment no matter what it was.

Thanks.

 

[cabot]

So that's TheG cleared then.

 

[Palmer_v1]

I've exhausted everything I intend to do for today. I'll respond to other posts if needed, but I'm alright with ending the day and seeing how the chips fall.

 

[Ourobolus]

So that's TheG cleared then.

?

 

[YesNOnoNOYes]

hoooow did roy not die on N1 continues to boggle my mind toooo... i know one thing: i blocked haly. then im told 2 additional info: topopi attacked roy but failed AND ....ER has received a message that he was attacked, but he had survived cuz he bp ( except by honipot)

i haaaave no idea what happened but no death!!! yey

o btw im not opposed to sitting on mike or to get lynched or whatever. im here to cooperate and make good from my horrible read on gorlakie yesterday. just let me know what Agency wants and im on board ^____^

 

[cabot]

?

TheGoddamn - Cleared by Darryl, but he could still be neutral depending on how Darryl's role worked. I need to go back and check.

Are you moderator, or collaborator!

 

[YesNOnoNOYes]

;_;

sooooo cute amg *____*

 

[Ourobolus]

Are you moderator, or collaborator!

I'm just not following the logic.

Anyway, carry on!

 

[Mike_Hawk689]

hoooow did roy not die on N1 continues to boggle my mind toooo... i know one thing: i blocked haly. then im told 2 additional info: topopi attacked roy but failed AND ....ER has received a message that he was attacked, but he had survived cuz he bp ( except by honipot)

i haaaave no idea what happened but no death!!! yey

o btw im not opposed to sitting on mike or to get lynched or whatever. im here to cooperate and make good from my horrible read on gorlakie yesterday. just let me know what Agency wants and im on board ^____^

Heuheuheu

 

[Palmer_v1]

Squidyj using his ability N1 would explain no deaths, but it refutes ER's claim. Maybe that's why he's still suspicious of him?

 

[Palmer_v1]

I'm just not following the logic.

Anyway, carry on!

Darryl claimed to have cleared TheGoddamn. Depending on the type of Cop, that might only mean that he's not Mafia. Your confirmation means that he would have to be town based on Darryl's report.

 

[Ourobolus]

Darryl claimed to have cleared TheGoddamn. Depending on the type of Cop, that might only mean that he's not Mafia. Your confirmation means that he would have to be town based on Darryl's report.

Ah, I gotcha. Yes, it would have specifically stated ISIS/KGB/unaligned.

 

[Sorian]

YNNNY being the sex addict is probably the best joke material this whole season.

Edit: I am neither confirming nor denying her claim of course since I have no clue, I just find the circumstance funny.

 

[Palmer_v1]

YNNNY being the sex addict is probably the best joke material this whole season.

Edit: I am neither confirming nor denying her claim of course since I have no clue, I just find the circumstance funny.

Her target of choice has added another level of immature humor to it as well.

 

[Hobohodo]

Squidyj using his ability N1 would explain no deaths, but it refutes ER's claim. Maybe that's why he's still suspicious of him?

Wouldn't that result in the death of Squidy though? Or did I miss something in his role description.

 

[Palmer_v1]

Wouldn't that result in the death of Squidy though? Or did I miss something in his role description.

If Roy protected someone, and I bet he did, that would also have been redirected to Squidyj.

 

[Hobohodo]

If Roy protected someone, and I bet he did, that would also have been redirected to Squidyj.

Oh of course, had so much of this game without doctors that I'd forgotten clean about them.

Hmm...

 

[Spoiled Milk]

Squidyj using his ability N1 would explain no deaths, but it refutes ER's claim. Maybe that's why he's still suspicious of him?

But refuting Ezekel's claim would refute Quantum's claim! What a mess that would be, hmm?

 

[Spoiled Milk]

I would like to point out that MikeHawk is acting in the same detached, aloof way that Haly was when he was about to be lynched.

 

[Ourobolus]

Can I join this game? NX is ridiculous.

 

[Palmer_v1]

Can I join this game? NX is ridiculous.

Becky: Ourobolus

 

[Spoiled Milk]

VOLUNTEER

Palmer, what did Ezekel role claim in private with you?

 

[Palmer_v1]

VOLUNTEER

Palmer, what did Ezekel role claim in private with you?

He's been consistent in Mission chats with what he's said in this thread.

 

[Spoiled Milk]

He's been consistent in Mission chats with what he's said in this thread.

Yes, he was consistent last night, too. TG and QB can verify this.

 

[Spoiled Milk]

I think one of the best scumtells is when someone changes their story, even if only slightly, over the course of a game. In fact, modifying your story only slightly to account for changing circumstances or increasing pressure instead of revealing you have been witholding major information for the greater good is really suspicious, so those are the people I would look for.

But Ezekel has been cleared by the cop and has been stalwart in his story so I think he's okay. We should focus on MikeHawk, and maybe look into Hobohodo more.

 

[Palmer_v1]

I think one of the best scumtells is when someone changes their story, even if only slightly, over the course of a game. In fact, modifying your story only slightly to account for changing circumstances or increasing pressure instead of revealing you have been witholding major information for the greater good is really suspicious, so those are the people I would look for.

But Ezekel has been cleared by the cop and has been stalwart in his story so I think he's okay. We should focus on MikeHawk, and maybe look into Hobohodo more.

Barring new evidence from someone, Mike is the most logical lynch by a large margin.

 

[EzekelRAGE]

Top one are known factors

This one includes theories. Added the QB claim/clears and YN claims to squid/arkos/cabbeh

 

[cabot]

Hey guys, I've got some confidence again.

VOTE: Mike_Hawk689

let's smash it before I do something outrageous like ask a girl out!

 

[Palmer_v1]

Hey guys, I've got some confidence again.

VOTE: Mike_Hawk689

let's smash it before I do something outrageous like ask a girl out!

Or eat a pot brownie.

 

[Spoiled Milk]

QB did not target me last night. I would have known.

Barring new evidence from someone, Mike is the most logical lynch by a large margin.

 

[Palmer_v1]

Top one are known factors

This one includes theories. Added the QB claim/clears and YN claims to squid/arkos/cabbeh

You've done something wrong on the bottom if you have me cleared.